Washington teen accused of killing parents and 3 siblings at $1.4M lake house to be tried as adult
FALL CITY, WASHINGTON: Andrew Humiston, the teenager accused of shooting dead his parents and three siblings at their $1.4 million lake house in October 2024, has been pictured for the first time nearly two years after the killings. The 17-year-old was publicly identified as the suspect this week after a judge ruled that he should be tried in adult court.
Andrew will remain in juvenile detention until he turns 18, when he will face trial over the deaths of almost his entire immediate family. The case has drawn renewed attention not only because of the latest court decision but also because of disturbing allegations about the family's life behind closed doors.
The teen accused of shooting and killing his parents and three siblings in Fall City entered a plea of not guilty after his case was moved to adult court. Andrew Humiston, now 17, was 15 at the time of the October 2024 shooting. He is charged with five counts of first-degree aggravated murder in the deaths of his parents: 43-year-old Mark Humiston, 42-year-old Sarah Humiston, and his siblings Katheryn, 7, Joshua, 9, and Benjamin, 13. Because Andrew Humiston is now charged in adult court, KOMO4 TV made a motion to film his face in the courtroom. Judge Veronica Galvan granted KOMO's request and lifted a prior court order restricting the media from naming him. Andrew Humiston is also charged with first-degree attempted murder in the shooting of his 11-year-old sister. Investigators said she played dead before calling for help. Full story here: https://t.co/YPVrOx6C19
— KOMO News (@komonews) November 18, 2026
Andrew Humiston accused of shooting parents and siblings
Prosecutors allege that Andrew used his father's Glock handgun to kill his parents, Mark and Sarah Humiston, and three younger siblings, Benjamin, 13, Joshua, 9, and Katheryn, 7, at their home in Fall City, Washington. Investigators said forensic evidence suggested that his younger brother, Benjamin, had not shot himself and that the crime scene had been staged.
According to prosecutors, Andrew showered and changed his clothes after the killings before using his father's cellphone to call 911.
Andrew's surviving 11-year-old sister later told investigators that her older brother was the one who shot the family, according to court documents.
NOW: A judge allowed us to film Andrew Humiston now that his case has been moved to adult court. He is charged with killing his parents and three siblings in Fall City in 2024. He pleaded not guilty to all charges today. @komonews https://t.co/btmrnkHbCU
— Jeremy Harris (@JeremyHarrisTV) November 17, 2026
Andrew Humiston's parents allegedly controlled children's lives
Police documents described the household as extremely religious and tightly controlled. The parents reportedly dictated who their five children could be friends with and homeschooled them.
Authorities also said the couple was suspicious of the government and medical professionals, particularly when it came to Covid-19 vaccines.
Court documents stated, "Initial reports indicate the home was abusive, tightly controlled, and dominated by extreme religious beliefs."
Andrew's defense attorney, Amy Parker, also made serious allegations about his mother's treatment of the children. She claimed his mother, Sarah, was physically abusive, withheld food, and threatened the children with punishment in Hell if they disobeyed her.
"The psychological abuse was even more intense," Parker told the court.
She also described how Sarah allegedly woke the children randomly during the night and accused them of cheating despite there being no reason for the accusations.
Family pictures show happier times at Lake Alice home
Despite the allegations, neighbors had described the Humistons as a seemingly picture-perfect family.
An old family photograph shows the children splashing around in the lake with their father near their home. The family had moved from Texas to Washington in 2019.
Other pictures show Andrew enjoying outdoor activities. His lawyer described him as someone who liked fishing and mountain biking, with one photograph showing him riding a bike mounted on a surfboard.
Soccer coach Rhea Robertson, who mentored one of the children, remembered the parents differently. Speaking to KOMO News at a 2024 vigil, she described them as dedicated parents.
"Dad worked so hard, and mom was the most dedicated, loyal mother you could ask for," Robertson said.
Inside the $1.4 million Fall City lake house
The Humistons' home sits in a forested area on the outskirts of Fall City, near Lake Alice, a 32-acre freshwater lake known for its rainbow trout and largemouth bass.
The family had reportedly experienced lumber theft shortly after moving into the property in 2019. The incident prompted Mark to install security cameras around the home.
Police said they had no records of previous calls to the property and that none of the family members had been in trouble with the law.