Justice Clarence Thomas called a 'barbarian' as Harry Litman slams his 'originalism' argument on domestic violence

Ex-federal prosecutor Harry Litman took a jab at Justice Clarence Thomas' approach to the Constitution in light of SCOTUS' ruling in the Rahimi case
PUBLISHED JUN 22, 2024
Justice Clarence Thomas' originalist stance was once again questioned by former prosecutor Harry Litman (Getty Images, @harrylitman/X)
Justice Clarence Thomas' originalist stance was once again questioned by former prosecutor Harry Litman (Getty Images, @harrylitman/X)

WASHINGTON, DC: In a case where a domestic abuser wanted access to his gun after it had been taken away owing to a victim's protection order, Justice Clarence Thomas was the lone dissenting opinion, as per Raw Story.

Harry Litman, a former federal prosecutor, argues that the US Supreme Court "painted itself into a corner" in an earlier gun case. Thus, they felt the need to fix themselves in the United States v Rahimi decision. Speaking to MSNBC's Nicolle Wallace, Litman jokingly said that Thomas, at least, maintained his consistency.



 

Harry Litman slams Clarence Thomas' 'originalism' argument on domestic violence

Litman remarked, "This opinion was cleaning up a self-inflicted error by the court two years ago in the Bruen case."

Notably, in the Bruen case, the state of New York was sued because it demanded proof of a unique need for protection before granting an unrestricted license to carry a concealed handgun.

Litman clarified that the difference in this case is that there is no originalism argument because beating your wife was legal at the time the law was written. He said, "There wasn't any history for understandable and irrelevant reasons, sad reasons, really, of regulating domestic offenders at the time."

It wasn't until 1920 that beating your wife was deemed illegal in all 20 states.

Former Deputy Assistant Attorney General Harry Litman speaks at
Harry Litman questioned Justice Clarence Thomas' rigid approach to the Constitution (Michael Tullberg/Getty Images)

Litman stated that the case on Friday, June 21, had to go in the manner that it did "and Thomas' adherence to what they said in Bruen really just shows the rigidity of the way he approaches the Constitution."

Moreover, in Friday's case, it was evident that the majority of the court thought that a domestic abuser shouldn't own a gun. He projected that the "originalism" dispute would be resolved in the upcoming years.

Litman questioned, "You can come up with relevantly similar regulations that we used to do, and he's saying society would do. But now take that question and think about, for example, gay marriage. Is that relevantly similar as to marriage as it used to be or abortion?"

WASHINGTON, DC - NOVEMBER 30: United States Supreme Court Associate Justice Clarence Thomas poses fo
US Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas has frequently drawn flak due to his own brand of originalist jurisprudence (Getty Images)

Internet reacts as Harry Litman questions Justice Clarence Thomas' 'originalism' argument on domestic violence

Netizens were in agreement with former federal prosecutor Litman as he slammed Justice Thomas over his "originalism" argument on domestic violence.

One wrote, "He really hates us...and loves his money and power," while another said, "The man is a barbarian."

"Thomas woud vote to end his mixed marriage, count on it," quipped a person, and someone else echoed, "If Thomas is so obsessed with Originalism then he needs to divorce his white wife and stop voting. Oh, and quit the Supreme Court as well."

An individual offered, "How does Thomas square his Originalist views with the fact that those views consider him 3/5ths of a human with no constitutional rights?" whereas one mentioned, "Will he cause his marriage to be invalidated as a result of one his future 'originalist' decisions? Must be consistent."

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

MORE STORIES

Trump revived his long-running clash with Jerome Powell by sharing a viral cartoon while demanding deeper rate cuts despite Fed independence
1 day ago
Supreme Court backs Trump’s move to freeze $4 billion in foreign aid, marking a major win for executive power
2 days ago
Pam Bondi also said the Justice Department was transferring inmates taken off death row under former President Joe Biden into maximum-security prisons
3 days ago
During a Wisconsin Senate immigration debate, the top Democrat lunged at chairman’s gavel, calling Republicans 'cowards' and questioning their faith
3 days ago
Donald Trump said UN officials 'ought to be ashamed,' adding he will send a letter to the Secretary General demanding an immediate investigation
4 days ago
JD Vance said that Democrats like Gavin Newsom and the left-wing media fuel violence by spreading lies about law enforcement
4 days ago
The display shows black-and-white presidential portraits in gold frames, but Joe Biden is replaced with an autopen signing his signature
4 days ago
The FBI confirmed the Dallas ICE shooting is a targeted assault after Joshua Jahn allegedly killed two detainees before turning the gun on himself
4 days ago
Local residents say they never want to see Lance Twiggs again, even as his dusty car and abandoned Amazon packages sit as reminders of the couple
5 days ago
Brilyn Hollyhand recalled Charlie Kirk’s lasting advice, later echoed by Donald Trump at Kirk’s memorial, saying it drives his fight today
6 days ago