Fact Check: Did Kamala Harris get National Guard to fill hurricane aid supply plane just for photo op?

Kamala Harris faced claims she staged a photo op with hurricane supplies, but the allegations were false
PUBLISHED OCT 15, 2024
Kamala Harris was accused of staging a photo op with aircraft carrying hurricane aid supplies (Getty Images)
Kamala Harris was accused of staging a photo op with aircraft carrying hurricane aid supplies (Getty Images)

RALEIGH, NORTH CAROLINA: Vice President Kamala Harris faced allegations of directing the National Guard to load a plane with supplies for hurricane victims purely for a photo op, and the supplies never reached the hands of the victims.

The accusation was made by Jonathan Howard and Charlie Keebaugh, members of Aerial Recovery, a nonprofit organization, during their guest appearances in the 'Shawn Ryan Show' podcast on October 10.

Kamala Harris accused of photo-op with Hurricane Helene supplies



 

"I had a squadron commander from North Carolina reach out to me. They had to load a C-17 full of supplies just to take a photo-op for Kamala, and they never sent the bird," Jonathan Howard claimed in the podcast.

The assertion stemmed from the guests' criticisms of the US government's response to Hurricane Helene, which caused extensive damage throughout western North Carolina.

Howard doubled down on his claim that the entire C-17 was loaded with supplies for hurricane victims only for the vice president to take a photo or video, and the aircraft never took off the ground.

Democratic presidential nominee, Vice President Kamala Harris shakes hands with U.S. Armed Forces members after being briefed on Hurricane Helene recovery operations at the Charlotte Air National Guard Base on October 5, 2024 in Charlotte, North Carolina. Harris provided updates on the federal response, visited a donation drop-off site for storm victims and met with impacted families during her visit to Charlotte. According to the Vice President’s office, 74 percent of people who lost electricity during the storm now have power restored. (Photo by Mario Tama/Getty Images)
Vice President Kamala Harris visited North Carolina after the Hurricane Helene (Mario Tama/Getty Images)

At least 123 have reportedly died in North Carolina in the catastrophic storm.

The Democratic presidential candidate did visit the Tar Heel State following the category 4 Hurricane Helene and stood before a C-17 plane with military personnel to vow continued federal assistance for those affected.

False: Kamala Harris did not do a photo op in front of C-17 filled with hurricane relief supplies

In light of the accusation quickly gaining ground, Shawn Ryan, who runs the podcast, came in defense of Kamala Harris, confirming that the claims made by the guests on his show were false.

The former Navy seal, in a video message posted on X (formerly Twitter), stated the assertion was "misinformation."



 

On Friday, October 11, in the morning, a day after the episode was aired, he received a message from one of the crew members on the cargo plane who confirmed the claim was partially true because the supplies failed to be delivered on the day of Harris' visit.

However, the reason was a technical crisis with the specific C-17, and the supplies were transferred to another plane, which reached the destination the very next day. Confirming the delivery, Ryan implied that Harris was not posing for just a photo.

A spokesperson for the North Carolina National Guard also denied the accusations, assuring Fox News the flight was canceled due to a mechanical mishap at the last minute, as per Daily Mail, and a separate plane delivered the supplies.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Former CNN host Don Lemon was arrested for entering a Minnesota church and filming anti-immigration enforcement protesters who disrupted a service
53 minutes ago
Kevin Warsh’s name appears in Epstein’s 2010 St Barth’s Christmas guest list, raising questions about his social connections ahead of Fed nomination
1 hour ago
The emails show Melania and Maxwell coordinating visits between New York and Palm Beach years before she became first lady
2 hours ago
An ODNI spokesperson said Gabbard viewed election security as vital to the republic, coordinating with counterintelligence to counter foreign risks
7 hours ago
Sen Lindsey Graham blocked the funding bill, demanding Senate leaders guarantee votes on measures targeting sanctuary cities and DOJ probes
9 hours ago
In the emails, Epstein claimed that Donald Trump had visited his home but never received a massage, reinforcing DOJ's finding of no wrongdoing
10 hours ago
Dozens of agencies risk funding lapse as House stays away, while Graham blocks DHS funding deal
10 hours ago
US District Judge Margaret Garnett dismissed death‑eligible counts, ensuring execution was no longer possible in the federal prosecution
11 hours ago
Georgia Fort, activists held over St. Paul church protest as Jeffries vows probe of DOJ 'extremists'
12 hours ago
Warren warned that the nomination was a bid to politicize the Fed, saying, 'Trump said anybody who disagrees with him will never be Fed Chairman'
12 hours ago