'He dodged the draft five times': Fox News panel erupts over Vance's attack on Tim Walz's military record

A fierce debate erupted over Minnesota Governor and Kamala Harris’ running mate Tim Walz's military service on Fox News' 'The Five'
Jessica Tarlov blasted 'The Five' panel for repeating JD Vance's claim that Tim Walz abandoned his unit by retiring just before he was deployed to Iraq (Foxnews/Getty Images)
Jessica Tarlov blasted 'The Five' panel for repeating JD Vance's claim that Tim Walz abandoned his unit by retiring just before he was deployed to Iraq (Foxnews/Getty Images)

WASHINGTON, DC: On Wednesday, Fox News' 'The Five' descended into a heated argument when Democratic commentator Jessica Tarlov confronted her colleagues over criticisms of Minnesota Governor Tim Walz’s military service.

The controversy flared up after Walz, who has been chosen as Vice President Kamala Harris’ running mate, faced attacks from Donald Trump supporters.

JD Vance’s desertion claim against Tim Walz challenged

The criticisms stemmed from Sen JD Vance’s claim that Tim Walz, a longtime Army National Guard member, abandoned his unit by retiring just before a scheduled deployment to Iraq.

This accusation is contentious given that the deployment orders were issued several months after Walz’s retirement, which had occurred as he left the Guard to pursue a congressional run. Additionally, neither Walz nor Vance had served in combat roles.


SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN - JANUARY 25: Minnesota Governor Tim Walz speaks about funding for the I-535 Blatnik Bridge before a visit by U.S. President Joe Biden at Earth Rider Brewery on January 25, 2024 in Superior, Wisconsin. Biden touched on his economic agenda and recent federal funding for infrastructure projects. (Photo by Stephen Maturen/Getty Images)
JD Vance slammed the timing of Minnesota Governor Tim Walz’s retirement as a means of avoiding deployment to Iraq on Wednesday (Stephen Maturen/Getty Images)

Tarlov criticized the attacks, referencing the Trump campaign manager’s role in the John Kerry Swift Boat controversy. She defended Walz, noting his 24 years of honorable service and pointing out Trump’s own draft dodging.

"So obviously, this was going to come up because the Trump campaign manager was the one behind the John Kerry Swift Boat attack, which was obviously very persuasive to people," Tarlov said.

Donald Trump (teamtrump/ Instagram)
Jessica Tarlov defended Tim Walz's military record while criticizing Donald Trump's draft dodging and campaign tactics (@teamtrump/Instagram)

"He served for 24 years, honorably, then he stopped to run for Congress on a platform of ending the war, and I don't think that anyone, especially with Donald Trump at the top of a ticket, he dodged the draft four or five times, bone spurs, Captain Bone Spurs."

Fiery exchange on Fox News over Tim Walz's military record

Greg Gutfeld interrupted, shouting, "Bone spurs are a very serious issue, Jessica." Tarlov continued to challenge the criticisms, citing Donald Trump's controversial remarks and personal issues.

"He denied he slept with Stormy Daniels but that obviously hasn't worked out for him. I don't think you should ever say anyone who served didn't do a good job in this. If JD Vance wants to get into that tit-for-tat, he was in the public affairs department. It's just a fact of all of this. I don't think he should be going there with Tim Walz. I think that everyone who has served—"



 

Jesse Watters interjected sharply, "He was in a war zone," referring to Vance’s service in Iraq. Tarlov pointed out, "He was a reporter."

Watters retorted, "He was in Iraq, Jessica. He was in the Marines. And this guy left his unit ... Listen, it doesn't matter what I think, Jessica, his unit thinks he's a coward."

Tarlov vehemently denied this, exclaiming, "It's not true!"

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

President Donald Trump reportedly consulted allies on whether to fire longtime Chief of Staff Susie Wiles and appoint a replacement
2026-10-16T16:42:09.000Z
WH counsel told a judge Trump invoked executive privilege to shield communications with advisers and Kennedy Center employees over official duties
2026-10-16T08:01:26.000Z
So far, Donald Trump has not endorsed Benjamin Netanyahu in Israel's October 27 election
2026-10-16T07:18:58.000Z
According to FEC filings, Elon Musk contributed $75 million to the Senate Leadership Fund on September 9 and another $83 million on September 23
2026-10-16T06:26:37.000Z
Marco Rubio questioned how many political candidates could win elections by promising to put America’s interests behind those of other countries
2026-10-16T05:58:53.000Z
Virginia contractor Agile1Tech’s initial $22,000 contract was expanded by $27,600 to cover three additional chandeliers
2026-10-16T05:38:23.000Z
The tense exchange unfolded during a healthcare event in Virginia Beach, where Kennedy appeared alongside Republican Rep Jennifer Kiggans
2026-10-16T05:18:48.000Z
Donald Trump said he had declined criminal investigations into political rivals but hinted another impeachment attempt could change his stance
2026-10-16T05:15:07.000Z
'President Trump keeps all options on the table to ensure that Iran can never have a nuclear weapon,' a White House spokesperson said
2026-10-16T05:06:30.000Z
Donald Trump criticized John Cornyn and Karl Rove as 'weak and ineffective political hacks,' claiming they were making it harder for Ken Paxton to win
2026-10-16T04:55:01.000Z