Fact Check: Is New York planning to darken the night skies with new legislation?

ALBANY, NEW YORK: In mid-March, a rumor circulated across social media claiming that New York is planning to darken the night skies with new legislation.

As per the rumor, authorities are trying to enforce a law that would force lights out after 11 PM. But is there any truth to this viral claim? Let us find out below.

Claim:  New York is planning to darken night skies with new legislation

An X user claimed on Monday, March 16, "Watch out NY! They are trying to enforce a law that will force lights out after 11 pm! Under the proposed legislation, Outdoor recreational facilities would NOT be allowed to operate lights between 11 pm and 5 am !!!"

Similarly, another post read, "New York has introduced a bill in Albany that would FORCE ALL residents to TURN OFF their outdoor lights at 11 PM or face FINES of $250-$500+ EACH TIME!"

"Is it true that New York is passing a law that exterior lights must be turned off at 11:00 pm or you'll be fined $250-$500? Light pollution?," wrote another X user.

Meanwhile, one online user wrote, "New York, America until 11 pm, then it becomes North Korea till morning. Let me guess, if you don’t pay the ridiculous fine, they suspend your license and eventually confiscate your home? Ahhh, the warmth of collectivism."

Fact Check: Partly true, 'The Dark Skies Protection Act' is under consideration

The claims made in the online posts are partly true, as there is a legislation under consideration, Assembly Bill 04615, called 'The Dark Skies Protection Act', News10NBC reported.

As per the bill, it is intended to protect wildlife, conserve energy, reduce carbon footprints, and preserve views of the night sky. Assembly Member Deborah Glick said, "It’s just about trying to limit the light pollution that we’re all experiencing."

Meanwhile, Glick, who his also the sponsor of the legislation, said, "This started with people complaining about not being able to see the night sky. But the bill just requires shielding light and having it directed downward."

The report mentioned that non-conforming light fixtures would have to be shut off from 11 PM to 5 AM, unless they are motion-activated. The bill also lists lots of exceptions, including lighting for highways, airports, emergency services, and worker safety.

"There are sporting events or concerts. So until those are completed — while they’re in progress — nobody is saying you have to shut the lights off at 11 o’clock when you’re still engaged in the activity," Glick said.

Talking about the fines, Glick said, "There are no fines. This is really about encouraging the Department of Environmental Conservation to provide educational materials to raise awareness."

To sum this up, as of now, there’s no telling if 'The Dark Skies Protection Act' will see the light of a full vote. However, as to whether lawmakers are considering it, that’s a fact.