10 reactions to Claudine Gay’s sudden resignation as Harvard president
Harvard President Claudine Gay's resignation and subsequent echoes across the political aisle
BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS: In the hallowed halls of Harvard, a storm brewed as the sudden resignation of President Claudine Gay sent shockwaves through the academic community and beyond. Gay's decision, announced on Tuesday afternoon, January 2, marked a critical moment in the university's history, prompting a cascade of reactions from various corners. The controversy unfolded against a backdrop of allegations ranging from a tepid response to antisemitism in a congressional hearing to accusations of plagiarism in her scholarly work. The ensuing debate not only questioned the leadership of one of the world's most prestigious institutions but also highlighted broader issues related to diversity, equity, and inclusion. Following are the reactions to Gay's sudden exit from Harvard:
Christopher Rufo
Claudine Gay's resignation letter framed the decision as being in the "best interests of Harvard" to allow the community to navigate a moment of "extraordinary challenge." However, conservative activist Christopher Rufo, who had earlier raised allegations of plagiarism, lambasted Gay's letter on X, asserting, "Rather than take responsibility for minimizing antisemitism, committing serial plagiarism, intimidating the free press, and damaging the institution, she calls her critics racist. This is the poison of DEI ideology. Glad she's gone."
Vivek Ramaswamy
Reflecting on the past selection process for Harvard's president, Vivek Ramaswamy called for a future approach based on "merit." "Back in 2006, I was one of 3 students appointed to the advisory board to select Harvard’s new President in 2007 after Larry Summers was forced to resign after his supposedly 'misogynistic' comments (which were badly distorted). Back then, it was a foreordained conclusion that the next President would be a woman, no questions asked - shut up, sit down, do as you’re told. And it was a thinly veiled exercise in race & gender when they selected Claudine Gay. Here’s a radical idea for the future: select leadership based on *merit.* It’s a great approach, actually,” wrote Ramaswamy.
Bill Ackman
Expressing disappointment in those defending Gay, Bill Ackman questioned the basis for supporting her presidency. "I am not right wing. I operate only in good faith, and am I am not a bully. I just pay attention to the facts and see where they take me. And Harvard didn’t roll over if you have been paying attention. She had the board’s publicly stated unanimous support only two or so weeks ago," he wrote. "It is sad that you see the world in such a way that those you disagree with must somehow be right wing and/or operating in bad faith. I find it hard to understand how one could conclude that Claudine Gay should have remained President of Harvard. What is the basis for your support for Gay? That calling for the genocide of the Jews is not bullying or harassment? Please explain," Ackman added.
Carol Swain
Conservative author Carol Swain, who accused Gay of plagiarizing from her work, raised a crucial question, asking on X why it took "Harvard University and Ms. Gay so long to do the right thing for the good of the nation."
Elon Musk
Billionaire Elon Musk endorsed the idea that Gay's resignation gained momentum due to its amplification on the X platform. Musk, who had supported Ackman's plea last month for Gay to "resign in disgrace," replied to a user's post, stating, "True. This story would otherwise have been buried and forgotten."
Elise Stefanik
House Republican Conference Chairwoman Rep Elise Stefanik praised Gay's decision, linking it to allegations of plagiarism and an inadequate response to antisemitism. "Two down," Stefanik said in a statement. "Harvard knows that this long overdue forced resignation of the antisemitic plagiarist president is just the beginning of what will be the greatest scandal of any college or university in history."
Kari Lake
Kari Lake, a Republican running for Senate in Arizona, credited Congresswoman Elise Stefanik for the president's departure, acknowledging Stefanik's tenacity. Lake stated, "This would not have happened without the tenacity of Congresswoman Elise Stefanik. Thank you for exposing the rot on college campuses."
Al Sharpton
Of course, not all reactions were celebratory. Civil rights activist Rev Al Sharpton expressed outrage, characterizing Gay's resignation "as an attack on every Black woman in the country" who has shattered the glass ceiling. Sharpton also vowed to picket outside Harvard alum Bill Ackman's office, challenging Ackman's accusation that Gay was merely a diversity, equity, and inclusion hire. "If he doesn’t think Black Americans belong in the C-Suite, the Ivy League or any other hallowed halls, we’ll make ourselves at home outside his office,” Sharpton declared.
Janai Nelson
Janai Nelson, president and director counsel of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, offered a cautionary perspective, criticizing the attacks against Gay as "unrelenting" and warning against dangerous precedents in the academy for political witch hunts. “Attacks against Claudine Gay have been unrelenting & the biases unmasked,” Nelson said. “Her resignation on the heels of Liz Magill’s [at UPenn] set dangerous precedent in the academy for political witch hunts. The project isn’t to thwart hate but to foment it thru vicious takedowns. This protects no one.”
Ibram X Kendi
Ibram X Kendi, founder of the Center for Antiracist Research at Boston University, highlighted the racial undertones. Kendi wrote on X, "Racist mobs won't stop until they topple all Black people from positions of power and influence who are not reinforcing the structure of racism." Kendi also questioned whether the response would be the same if the Harvard president were White, stating, "The question is whether all these people would have investigated, surveilled, harassed, written about, and attacked her in the same way if the Harvard president in this case would have been White." He added, "I. Think. Not."
