'Heroes' creator Tim Kring pays tribute to Hayden Panettiere, recalls her no-brainer casting

Tim Kring remembered Hayden Panettiere's audition for Claire Bennet and praised the talent and range that made her stand out at 16
Tim Kring reflected on Hayden Panettiere's natural talent and instant connection to Claire Bennet (Getty Images)
Tim Kring reflected on Hayden Panettiere's natural talent and instant connection to Claire Bennet (Getty Images)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: When 'Heroes' premiered in September 2006, Hayden Panettiere quickly became one of the faces of the NBC drama as Claire Bennet, the seemingly ordinary cheerleader at the center of the story.

Twenty years later, creator Tim Kring is reflecting on the casting process and why Panettiere stood out immediately. The actress died at 36 in South Carolina on August 16, with her death recently ruled an accident.

NEW YORK, NY - JANUARY 05:  Hayden Panettiere discusses
Hayden Panettiere discussed 'Nashville' with the Build Series at AOL HQ on January 5, 2017, in New York City (Roy Rochlin/FilmMagic)

Tim Kring recalls Hayden Panettiere's instant connection to Claire Bennet

Speaking to Entertainment Weekly, Kring explained that 'Heroes' had such a large cast that the production could not afford to hire many “really known actors.” Instead, they wanted performers who “felt like they were ordinary people,” with a relatable, everyman quality.

Kring said Claire was envisioned as “the cheerleader who you had the crush on, not the one that everybody else had the crush on,” describing her as not the golden girl but someone “slightly quirky, with something offbeat about her.”

Panettiere was 16 when she auditioned, and Kring said the team did not have to look far to find their Claire. “We did not look very far; we saw [Panettiere], and that was it,” he added.

LOS ANGELES, CA - NOVEMBER 01:  Writer Tim Kring (L) and actress Hayden Panettiere attend the Hollywood Entertainment Museum's Hollywood Legacy Awards XI held at the Esquire House Hollywood Hills on November 11, 2008 in Los Angeles, California.  (Photo by Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images)
Tim Kring and Hayden Panettiere attended the Hollywood Entertainment Museum's Hollywood Legacy Awards XI on November 11, 2008, in Los Angeles, California (Alberto E Rodriguez/Getty Images)

Kring recalled that Panettiere was an “extraordinary actress” who embodied the “girl-next-door quality” while also possessing exceptional range. He added that after seeing her audition, he could not remember having another performer in mind for Claire.

“It was just pure talent that walked in the door,” Kring said and added, “There’s nobody in my head that we saw other than her.” 'Heroes' ultimately ran for four seasons before ending in 2010.

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - MARCH 06: Hayden Panettiere attends the Global Premiere of Paramount Pictures and Spyglass Media Group's
Hayden Panettiere attended the Global Premiere of 'Scream VI' at AMC Lincoln Square on March 6, 2023, in New York City (Jason Mendez/Getty Images for Paramount Pictures)

Hayden Panettiere remembered by her 'Heroes' costars

The 'Heroes' team reunited in honor of Panettiere on August 25. Jimmy Jean-Louis, who played Rene, also known as “the Haitian,” shared photos from the gathering on Instagram, describing the reunion as “deeply emotional.”

“There was sadness in our hearts, but also so much love, gratitude, and warmth,” Jean-Louis wrote, adding, “Au revoir Hayden.” Masi Oka, Santiago Cabrera, Greg Grunberg, Sendhil Ramamurthy and Jack Coleman were among those present, while Zachary Quinto joined through a video call.

Writer and producer Bryan Fuller also shared photos, calling Panettiere “No. 1 on the call sheet and No. 1 in our hearts and memories.” He wrote that the group shared stories of “Hayden’s light” and ended with, “Rest in peace, Hayden.”

Panettiere’s representative confirmed her death on August 16 on behalf of her father, Alan “Skip” Panettiere. The Greenville Police Department later said she was found unresponsive and that the preliminary investigation had found no signs of foul play or suspicious circumstances.

Oka remembered Panettiere as having a “beautiful spirit,” “immense talent” and “joyful energy,” while saying she was “wiser beyond her years” and “gone too soon.”

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The ‘Dune’ star also issued a lengthy statement addressing the criticism and said she was ‘disturbed’ over the ongoing speculation.
2026-11-19T11:53:43.000Z
Ramsay said he was ‘lost for words’ over his latest achievement and called himself ‘the luckiest chef on the planet.’
2026-11-19T09:22:31.000Z
Just days earlier, Larry Poindexter was hit by a car at night while crossing the street to pick up food in his Studio City neighborhood
2026-11-19T07:10:45.000Z
Lainey Wilson joked about Taylor Swift’s wedding venue, while Brad Paisley teased Swift about eating shrimp at her wedding
2026-11-19T06:58:30.000Z
Ella Langley won six awards at the 2026 CMA Awards, including Entertainer of the Year, marking a major career milestone
2026-11-19T06:27:28.000Z
The CMA initially denied Sammy Kershaw's request to walk the pre-show red carpet with his wife, Mendy
2026-11-19T05:38:11.000Z
Known for surprising her audience, Swift made her CMA comeback even more special by bringing several country music stars into the performance.
2026-11-19T05:03:46.000Z
Lance Bass confirmed interviewing for Justin Timberlake’s documentary, which will revisit his controversial Super Bowl performance with Janet Jackson
2026-11-19T04:01:48.000Z
Costume designer Molly Rogers accidentally revealed the baby’s gender in a now-deleted congratulatory Instagram Story
2026-11-19T03:48:17.000Z
Wilson said Parton gave us 'joy, hope, and heart' as she remembered the late icon in country music's biggest night.
2026-11-19T03:39:32.000Z