Supreme Court turns away Pennsylvania Judge suspended over partisan posts in free speech fight

The posts praised high-profile Democrats, including President Joe Biden and Pennsylvania Gov Josh Shapiro, and advocated for specific political policies, such as raising the minimum wage
Pennsylvania’s Judicial Conduct Board brought charges against Cohen over 66 Facebook posts made on a public profile where he identified himself as a sitting judge (Getty Images)
Pennsylvania’s Judicial Conduct Board brought charges against Cohen over 66 Facebook posts made on a public profile where he identified himself as a sitting judge (Getty Images)

WASHINGTON, DC: The Supreme Court on Monday, Oct 5, rejected a Pennsylvania Judge’s bid to restore his job after he was fired for posting partisan content on Facebook.

The case centers on free speech protections under the First Amendment and judicial ethics rules.

Pennsylvania’s judicial discipline Board brought charges against Cohen regarding 66 Facebook posts made on a public profile where he identified himself as a sitting judge.

The posts praised high-profile Democrats, including President Joe Biden and Pennsylvania Gov Josh Shapiro, and advocated for specific political policies, such as raising the minimum wage

Former state lawmaker spent decades as Democratic leader

Cohen spent more than four decades in the Pennsylvania Legislature before becoming a judge and was elected to the judgeship as a Democrat.

Justice Scales and wooden gavel or hammer on wooden surface
Cohen had spent more than four decades in the Pennsylvania Legislature before becoming a judge and ran for the judgeship as a Democrat (Getty Images)

He argued that his Facebook posts were simply an extension of his views on issues of public concern. He also said the lower courts applied an improper standard in upholding his suspension.

“This Court’s guidance is sorely needed,” his attorneys wrote in his petition.

“If allowed to stand, the Cohen decision will have a chilling effect on judicial speech, invite political interference in the judicial branch, undermine the rule of law, and have the perverse effect of impugning the integrity of the judiciary.”

Court filings also show that Cohen lost his pension benefits as a result of his suspension.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court applied a balancing test to determine whether the state’s interest in protecting the integrity and impartiality of the judiciary outweighed Cohen’s First Amendment interests. The court concluded that the state’s interest prevailed because of the volume and tone of his partisan political posts.

Cohen argued that judges are different because they are public officials who speak to the people they represent, rather than ordinary government employees.

 “This Court should grant the petition because it cleanly presents a question of importance concerning fundamental First Amendment protections for members of the judiciary,” his lawyers at DLA Piper wrote.

Micky conitnues to mount his efforts to keep Lisa Trammel out of prison (Netflix)
Pennsylvania’s Judicial Conduct Board brought charges against Cohen regarding 66 Facebook posts made on a public profile where he identified himself as a sitting judge (Image: Netflix)

Court describes Cohen's posts as 'partisan cheerleading'

Pennsylvania’s Judicial Conduct Board called Cohen’s posts “partisan cheerleading” and argued that there was no basis for allowing a sitting judge to engage in such political activity under his First Amendment rights.

“There is no reason for this Court to review that straightforward application of familiar rules that judges around the country have followed for decades,” the board wrote in court filings.

The board is represented by Stanford Law School’s Supreme Court Litigation Clinic.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The Senate vote came after Republicans lost control of both chambers of Congress in the midterm elections, with the Iran conflict emerging as one of the issues blamed for the party’s electoral setback
2026-11-20T06:35:19.000Z
Kirkland & Ellis completed $12 million in pro bono work but rejected requests tied to the Kennedy Center and Trump's triumphal arch
2026-11-20T05:41:23.000Z
The Trump administration had filed the lawsuit seeking to investigate whether voters confused the two candidates and to block certification of the election if GOP Sen Dan Sullivan lost
2026-11-20T04:35:14.000Z
Stephen Miller reportedly pushed Sean Cairncross out over concerns about his cybersecurity credentials, though others described his exit as amicable
2026-11-20T03:10:52.000Z
Republicans warned Trump's energy deal could fund Russia's war in Ukraine, with Senator John Cornyn calling the move a mistake
2026-11-20T02:25:50.000Z
Elon Musk distanced himself from MAGA, and said pouring millions of dollars into the GOP midterm campaign was a 'pretty foolish' decision
2026-11-19T20:59:06.000Z
In an unusual outreach across party lines, potential GOP presidential nominee for 2028 Texas Sen. Ted Cruz said he would be willing to work with Sen.-elect James Talarico
2026-11-19T19:08:52.000Z
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin was barred from TV appearances and placed in a 'primetime timeout' after remarks on recent outages
2026-11-19T18:27:07.000Z
President Donald Trump expressed his displeasure over the failed Iran deal negotiated by JD Vance, adding to the growing tensions between the president and his deputy
2026-11-19T15:46:10.000Z
Donald Trump dismissed concerns over the truth behind US tech outages, saying they were isolated incidents linked to new equipment
2026-11-19T06:00:56.000Z