'It's disappointing': Ex-US AG Matt Whitaker slams NY civil fraud trial ruling on 'Fox & Friends' after Donald Trump ordered to pay $355M

Describing the case as 'very weak' from a legal standpoint, Matt Whitaker claimed that Judge Arthur Engoron 'gave a forum for Letitia James to make ridiculous claims'
Matt Whitaker discusses the sentencing of Donald Trump in the New York civil fraud case on the February 17, 2024 episode of 'Fox & Friends' (Screengrab/Fox News)
Matt Whitaker discusses the sentencing of Donald Trump in the New York civil fraud case on the February 17, 2024 episode of 'Fox & Friends' (Screengrab/Fox News)

NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK: The February 17 episode of 'Fox & Friends' had former acting US Attorney General Matt Whitaker join the co-hosts to share his take on the proceedings of the New York civil fraud case against former president Donald Trump.

In the case brought up by New York Attorney General Letitia James, the state Supreme Court Judge Arthur Engoron ordered Trump and The Trump Organization to pay penalties of more than $350 million on February 16, 2024.

Additionally, the former president was barred from serving as an officer or director of any corporation or other legal entity in the state for three years. His sons, Eric Trump and Donald Trump Jr, were also asked to pay $4 million and were barred from serving as executives in New York for two years, according to CNN.

Matt Whitaker warns NYC may lose businesses

Describing the case as "very weak" from a legal standpoint, Whitaker claimed that Judge Engoron "gave a forum for Letitia James to make ridiculous claims."

Former US AG Matt Whitaker with the co-hosts on the February 17, 2024 episode of 'Fox & Friends' (Screengrab/Fox News)
Former US AG Matt Whitaker with 'Fox & Friends' hosts during the February 17, 2024 episode (Screengrab/Fox News)

"Ultimately the judgment is untethered to any number," he stated. "There was no victim, no bank has lost any money, no insurance company was out anything. So the judge has picked a number out of the air hoping to punish Trump, The Trump Organization, the Trump children, and others in the ... organization, and I think it's disappointing."

"The other thing that's going to happen ... is (we are) going to see businesses fleeing New York," he continued, "Just like Elon Musk left Delaware, (we're) going to see these businesses leave," Whitaker added.

Donald Trump is not likely to have better luck on appeals

Host Pete Hegseth asked Whitaker whether Donald Trump stands a chance to win on appeal, to which he replied, "It's an appeal to the New York Court of Appeals - it's going to be a seven-judge panel all appointed by Democratic Governors Cuomo and Hochul."

"So you know, there's a chance that justice is not only delayed but could be denied, unfortunately. But I think in this case, this Judge Engoron was so fundamentally biased and unfair to President Trump that the Court of Appeals is going to have to insert themselves," he added.

"Remember, the US Supreme Court does sit above the State Supreme Court ultimately and could, if necessary, and especially in an anti-due process case like this ... it could make its way to the US Supreme Court because it is so fundamentally inconsistent with American jurisprudence," he further stated.



 

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff traveled to Russia and Ukraine last month to begin talks aimed at ending the years-long conflict
2026-10-17T20:47:47.000Z
Vice President JD Vance acknowledged that reviving the economy would take time as the Trump administration worked to turn things around
2026-10-17T19:58:00.000Z
Judge Ana C Reyes reprimanded Trump's lawyers for removing park trees without notifying the court as previously ordered
2026-10-17T18:58:06.000Z
Trump reportedly reconsidered his candidates for key seats as Republicans fought to protect their slim majorities in the Senate and House
2026-10-17T17:31:48.000Z
Trump wanted Maria Bartiromo to replace Karoline Leavitt as White House press secretary, but a key issue reportedly stopped the plan
2026-10-17T16:27:24.000Z
Trump said that the Lindsey O Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act of 2026 lets him reverse sanctions provisions for any foreign person
2026-10-17T15:29:56.000Z
Ilhan Omar has reportedly not been seen in public since Monday, October 12, when federal agents searched her Washington, DC, home
2026-10-17T08:03:31.000Z
Kristi Noem was appointed special envoy in March after her removal as HSS amid scrutiny of her leadership and Corey Lewandowski’s influence
2026-10-17T07:55:06.000Z
Trump revisited Barack Obama’s promise that Americans could keep their doctors under the Affordable Care Act during his rally in Dalton, Georgia
2026-10-17T06:49:31.000Z
DHS Secretary credited Trump’s border security policies for the decline, saying the latest figures reflected his efforts to strengthen enforcement
2026-10-17T06:28:54.000Z