CNN's Harry Enten shocked by John Fetterman's huge fall to -40 points approval among Democrats

Harry Enten said 'There is no historical analog to this. That is how unpopular John Fetterman is with Pennsylvania Democrats'
Harry Enten flags dramatic collapse in Fetterman's support from his own party's voters since his first election in 2023 (Getty Images, CNN/Youtube)
Harry Enten flags dramatic collapse in Fetterman's support from his own party's voters since his first election in 2023 (Getty Images, CNN/Youtube)

ATLANTA, GEORGIA: CNN data analyst Harry Enten is raising serious questions about the political future of Democrat John Fetterman, pointing to a sharp decline in his standing among party voters, one that comes as internal tensions, including major disagreements over his vote to advance a full-year funding bill for the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).

Speaking on CNN News Central on Friday, March 20, Enten suggested that the numbers paint a troubling picture for the Pennsylvania senator.

PHILADELPHIA, PA - OCTOBER 15:  Democratic candidate for U.S. Senate John Fetterman reacts to applau
John Fetterman reacts to applause from supporters during a joint rally with Democratic candidate for Governor Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro at Norris Park on October 15, 2022 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania (Mark Makela/Getty Images)

Harry Enten lays out 'disastrous' numbers for John Fetterman

Breaking down the data, Enten emphasized just how dramatically Fetterman’s popularity has fallen within his own base.

“I would just say that John Fetterman is doing as well with Pennsylvania Democrats as the New York Giants are as liked in the commonwealth of Pennsylvania.”

He then contrasted Fetterman’s earlier standing with his current position saying “Back in 2023, he was a Democrat, liberal darling, at plus-68 points. Look at how low he has fallen, down to minus-40 points.”

Enten dramatically added, “He's down there with the Titanic among Democrats in the commonwealth of Pennsylvania.”

Anchor John Berman highlighted the scale of the shift saying “This is 108-point swing.”

Even Enten appeared stunned. “Wait a minute, 108-point swing, you never see anything like that.. my goodness gracious”, he added.

WASHINGTON, DC - APRIL 23: Sen. John Fetterman (D-PA) walks to the Senate chamber at the U.S. Capitol on April 23, 2024 in Washington, DC. The Senate is taking up a $95 billion foreign aid package today for Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan. (Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)
Sen John Fetterman (D-PA) walks to the Senate chamber at the US Capitol on April 23, 2024 in Washington, DC (Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)

Harry Enten draws stark comparison

To underline how unusual the situation is, Enten compared John Fetterman’s numbers with senators who previously lost primaries.

“Bob Smith plus-15, Arlen Specter plus-13, Joe Lieberman plus-six, Dick Lugar at zero, Lisa Murkowski was at minus-15 points.”

He then delivered the key point: “All of these were considerably more popular than John Fetterman is right now at minus-40 points.”

“There is no historical analog to this. That is how unpopular John Fetterman is with Pennsylvania Democrats.

ARLINGTON, VA - MARCH 03: Voting booths sit empty midway through the day of the Democratic president
Voting booths sit empty midway through the day of the Democratic presidential primary elections at the Sleepy Hollow Elementary School polling location on Super Tuesday, March 3, 2020 in Arlington, Virginia (Samuel Corum/Getty Images)

Looking ahead, Enten made a clear prediction about what Fetterman could face if he seeks re-election.

“There is basically no doubt in my mind that if Fetterman decides to run for re-election as a Democrat, he will face a primary challenge. It will be a very competitive one.”

With intra-party tensions rising and key votes like DHS funding adding to the friction, Fetterman’s political standing appears increasingly fragile.

According to Enten’s analysis, the scale of his decline isn’t just notable, it’s historically unprecedented, leaving the Democrat with a steep uphill battle if he chooses to stay in the race.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Puck's Leigh Ann Caldwell said Anthony Fauci's refusal to answer Congress could serve as a roadmap for pardoned Trump administration officials
20 hours ago
The debate began after Jessica Tarlov cited the killing of Minnesota lawmaker Melissa Hortman and her husband while discussing political violence
4 days ago
The report said hosts' wardrobe budgets were significantly reduced, marking a shift away from the designer labels long associated with the show
7 days ago
Jon Stewart continued the bit by humorously wondering whether the president seen by the public was actually the real Trump or the supposed stand-in
Jul 22, 2026
Scott Jennings said it was only a matter of time before the Democratic Party's more radical views became its mainstream platform
Jul 19, 2026
Bill Maher mocked Democrats' 2028 hopefuls, joking he couldn't choose from the current 'crop of geniuses'
Jul 19, 2026
Former DNC spokesperson Xochitl Hinojosa criticized ICE shootings, while Jason Rantz said the officer acted to avoid a fleeing vehicle
Jul 19, 2026
Joey Jones said the deaths of two US service members in Jordan underscored the gap between official messaging and the reality on the ground
Jul 18, 2026
CNN's Harry Enten cited new polling showing rising frustration over grocery prices, with lower-income Americans
Jul 17, 2026
Tony Dokoupil's remarks immediately set the tone for CBS' coverage and distinguished it from a traditional introduction to a presidential address
Jul 17, 2026