Nancy Guthrie probe hit by critical early error as officers assumed she ‘wandered off’: Source

A source claimed that those leading the investigation, including a supervisor, lacked sufficient homicide investigation experience
More than 60 days have passed since 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie disappeared from her home in Tucson’s Catalina Foothills during the early hours of February 1 (@savannahguthrie/Instagram)
More than 60 days have passed since 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie disappeared from her home in Tucson’s Catalina Foothills during the early hours of February 1 (@savannahguthrie/Instagram)

SCOTTSDALE, ARIZONA: The investigation into the missing case of a popular news host, Savannah Guthrie’s mother, Nancy Guthrie, barely seems to have moved forward, even after over 60 days of her disappearance. While investigators believe that she was abducted, there has been no breakthrough in the case.

Nancy Guthrie disappeared from her home in Tucson’s Catalina Foothills in the early morning hours of February 1.

Early errors led probe in wrong direction

Investigators present at the crime scene during the early investigation reportedly took a critical misstep by treating the matter as a case of an old lady who wandered off rather than pursuing it with a criminal angle, revealed a source familiar with the investigation to New Nation’s senior national correspondent Brian Entin.

(FBI)
FBI video showed a masked man captured near Nancy Guthrie's home(FBI)

“Speaking with some people that actually know the intimate knowledge of this investigation, told me that there was a rush to judgment of what was happening at that scene, and it was that Nancy had somehow wandered off," the source told Entin.

The source revealed that investigators made a judgment in the early days of the probe that it was a missing and rescue case and pursued the case with the same lens instead of treating it as an abduction case, leaving the case hanging in balance.

Probe by inexperienced officials: alleges source

Besides the probe team investigating the wrong angle, the relatively less experienced officials leading the case have also raised concerns.

The officers at the scene "were not tenured homicide detectives" and "didn't have a lot of experience in homicide at that point, to include the supervisor, who, from my understanding, never investigated a homicide before being installed as the supervisor of the homicide unit,” the source said.

Department’s morale ‘extremely low’

The source, who provided inside information to a new outlet's correspondent, said that the probe team’s morale around Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos was ‘extremely low’ and there was no name in the case despite months of investigation.

The informer further added that the probe team was only pursuing the case because there are people who want to bring Nancy home safely.

(@savannahguthrie/Facebook)
Savannah Guthrie's mother, Nancy, went missing on Feb 1 (@savannahguthrie/Facebook)

"Just because we have an incompetent lead doesn't mean that we don't care… that we don't want Nancy to be brought home safely and that we're not with her in this. We are completely with her and her family on this," the source was quoted as saying in the report.

Speaking on Sean Hannity’s program, legal commentator and true crime broadcaster Nancy Grace strongly criticized the investigation and called for the sheriff to resign.

“By destroying the crime scene and by releasing the crime scene too early, they destroyed a lot of evidence,” she said.

RELATED TOPICS DISAPPEARANCE OF NANCY GUTHRIE

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'No treatment aside from supportive care had any chance for success,' said Dr Mike Wenninger, the director of animal health at the Cincinnati Zoo
2026-11-21T04:17:55.000Z
Campaign for Accountability filed a complaint against Katie Zacharia after Donald Trump introduced her as an attorney during her five-day White House stint
2026-11-21T02:26:34.000Z
Patrick argues that these warnings should have alerted the providers to the danger and prompted them to take action
2026-11-20T21:12:52.000Z
The president appeared to announce the proposed measure without first briefing his own administration
2026-11-20T20:03:04.000Z
Trump said Nvidia should give Huang another opportunity, describing him as a valuable figure whose expertise was too important for the United States to lose
2026-11-20T19:28:27.000Z
The Fox Business interview comes as Melania Trump takes on a more visible role in a new docuseries released on November 20
2026-11-20T17:49:47.000Z
Huang allegedly told one subordinate that their mother should have aborted them
2026-11-20T16:06:58.000Z
The two-part series follows the first lady's previous documentary, 'Melania', released in January
2026-11-20T08:31:07.000Z
Sheriff Chad Chronister said a 911 call captured a child pleading with his father not to shoot before another gunshot was heard
2026-11-20T06:28:33.000Z
'Despite multiple attempts to move the hat out of her system, it was ultimately too much to overcome,' the zoo said in a statement
2026-11-20T05:41:41.000Z