‘Predetermined outcomes’: Trump admin accused of politicizing Ivy League antisemitism probes

Haley Van Erem alleges some university investigations lacked evidence of Title VI violations and were steered toward settlements
A former Justice Department lawyer raised concerns about the handling of university antisemitism investigations (Getty Images)
A former Justice Department lawyer raised concerns about the handling of university antisemitism investigations (Getty Images)

WASHINGTON, DC: A former Justice Department lawyer has accused the Trump administration of pressuring investigators to pursue settlements with Ivy League universities as part of its efforts to address allegations of antisemitism on college campuses.

The whistleblower complaint alleges that some investigations were rushed, lacked sufficient evidence of legal violations and were driven by predetermined outcomes. The Justice Department has rejected the allegations, saying it “stands behind the integrity of these investigations.” The disclosure involves investigations into Harvard University, Columbia University and Brown University. 

Whistleblower alleges investigators were pushed toward university settlements

The complaint was filed by lawyers representing Haley Van Erem, a former DOJ attorney who had worked in the department’s Civil Rights Division for nearly a decade before being involuntarily assigned to HHS to work on Title VI investigations involving universities.

Students attending Brown University walk through the main campus in Providence, Rhode Island (Robert Nickelsberg/Getty Images)
Students attending Brown University walked through the main campus in Providence, Rhode Island (Robert Nickelsberg/Getty Images)

The disclosure, filed with inspectors general at the Justice Department and HHS, as well as the Office of Special Counsel, alleges that the investigations were conducted with outcomes already in mind.

According to the complaint, the investigations were marked by “extraordinary procedural irregularities” and “predetermined outcomes without factual or legal support.” The lawyers described the effort as a “politically mandated effort” to pressure universities into settlements and use funding restrictions as leverage.

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - APRIL 29: Students/demonstrators lock arms to guard potential authorities against reaching fellow protestors who barricaded themselves inside Hamilton Hall, an academic building which has been occupied in past student movements,, and name it after a Palestinian child allegedly killed by the Israeli military on Tuesday, April 30, 2024 in New York City. Pro-Palestinian demonstrators marched around the
 Student demonstrators locked arms while guarding fellow protesters inside Hamilton Hall in New York City on April 30, 2024 (Alex Kent/Getty Images)

The complaint says Daniel Shieh, an associate deputy director in HHS’ Office for Civil Rights, acknowledged that investigators had not established a Title VI violation at Brown. Despite that, the complaint alleges Shieh said officials would not approve a finding clearing the university.

“Shieh admitted that there was ‘not a Title VI violation’ at Brown but said that ‘there’s no way we’re going to get a letter of no violation cleared,’” the complaint states.

Brown ultimately agreed to a $50 million settlement with the administration, while Columbia agreed to a $200 million agreement restoring access to federal funding. Neither settlement included an admission of wrongdoing.

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - APRIL 24: Student demonstrators occupy the pro-Palestinian
Student demonstrators occupied the pro-Palestinian Gaza Solidarity Encampment at Columbia University on April 24, 2024 (Michael M Santiago/Getty Images)

Whistleblower raises concerns over Harvard antisemitism probe

The complaint also raises concerns about the handling of the Harvard investigation, alleging that officials discussed funding freezes and proposed settlement terms before investigators had established potential Title VI violations.

The disclosure further alleges that investigators were directed to interview Middle East Studies professors, including Muslim faculty members, in circumstances the whistleblower believed were not tied to specific allegations of antisemitism. Van Erem said she was concerned the interviews could be used to elicit statements that officials could characterize as antisemitic.

(Harvard College PSC)
A group of students protested inside Harvard University (Harvard College PSC)

The complaint says Van Erem left the Justice Department in May 2025 because she was “unwilling to be made vulnerable to further participation in politically motivated investigations unsupported by facts and contrary to law.”

Rep Jamie Raskin, the top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee, separately cited the allegations in a letter to Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights Harmeet Dhillon, calling the investigations a “fake, a pre-baked frame-up operation thoroughly political in nature,” adding that "the whole project was designed ... to curtail their freedom of speech and academic freedom.”



The DOJ disputed Van Erem’s account, saying, “While at the DOJ, Ms. Haley Van Erem did not work on university investigations. And for all matters, the Department stands behind the integrity of these investigations.”

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Republicans warned Trump's energy deal could fund Russia's war in Ukraine, with Senator John Cornyn calling the move a mistake
2026-11-20T02:25:50.000Z
Elon Musk distanced himself from MAGA, and said pouring millions of dollars into the GOP midterm campaign was a 'pretty foolish' decision
2026-11-19T20:59:06.000Z
In an unusual outreach across party lines, potential GOP presidential nominee for 2028 Texas Sen. Ted Cruz said he would be willing to work with Sen.-elect James Talarico
2026-11-19T19:08:52.000Z
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin was barred from TV appearances and placed in a 'primetime timeout' after remarks on recent outages
2026-11-19T18:27:07.000Z
President Donald Trump expressed his displeasure over the failed Iran deal negotiated by JD Vance, adding to the growing tensions between the president and his deputy
2026-11-19T15:46:10.000Z
Donald Trump dismissed concerns over the truth behind US tech outages, saying they were isolated incidents linked to new equipment
2026-11-19T06:00:56.000Z
As per sources, Trump also privately praised Marco Rubio and suggested that the secretary of state could be a strong Republican presidential candidate in 2028
2026-11-19T05:15:11.000Z
Elon Musk said he felt 'pretty foolish' about his Republican campaign spending, admitting money alone could not win elections
2026-11-19T03:36:56.000Z
The incoming House Oversight Committee chairman sent document preservation notices to 12 people close to Trump, including his sons, Vice President JD Vance, and senior administration officials
2026-11-19T03:28:25.000Z
Relatives of former President John F Kennedy and military veterans have filed lawsuits seeking to block construction of Donald Trump’s gilded triumphal arch
2026-11-19T02:49:10.000Z