Caught in 4K: GOP senator peeks at opponent's answer, copies it in hilarious debate moment

The viral debate moment added another unusual chapter to Alaska's Senate race, where two candidates named Dan Sullivan are on the ballot
Sen Dan Sullivan drew laughter after appearing to check Mary Peltola's answer before raising the same paddle during an Alaska debate (@MaryPeltola/X)
Sen Dan Sullivan drew laughter after appearing to check Mary Peltola's answer before raising the same paddle during an Alaska debate (@MaryPeltola/X)

KODIAK, ALASKA: Republican Sen Dan Sullivan appeared to look at Democratic challenger Mary Peltola's answer before giving the same response during a lightning-round debate in Kodiak, Alaska.

The exchange drew laughter from the audience and was later shared online by Peltola on Saturday, September 12, who wrote, "Happy to help, Dan."



Question puts Dan Sullivan on the spot

The moment came during a debate focused on Alaska's fishing industry.

Candidates were given paddles to display their answers to a series of yes-or-no questions.

A moderator asked whether the North Pacific Fishery Management Council and NOAA Fisheries adequately consider the effects of their decisions on subsistence users, salmon migration, habitat, and Indigenous ways of life.

Sen. Dan Sullivan (R-AK) speaks as United States Northern Command and North American Aerospace Defense Command (USNORTHCOM) Commander Gen. Gregory Guillot, Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Homeland Defense and Americas Security Affairs Mark Ditlevson, and Department of War Principal Deputy General Counsel Charles Young III, appear at a Senate Committee on Armed Services hearing on Capitol Hill on December 11, 2025 in Washington, DC.
Candidates used paddles to answer yes-or-no questions during the debate on Alaska's fishing industry (Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)

Peltola quickly raised a paddle marked "No."

Sullivan, meanwhile, had his head down and appeared to be looking through papers when the question was asked.

A moderator then called on the senator to answer.

Sullivan put down his papers and looked up as the moderator again asked him to respond with either yes or no.

Senator checks opponent's response

Before raising his paddle, Sullivan turned toward Peltola and appeared to look at her answer.

He then held up his own paddle showing the same response: "No." 

ANCHORAGE, ALASKA - NOVEMBER 08: Rep. Mary Peltola (D-AK) speaks to supporters at a watch party on November 08, 2022 in Anchorage, Alaska. Rep. Mary Peltola (D-AK) is running against former Republican Gov. Sarah Palin and others in Alaska's at-large congressional district. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
Sullivan appeared to look toward Peltola before raising a paddle with the same response (Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

The audience immediately laughed at the exchange.

Sullivan smiled and said, "Sorry," as the debate continued.

The brief moment was later posted by Peltola on X, where she directly addressed her Republican opponent.

"Happy to help, Dan," Peltola wrote alongside the video. "Alaskans deserve a senator who knows where they stand."

The clip showed the candidates standing beside each other during the lightning round, with Sullivan initially focused on documents before being prompted to answer.

Mary Peltola seizes on viral clip

Peltola's campaign used the exchange to highlight the difference between the two candidates in the Senate race.

Her post quickly drew attention to Sullivan's response during the debate. 

WASHINGTON, DC - SEPTEMBER 13:  U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) (L) participates in a ceremon
Peltola later shared the debate exchange on social media and addressed Sullivan directly (Getty Images)

The candidates had been discussing issues affecting Alaska's fishing communities when the moment occurred.

The North Pacific Fishery Management Council and NOAA Fisheries play major roles in managing fisheries and marine resources that are important to communities across the state.

Sullivan's answer matched Peltola's position on the specific question, though the senator did not offer an explanation during the lightning round before the debate moved on.

Race already has two Dans

The incident adds to the unusual circumstances surrounding Alaska's Senate contest.

Sullivan is seeking another term against Peltola, a former US representative, and Dan J Sullivan, a retired teacher from Petersburg who shares the incumbent's name.

(Sullivan for US Senate, Brandon Bell-Pool/Getty Images)
Alaska's Senate ballot includes two candidates with variations of the name Dan Sullivan (Sullivan for US Senate, Brandon Bell-Pool/Getty Images)

Dan J Sullivan successfully fought to remain on the ballot after Alaska election officials initially questioned whether his candidacy could confuse voters.

The state Supreme Court ultimately allowed him to continue, and he advanced through Alaska's August primary to the general election.

The incumbent appears on the ballot as Dan S Sullivan, while his namesake challenger is listed as Daniel J Sullivan Jr.

An unusual race gets stranger

The three-way contest is taking place under Alaska's ranked-choice voting system and has drawn national attention as Democrats target the Republican-held seat.

Peltola led the Senate primary, with Sen Sullivan finishing behind her and his namesake also advancing to November, according to reported election results.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Trump said Iran was calling for a deal but also raised the possibility of staying and keeping its oil, drawing a comparison to Venezuela
5 minutes ago
Texas Republican Ted Cruz appeared on ESPN’s 'College GameDay' to discuss the Protect College Sports Act
34 minutes ago
Trump responded after UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham said a border poll would require clear public support
1 hour ago
Trump also claimed NBC wanted to give him a five-year extension and 'would have paid me anything' to stay with 'The Apprentice'
10 hours ago
Despite dismissing the press secretary speculation, JD Vance praised Maria Bartiromo as 'an amazing person' and 'an amazing talent'
11 hours ago
Brendan Carr defended the FCC’s interpretation of the equal-time rule, while James Talarico and Jimmy Kimmel pushed back
11 hours ago
Ted Cruz faced repeated booing from the crowd when he appeared on ESPN's 'College GameDay' to promote the Protect College Sports Act
11 hours ago
Donald Trump said Canada is eager to strike a new trade agreement and urged Ottawa to lower tariffs on American farmers, hinting at a deal soon
14 hours ago
President Trump questioned US support for NATO after recalling the alliance's refusal to help during the Iran conflict
18 hours ago
A federal judge ruled against the Trump administration after deleted Signal messages obscured the origins of a proposed FEMA workforce cut
19 hours ago