'Why this nuclear option?' Jonathan Turley questions Donald Trump's $355M penalty in New York civil fraud case on 'Fox & Friends'

Jonathan Turley claimed that Donald Trump is facing a 'public execution' as Attorney General Letitia James wanted to 'bag him for something'
Ainsley Earhardtv and Jonathan Turley discussed Donald Trump's $355 million fine on 'Fox & Friends' (Screengrab/Fox News, Getty Images)
Ainsley Earhardtv and Jonathan Turley discussed Donald Trump's $355 million fine on 'Fox & Friends' (Screengrab/Fox News, Getty Images)

NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK: Fox News contributor Jonathan Turley joined co-host Ainsley Earhardt to talk about the verdict of Donald Trump's New York civil fraud case on the February 21 episode of 'Fox & Friends'.

Turley felt that the State Supreme Court Judge Arthur Engoron took an extreme approach, as did Attorney General Letitia James in her attempt to prosecute the former president.

Trump was ordered to pay about $355 million to the state of New York in damages during the February 16 ruling. 



 

Jonathan Turley dubs verdict in Donald Trump's New York civil fraud case a 'public execution'

Turley claimed that it was not customary to use the legal mechanisms in the manner in which it was used to prosecute Trump.

He claimed, "The statute hasn't been used in this way against an individual where there wasn't a crime, the company didn't go bankrupt, the loans were paid off and everyone made money. Even The New York Times couldn't find, in decades, a case that really looked like this one and that's not too surprising."

"You have an attorney general who ran on the pledge to bag him for something. So this was the ‘something’ she came up with," maintained Turley.

(Fox News/YouTube)
Jonathan Turley slammed the $355 million fine levied on Donald Trump in the New York civil fraud ruling (Fox News/YouTube)

He went on to state, "The argument of the court is it was still fraud, even though you didn't cost anyone a dollar… Because overvaluing or undervaluing property is very common in the real estate area."

"But even if you accept that this is fraudulent, the question is why this nuclear option, why this, in effect, a public execution? And the glee that people are expressing that he might have a fire sale of his properties really shows the discomfort that many of us have with this opinion," expressed the legal scholar. 

Letitia James and Donald Trump react to the New York civil fraud case verdict

While Attorney General James celebrated her victory in the New York Supreme Court, Trump called her "vicious and sick," sharing his plan for "revenge."

"Today, justice has been served. Today we proved that no one is above the law. No matter how rich, powerful, or politically connected you are," stated James at a press conference in her Manhattan office, as per Fox News. 

ROCHESTER, NY - SEPTEMBER 20:  New York State Attorney General Letitia James speaks at a news confer
Attorney General Letitia James feels the court's ruling in Donald Trump's New York civil fraud case was justice served (Getty Images)

On the other hand, Trump appeared at a Fox News town hall with Laura Ingraham on February 20 and claimed that the "horrible attorney general" campaigned on "getting" him.

"If I didn't run (for President), I wouldn't have any of these lawsuits. … These are vicious, sick people. … My revenge will be success," asserted the former president ahead of South Carolina's GOP primary.

(Getty Images)
Donald Trump called Letitia James 'vicious and sick' owing to the ruling in his New York civil fraud case (Getty Images)


 

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

A day after President Donald Trump extended his 'complete and total endorsement' to existing Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu, JD Vance declined to support Bibi for the reelection in the October 27 poll
2026-10-20T16:34:18.000Z
Sen Thom Tillis (R-NC) said Russian President Vladimir Putin is playing President Trump 'like a fiddle' by shifting US support away from Ukraine and warned that 'history' won’t judge Trump well if he abandons Ukraine
2026-10-20T15:16:58.000Z
The New York Times reported that Roger Marshall sued over 700 patients for unpaid medical bills during his 25-year career, with 81 later arrested
2026-10-20T06:39:41.000Z
Feds reportedly gathered DNA evidence, govt records and whistleblower tips to investigate Ilhan Omar and her father over alleged immigration fraud
2026-10-20T05:59:31.000Z
Johnson said their busy travel schedules had prevented him from speaking directly with Trump, but he was confident the president would carefully weigh the decision’s implications
2026-10-20T04:44:57.000Z
French President Emmanuel Macron condemned the violence, saying 'Nothing justifies it, nothing explains it, nothing excuses it,' while officials blamed the ultra-left movement
2026-10-20T02:13:27.000Z
Slotkin said that if Democrats regain control of Congress, they should pass major domestic bills and use their oversight powers to investigate major cases of corruption in the Trump administration
2026-10-19T21:23:11.000Z
GOP proposal would allow prerecorded messages and calls using AI-generated voices. Schumer said loosening the rules could make it easier for political groups to spread false information through convincing AI-generated audio
2026-10-19T20:18:09.000Z
The Trump administration plans to redesign Washington, DC's historic East Potomac Golf Links into a championship-level venue. However, the administration says the course will remain open to the public rather than become a private club
2026-10-19T19:50:31.000Z
Trump has denied reports that Wiles could soon leave. But Matthews told MeidasTouch’s Jack Cocchiarella that Trump “is unhappy with the way things are right now” and appears to be blaming Wiles
2026-10-19T16:25:08.000Z