‘The scheme is working’: Dan Sullivan claims voters regret accidentally backing his namesake

The alleged ploy overshadowed the Alaska election after the New York Times broke the news that Democratic operatives spent months searching for someone named Dan Sullivan to run against the Republican incumbent.
Alaska Republican Senate candidate, incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan (R-AK) talks with members of the media after casting his ballot at a polling location at the Alaska Zoo on Election Day on November 03, 2026  (Getty Photos | Justin Sullivan)
Alaska Republican Senate candidate, incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan (R-AK) talks with members of the media after casting his ballot at a polling location at the Alaska Zoo on Election Day on November 03, 2026 (Getty Photos | Justin Sullivan)

WASHINGTON, D

WASHINGTON, DC: Democrats’ alleged strategy of fielding a candidate with the same name as incumbent Republican Sen. Daniel S. Sullivan to confuse voters may have paid off, or at least that is what a furious Alaska senator is now claiming.

The 61-year-old Republican Senator has claimed several Alaska voters approached him on election day and apologized after confusing him with Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher whose presence on the ballot has prompted a Justice Department investigation.

DOJ even filed litigation to stall certification of election results in the state of Alaska if Democratic Senate candidate Mary Peltola wins the election.

Sen. Dan S. Sullivan (R-AK) arrives to vote at a polling location at the Alaska Zoo on Election Day on November 03, 2026 in Anchorage, Alaska (Getty Photos | Justin Sullivan)

However, a federal judge dismissed the lawsuit, ruling that the federal government doesn't have authority to force Alaska to segregate and investigate any ballots in the three-way race between Sullivan, Daniel J. Sullivan, and Democrat Mary Peltola.

Dan Sullivan claims voters ‘apologized’ to him

The Alaska incumbent was speaking to Fox News correspondent Matt Finn on Tuesday, November 03, when he claimed local voters are apologizing to him after worrying they mistakenly voted for the rival candidate with the same name.

“We’ve been hearing from all kinds of people who are confused [when it comes to casting their ballot],” he said. “I’ve heard from people who think they’ve voted for the wrong guy and have apologized to me. Just like I said, the scheme is working.”

Rep. Mary Peltola (D-AK) speaks during the US Capitol Christmas Tree lighting ceremony on the west front of the US Capitol on December 03, 2024, in Washington, DC (Getty Photos | Kevin Dietsch)

The alleged ploy overshadowed the Alaska election after the New York Times broke the news that Democratic operatives spent months searching for someone named Dan Sullivan to run against the Republican incumbent.

According to the report, individuals linked to Peltola’s campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee allegedly discussed recruiting a candidate with a similar name to potentially draw votes away from the incumbent senator.

Peltola denied any involvement in the alleged plan, while the other Sullivan has maintained that his candidacy was legitimate and that he was not recruited by her campaign.

President Donald Trump also repeatedly weighed in on the controversy, accusing Democrats of trying to manipulate the election. In an October Truth Social post, Trump described the alleged tactic as “CHEATING,” warning that even a small number of misdirected votes could determine the outcome.

Voters cast their ballots inside a polling location at the Bridge of Hope Church on November 3, 2026, in Youngstown, Ohio (Getty Photos | Jeff Swensen)

‘Decoy’ Dan Sullivan missing on Election Day

According to NY Post, ‘decoy’ Dan Sullivan remained missing on Election Day as the Alaska incumbent and Peltola continued holding campaign events.

He did not respond to an email or text message from The Post on Tuesday. His voicemail played a lengthy Halloween-themed message.

Sullivan left his small hometown of Petersburg last Monday, CBS News reported, with a former student spotting him on a flight to Anchorage.

Sullivan’s disappearance came as Attorney General Todd Blanche maintained that the Department of Justice (DOJ) could scrutinize individual ballots in Alaska if the midterm results suggest that voter confusion may have affected Republican Sullivan’s reelection bid.

Asked what circumstances could trigger further DOJ action, Blanche told Fox News' Martha MacCallum: “There’s a scenario where the incumbent, Senator Sullivan, could lose, but really he didn’t lose because of ranked-choice voting. If it’s clear that voters were confused, and again, that’s why you need to preserve these ballots.”

He added that authorities could potentially “look at the individual ballots” to determine whether there was evidence of voter confusion. 

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Marc Elias accused Trump’s DOJ of targeting his law firm, which represents Dem Senate candidate Mary Peltola’s campaign, calling the probe a 'sham'
2026-11-04T03:21:04.000Z
Hakeem Jeffries said Democrats are close to reclaiming House control, declaring, 'We’re on the brink of a dramatic change of direction in this country'
2026-11-04T03:16:59.000Z
Donald Trump said he had the 'ultimate power' to veto bills and welcomed the nickname 'Mr Veto' if Democrats won Congress
2026-11-04T02:52:30.000Z
CNN polling showed Trump had a 34% approval rating in the US, with 64% disapproving of his performance and 73% unhappy with his handling of the economy
2026-11-04T01:35:32.000Z
President Donald Trump’s election-day announcement to end financial support to Israel met with harsh criticism from former Republican and House Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene, who had previously pushed to cut the funding
2026-11-03T21:42:29.000Z
Karen Bass campaign focused on issues such as homelessness and affordable housing, as well as her Inside Safe initiative. The program aims to move people from homeless encampments into interim housing, with the goal of helping them transition to permanent housing
2026-11-03T19:57:11.000Z
Donald Trump said American forces struck a newly completed Iranian anti-aircraft installation overnight after monitoring its construction for over two months
2026-11-03T18:31:30.000Z
On stopping aid, President Donald Trump said Israel was 'fine with it because, you know, they have become a very successful country,' adding that 'they don’t need it'
2026-11-03T17:41:43.000Z
Parts of Indiana and Kentucky are expected to report the first results after polls close at 6 p.m. Georgia, South Carolina, Vermont and Virginia will follow at 7 p.m., as their polling places close
2026-11-03T15:31:18.000Z
Marjorie Taylor Greene criticized Trump for breaking his promise to keep the US out of foreign wars and questioned his handling of the Epstein files
2026-11-03T07:36:23.000Z