'Why risk Americans' lives?' Republican physician and health chair confronts Trump on vaccines

Bill Cassidy said he could support Trump's FDA commissioner nominee only if she acknowledged that calling the measles vaccine 'lethal' was 'absurd'
Sen Bill Cassidy pressed President Donald Trump to explain the basis for his vaccine claims as the administration faced questions over proposed childhood immunization changes (Win McNamee/Getty Images, Samuel Corum/Getty Images)
Sen Bill Cassidy pressed President Donald Trump to explain the basis for his vaccine claims as the administration faced questions over proposed childhood immunization changes (Win McNamee/Getty Images, Samuel Corum/Getty Images)


WASHINGTON, DC: Louisiana Republican Sen Bill Cassidy, a physician and chairman of the Senate Health Committee, directly challenged President Donald Trump's vaccine messaging during a Sunday, September 20, interview on 'Face The Nation', questioning the basis for the president’s claims and warning that discouraging immunization could lead to more people becoming sick or dying.

Bill Cassidy demands radical honesty

Asked about Trump’s plan to split some childhood vaccines into five doses, Cassidy said he did not know which vaccines the president was referring to or whether manufacturers would follow through.

He called for “radical honesty” from the administration and said vaccines “are safe” and have been proven safe.



Cassidy warned that if Trump discourages immunization, fewer people could be vaccinated and more people could become sick or die from measles.

Republican doctor challenges Trump

Cassidy also addressed Trump’s previous characterization of the measles vaccine as lethal.

He called that claim “absurd” and questioned where the president was getting his information. 

WASHINGTON, DC - MAY 12: U.S. Senator Bill Cassidy (R-LA) questions the witnesses, who were appearin
Cassidy called the claim that the measles vaccine is lethal 'absurd' and asked Trump to explain where the information came from (Getty Images)

“If you really don't have it, why are you willing to risk the lives of fellow Americans?” Cassidy asked.

He said the administration should provide Americans with clear information about vaccine safety rather than creating confusion.

Bill Cassidy backs vaccine nominees

The senator also discussed Trump’s nominees for top federal health positions. 

Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. (L), and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy Dr. Heidi Overton (R), stand in the Oval Office after U.S. President Donald Trump signed an executive order calling for childhood vaccine shots to be spaced out into separate visits at the White House on August 10, 2026 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)
Cassidy said one Trump health nominee earned his vote after affirming that vaccines are safe and should be taken (Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images) 

Cassidy said he wanted to hear FDA commissioner nominee Dr Heidi Overton acknowledge that calling the measles vaccine lethal was wrong.

He separately said Trump’s Surgeon General nominee Dr Nicole Saphier had earned his vote after telling lawmakers that the vaccine is not lethal, is safe, and that people should be vaccinated.

Cassidy said that when someone is willing to tell Americans vaccines are safe, “what else can you ask for when it comes to vaccines?”

Why families are watching

Cassidy pointed to concerns about measles exposure at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, including an incident involving a child with active measles who entered a neonatal intensive care unit.

BOSTON, MA - AUGUST 30:  Anti-vaccine activists hold signs in front of the Massachusetts State House
Cassidy said the president should tell Americans that vaccines are 'safe and effective' (Getty Images)

He also cited four deaths in Pennsylvania discussed during the interview, noting that officials distinguish between deaths caused by measles and deaths associated with it.

Cassidy said the president should tell Americans: “Be vaccinated. It is safe and effective.” 

He added that confusing public messaging could hurt Republicans in the midterm elections because, in his view, women who make health decisions for families overwhelmingly support childhood immunization.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

House Speaker-elect Hakeem Jeffries said he was ready to work with Republicans but had yet to hold extensive talks with GOP leaders
2026-11-21T21:48:01.000Z
The court ruled that proxy votes did not count toward a quorum under the Constitution's rules for congressional meetings
2026-11-21T21:30:53.000Z
President Donald Trump said either an open Republican primary or a unified party ticket could work when asked about the party's approach
2026-11-21T19:28:10.000Z
The Democratic leader reflected on her decades-long career and challenges as a woman in politics ahead of her January 2027 retirement from Congress
2026-11-21T17:45:56.000Z
A prominent Trump supporter who got a tattoo of his face after the Butler assassination attempt said he was 'absolutely done' with the president
2026-11-21T16:44:54.000Z
Ted Cruz and John Cornyn disagreed over the White House nomination for a federal judgeship in Dallas
2026-11-21T08:12:52.000Z
Judge Jennifer Rochon rejected the plaintiffs' request, saying Common Cause failed to prove Trump ads posed ongoing harm after the elections
2026-11-21T07:49:15.000Z
The directive further requires contractors to follow White House instructions to withhold communications that the administration considers protected by executive privilege
2026-11-21T06:48:19.000Z
The FBI investigated claims that Mary Peltola's campaign recruited a similar-named candidate to influence the Alaska Senate election, allegations she denied
2026-11-21T06:25:36.000Z
Donald Trump jokingly asked Stephen Miller if he wanted to run for president, calling him 'the most powerful man in the world'
2026-11-21T04:18:53.000Z