CNN's Brianna Keilar hailed as she fact-checks Josh Brecheen's claim that Joe Biden has power to shut down border

Brianna Keilar challenged Josh Brecheen to voice his concerns about the bipartisan Senate border deal
PUBLISHED FEB 7, 2024
 Brianna Keilar fact-checked Josh Brecheen's claims about 1952 border laws (@brikeilarcnn/X; United States Congress)
Brianna Keilar fact-checked Josh Brecheen's claims about 1952 border laws (@brikeilarcnn/X; United States Congress)

ATLANTA, GEORGIA: CNN anchor Brianna Keilar challenged GOP Representative Josh Brecheen's assertion regarding President Joe Biden's authority to close the southern border, firmly stating, "You are just wrong."

Keilar pressed Brecheen to articulate his concerns about the bipartisan Senate border deal that emerged after extensive negotiations, legislation that received endorsement from the Border Patrol union.

WASHINGTON, DC - APRIL 27:  Correspondent Brianna Keila attends Google & Hollywood Reporter Host an
CNN anchor Brianna Keilar pushed back on GOP Rep Josh Brecheen’s assertion about President Biden’s abilities to shut down the southern border (Getty Images)

Brianna Keilar fact-checks GOP on President's border authority as netizens applaud

On an X/Twitter post, Keilar pointed out, "A fact check on whether a president already has the authority to shut down the border under a 1952 law. They don’t, despite what Republicans like Rep Brecheen say, even as they oppose the Senate bipartisan compromise that would grant it."



 

Under the same post, several took to its comment section, agreeing to Keilar's comments, "Thank you for holding this guy, with his little Hitler mustache, accountable and not letting him get away with more disinformation. They have a bill they can sign, and they refuse because they know the border is the only issue they have to run on besides tax cuts for the rich".



 

Others chimed in saying, "YOU ARE SAVAGE YES."



 

"Rep Brecheen pretends not to understand what you are saying @brikeilarcnn but he is one of the group of Republicans that reject the best border deal ever for the sole reason that Trump orders them to so he can use this for a campaign issue."



 

"I’ve never watched you, but I’m impressed that you persisted in citing facts when faced with erroneous statements . Good job!"



 

"This is journalism. Love the back and forth," another user said. 



 

"That was masterful and professional. Keep at it Brianna!"



 



 

One follower even tagged her as, "Queen!"

Brianna Keilar rebuts lawmaker on border solutions, cites legislative nuances

Josh Brecheen, a member of the House Homeland Security Committee, asserted that the solution to closing the US-Mexico border has long been available within existing laws, but the current administration has failed to enforce them.

As per The Hill, He cited, “The real solution is, it’s already been on the books for decades, and they refuse to enforce it. 2017 it was being enforced. You had the lowest number of illegal immigration in our nation’s history, 40 years. And yet what’s the difference between 2017 and to date? The difference is an administration that chooses to be lawless, and Republicans go ahead.”

“The real solution is, it’s already been on the books for decades, and they refuse to enforce it,” Brecheen said
Josh Brecheen asserted that the solution to closing the US-Mexico border has long been available within existing laws (United States Congress)

Keilar countered Brecheen's argument by pointing out that the law he referenced, the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952, also includes provisions allowing individuals to seek asylum at the border, even if they enter US territory without authorization. She emphasized that if Brecheen is citing this particular law, he should be aware that the Senate bill under discussion would alter it.

Keilar explained that the proposed legislation would grant the president the authority to enact the measures Brecheen mentioned.

She further highlighted, saying, "It would give the president the ability to do exactly what you were citing, the part of the bill that you’re citing, because in November of 2018, when former President Trump tried to use that very bill that you’re talking about to curb illegal migrant crossings, he was prevented from doing so by a federal court because it violated the very law that he was trying to use. The law that you were saying is on the books.”

Josh Brecheen defended border stance citing Joe Biden's actions

Brecheen defended his position by asserting that President Joe Biden had previously utilized the law in question on day five of his presidency concerning travelers from Brazil, South Africa, and the United Kingdom.

He said, "The law that’s on the books. President Biden on day five utilized it when it came to Brazil, South America, South Africa, excuse me, and the United Kingdom. He utilized that, that provision of law."

Joe Biden (Getty Images)
Josh Brecheen says Joe Biden utilized border laws for travelers from Brazil, South Africa and the United Kingdom (Getty Images)

However, Keilar continued to push back against Brecheen's assertion, indicating further disagreement with his interpretation of the law.

Keilar countered Brecheen's assertion by stating, "It can't apply to asylum, congressman." Meanwhile, the bipartisan border deal, which was finalized in text, encountered significant obstacles in the Senate.

Senate Republicans opted not to bring the bill to the floor, with over half of the GOP conference expressing opposition to the legislation despite months of effort invested in its crafting.

MORE STORIES

Trump framed the end of the shutdown as a political victory, urging voters not to forget the episode when heading into the 2026 midterm elections
2 hours ago
Appearing on 'Fox & Friends' Tuesday, November 11, the Pennsylvania Democrat said Chuck Schumer 'never' talked to him during the government shutdown
20 hours ago
Trump went off on a rant, claiming California’s infamous bullet train is '3,000 percent' over budget
1 day ago
GOP lawmakers are upset that thousands of federal workers and military personnel went weeks without pay, while members of Congress kept their salaries
1 day ago
Democrats blasted Chuck Schumer for weak leadership and failing to unite the party against the shutdown deal and rising health-care costs
2 days ago
Jeanne Shaheen defended breaking with Democrats to support a bipartisan plan she co-brokered with Angus King and Maggie Hassan to end the shutdown
2 days ago
Eight Senate Democratic Caucus members, including John Fetterman and Catherine Cortez Masto, backed a bipartisan deal to reopen the government
2 days ago
Gavin Newsom is among the top Democrats criticizing the deal, which does not include an extension of the expiring Affordable Care Act subsidies
2 days ago
'I cannot in good faith support this CR that fails to address the healthcare crisis,' Chuck Schumer said
2 days ago
Bernie Sanders said the healthcare system is broken and warned the Senate vote would worsen it by doubling Affordable Care Act premiums for millions
3 days ago