MEAWW News Logo
Watch
✕
US Politics Entertainment World Fact Check Public Opinion Opinion Media
► Watch
Home / Galleries

5 troubled executions before Christa Pike, from botched lethal injections to second attempts

US Oct 9, 2026
BY SANA YASEEN
(L-R) Alan Eugene Miller, Christa Pike and Tony Carruthers
(L-R) Alan Eugene Miller, Christa Pike and Tony Carruthers
Christa Pike's failed execution in Tennessee on September 30, 2026, has renewed scrutiny of lethal injection procedures across the United States. Pike survived after receiving two doses of pentobarbital, making her case different from earlier aborted executions in which no lethal drugs were administered. Here are five previous cases, arranged chronologically, and what happened afterward.
6 Photos
1 / 6
Christa Pike survived after receiving lethal drugs
IMAGE SOURCE: AP PHOTO/GEORGE WALKER IV, TDOC VIA AP

Christa Pike survived after receiving lethal drugs

Tennessee officials halted Pike's execution on September 30 after administering two doses of pentobarbital, a drug used in lethal injections. Pike remained alive and was transported to a hospital. She later regained consciousness. Robin Maher, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center, described the case as unprecedented because earlier prisoners had survived aborted lethal injections before the execution drugs were administered. Gov. Bill Lee subsequently paused the state's remaining executions for 2026 and ordered a review. Pike's legal future remains uncertain.

2 / 6
Alan Eugene Miller survived Alabama's failed attempt
IMAGE SOURCE: ALABAMA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS

Alan Eugene Miller survived Alabama's failed attempt

Alabama called off Miller's execution on September 22, 2022, after officials spent approximately 90 minutes unsuccessfully attempting to establish intravenous access. No lethal drugs were administered, and Miller was returned to his cell. Following litigation over the failed procedure, Alabama agreed not to attempt another lethal injection. Miller was eventually executed using nitrogen hypoxia on September 26, 2024, becoming the second person in the country executed by that method.

3 / 6
Kenneth Eugene Smith's execution was called off
IMAGE SOURCE: ALABAMA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS

Kenneth Eugene Smith's execution was called off

Just two months after Miller's failed execution, Alabama encountered similar problems with Kenneth Eugene Smith. Officials abandoned his November 17, 2022, lethal injection after struggling to establish IV access before the execution warrant expired. No execution drugs were administered. Smith survived that attempt but remained on death row. On January 25, 2024, Alabama executed him using nitrogen hypoxia, making him the first person in the United States executed by that method.

4 / 6
Idaho abandoned Thomas Creech's execution after 8 attempts
IMAGE SOURCE: IDOC

Idaho abandoned Thomas Creech's execution after 8 attempts

Idaho abandoned Thomas Creech's execution on February 28, 2024, after medical personnel made eight unsuccessful attempts to establish intravenous access. The procedure was stopped after approximately 58 minutes, before any lethal drugs were administered. Creech was returned to his prison cell and remained under a death sentence. The failed execution prompted further legal challenges and scrutiny of Idaho's procedures, while the state subsequently moved toward using the firing squad as its primary execution method.

5 / 6
Tennessee's first failed attempt of the year involved Tony Carruthers
IMAGE SOURCE: TDOC

Tennessee's first failed attempt of the year involved Tony Carruthers

Tennessee halted Tony Carruthers' execution on May 21, 2026, after officials established a primary IV line but could not insert the backup line required by state protocol. An attempt to establish a central line also failed, and no lethal drugs were administered. Gov Bill Lee granted Carruthers a one-year reprieve, leaving him on death row. Four months later, Tennessee's execution of Pike was also halted, although her case differed significantly because the lethal drugs had already been administered.

6 / 6
Joe Nathan James Jr's execution went ahead despite complications
IMAGE SOURCE: ALABAMA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS

Joe Nathan James Jr's execution went ahead despite complications

Unlike the other prisoners, Joe Nathan James Jr. did not survive his troubled execution. Alabama executed him on July 28, 2022, following a delay of approximately three hours associated with difficulties establishing intravenous access. A subsequent private autopsy documented multiple puncture wounds and other injuries, raising questions about the procedure. James' case illustrates a different outcome from the aborted attempts: despite serious complications, officials proceeded with the execution, and he was pronounced dead.

