Internet split as judge snaps at Trump lawyer Alina Habba after denying E Jean Carroll trial adjournment

Judge Lewis Kaplan rebuked Donald Trump's attorney during the defamation trial and denied the delay request once again
PUBLISHED JAN 18, 2024
Judge Lewis Kaplan and Trump attorney Alina Habba engaged in a fiery clash during the proceedings of the defamation lawsuit filed by E Jean Carroll (United States Courts/ YouTube, Getty Images)
Judge Lewis Kaplan and Trump attorney Alina Habba engaged in a fiery clash during the proceedings of the defamation lawsuit filed by E Jean Carroll (United States Courts/ YouTube, Getty Images)

MANHATTAN, NEW YORK: Judge Lewis Kaplan and Trump attorney Alina Habba had a nasty exchange on the second day of the proceedings in the defamation lawsuit filed by writer E Jean Carroll against former President Donald Trump.

Based on a report by Daily Mail, the New York judge scolded Habba on Wednesday, January 17, when she repeated the request to delay the trial so Trump could attend his mother-in-law's funeral on January 18 in Florida.

Judge Kaplan, who had previously rejected the attorney's request on January 12 to delay the proceedings, stated, "Mr Trump is free to attend the trial, the funeral, or all or parts of both, as he wishes."

(@realDonaldTrump/Truth Social)
Donald Trump with his late mother-in-law Amalija Knavs (@realDonaldTrump/Truth Social)

Former first lady Melania Trump's mother, Amalija Knavs, 78, died on January 9.

Judge asked Alina Habba to 'sit down'

Before the plaintiff took the stand to make her statements, Habba again asked for an adjournment of the trial.



 

"The application is denied," Judge Kaplan said. "I will hear no further argument on it."

However, Habba continued to speak, irking the judge. "None. Do you understand that word?" he asked. "Sit down."

The attorney fired back, saying, "I don't like to be spoken to in that way, your honor." Kaplan cut her off, saying, "It's denied. Sit down."

The judge also snapped at Trump for making loud remarks during Carroll's statement and threatened to kick him out of the courtroom.



 

Since the judge denied his request the first time, the GOP frontrunner has made it into a campaign tool, labeling the judge "unfair" and "biased."

Besides slamming Kaplan on multiple occasions, Trump also vowed to attend his mother-in-law's funeral despite repercussions.

Internet reacts to courtroom drama

The courtroom proceedings have divided netizens into two groups.

CHARLOTTE, NC - MARCH 2: U.S. President Donald Trump speaks to supporters during a rally on March 2,
Some social media users spoke in support of Donald Trump slamming the NY judge (Getty Images)

While some users on X criticized Kaplan's "unprofessional" behavior, another group appreciated him for "setting a boundary" for Trump and his attorney.

One user remarked, "Karma isn't far away from all of this corruption."



 

Another opined, "Open hostility by the judge is disgusting."



 

"That's awful!!!" read a third response. A fourth user added, "Unbelievably UNPROFESSIONAL!"



 



 

On the other hand, one user said, "Judge was entirely appropriate under the circumstances. Being a trial lawyer means either knowing your judge or taking your lumps. She chose lumps."



 

"Like Trump, she doesn't like to be told NO," read another reaction.



 

Applauding the judge, a user said, "Great judge, he knows these two need limit and boundary settings!"



 

"Good job judge. This isn’t tRump’s show The Apprentice," a response read.



 

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Two battalions from the 11th Airborne Division were readied for cold-weather deployment as they were best suited for Minnesota’s harsh winter conditions
8 hours ago
50 trainers guided 2,000 DSA members and 2,000 allies as Renee Good's death spurred activists to expand rapid response networks
11 hours ago
Abigail Spanberger defeated Republican candidate Winsome Earle-Sears in the 2025 election, reshaping Virginia’s political balance heading into 2026
1 day ago
Adriana Camberos' first conviction involved fake energy drinks sold in the US with counterfeit labels, and Trump commuted her sentence in January 2021
1 day ago
'If I move him, these Fed guys - certainly the one we have now - they don't talk much. I would lose you' Donald Trump said about Kevin Hassett
2 days ago
Charles Wall served for the past year as ICE's principal legal advisor, overseeing 3,500 staff in immigration court and advising DHS leadership
2 days ago
Donald Trump launched 'The Great Healthcare Plan' in Washington, promising lower costs, transparency, and less corporate influence
3 days ago
Donald Trump's Truth Social post on Thursday, January 15, signaled possible military deployment if unrest over ICE protests continued
3 days ago
Whip Tom Emmer said members must be in Washington to 'pass legislation to lower costs, secure the border, and support the president’s agenda'
4 days ago
The Michigan representative’s anger stems from the death of Renee Nicole Good, an ICE agent, during a protest on January 7 in Minneapolis
4 days ago