MORE GALLERIES

Michelle Obama rocks optical-Illusion skirt, $50K diamond rings for Gloria Steinem tribute 6

Michelle Obama rocks optical-Illusion skirt, $50K diamond rings for Gloria Steinem tribute

Nov 20, 2026
Melania Trump stuns in black lace-trimmed dress and elegant blazer at New York premiere of her docuseries 5

Melania Trump stuns in black lace-trimmed dress and elegant blazer at New York premiere of her docuseries

Nov 20, 2026
Who is Mary Peltola? From her Yup’ik heritage to 1995 pageant win, 7 facts about Alaska’s senator-elect 7

Who is Mary Peltola? From her Yup’ik heritage to 1995 pageant win, 7 facts about Alaska’s senator-elect

Nov 18, 2026
What is a dirty bomb and how dangerous is it? 7 facts amid alleged Iran plot targeting DC 7

What is a dirty bomb and how dangerous is it? 7 facts amid alleged Iran plot targeting DC

Nov 18, 2026
Can't access your money? 7 major US institutions trigger alarm as customers report outages 8

Can't access your money? 7 major US institutions trigger alarm as customers report outages

Nov 17, 2026
Meet the wealthy newcomers joining Congress in 2027, from business moguls to a Yankees star 6

Meet the wealthy newcomers joining Congress in 2027, from business moguls to a Yankees star

Nov 16, 2026
Phil Collins, 75, makes rare public appearance with his three children including Lily Collins at Rock & Roll Hall of Fame ceremony 5

Phil Collins, 75, makes rare public appearance with his three children including Lily Collins at Rock & Roll Hall of Fame ceremony

Nov 16, 2026
Mandy Moore shares rare photos ft all three children from NYC family trip 6

Mandy Moore shares rare photos ft all three children from NYC family trip

Nov 16, 2026
Photos show California coast battered by giant 50-foot waves as flooding threatens neighborhoods 5

Photos show California coast battered by giant 50-foot waves as flooding threatens neighborhoods

Nov 16, 2026
What Trump posted during nationwide FAA ground stop before calling for more funding 6

What Trump posted during nationwide FAA ground stop before calling for more funding

Nov 15, 2026
Four years after Idaho murders, photos show how a new generation of students honors the victims 6

Four years after Idaho murders, photos show how a new generation of students honors the victims

Nov 14, 2026
Dramatic photos show cruise ship overturned in New Orleans after tanker collision leaves 32 hospitalized 6

Dramatic photos show cruise ship overturned in New Orleans after tanker collision leaves 32 hospitalized

Nov 14, 2026
Melania Trump and Usha Vance keep it stylish as they meet military families in Alabama ahead of Thanksgiving 7

Melania Trump and Usha Vance keep it stylish as they meet military families in Alabama ahead of Thanksgiving

Nov 13, 2026
Ariana Grande and Ricky Alvarez make surprise red carpet debut after rekindling their romance 5

Ariana Grande and Ricky Alvarez make surprise red carpet debut after rekindling their romance

Nov 12, 2026
Will Trump's proposed 250-foot arch cast a shadow over JFK's grave? Photos show what's at stake 5

Will Trump's proposed 250-foot arch cast a shadow over JFK's grave? Photos show what's at stake

Nov 11, 2026
Olivia Culpo shares rare photos of her and Christian McCaffrey’s 5-week-old son Rowan at his first 49ers game 6

Olivia Culpo shares rare photos of her and Christian McCaffrey’s 5-week-old son Rowan at his first 49ers game

Nov 11, 2026
Hunter Biden honored at Trinity College Dublin as dad Joe and daughter Maisy join candlelit celebration 5

Hunter Biden honored at Trinity College Dublin as dad Joe and daughter Maisy join candlelit celebration

Nov 11, 2026
Trump and Jensen Huang's relationship in pictures: Key moments that brought them together 7

Trump and Jensen Huang's relationship in pictures: Key moments that brought them together

Nov 10, 2026
Melania Trump turns heads in bomber jacket and sleek pencil skirt during LSU visit 6

Melania Trump turns heads in bomber jacket and sleek pencil skirt during LSU visit

Nov 9, 2026
Karoline Leavitt gives rare glimpse into her private life with photos from best friend's bridal celebration 4

Karoline Leavitt gives rare glimpse into her private life with photos from best friend's bridal celebration

Nov 9, 2026
MEAWW News is a part of the Scale Content Inc. publishing group.

Google Source

About Us
Editorial Guidelines
Privacy Policy
Cookie Policy
Terms of Use
Contact Us
Link to Facebook
Link to Instagram
Link to X
Link to Youtube
Link to Tiktok

© Scale Content Inc. 1178 Broadway, 3rd Floor #3469, New York, NY 10001, United States