Alan Dershowitz lashes out at ‘redeemed’ Epstein survivor in heated rant

While acknowledging there had been real victims in the Epstein case, Alan Dershowitz had said many accusations were exaggerated or false
UPDATED DEC 24, 2025
Alan Dershowitz pushed back against Greta Van Susteren’s characterization of survivor Maria Farmer during an interview (Screengrab/Newsmax)
Alan Dershowitz pushed back against Greta Van Susteren’s characterization of survivor Maria Farmer during an interview (Screengrab/Newsmax)


WASHINGTON, DC: Attorney Alan Dershowitz took a jab at Jeffrey Epstein survivor Maria Farmer as news reports claimed she had been "redeemed" after documents released by the Justice Department proved she had reported the disgraced financier years ago.

During a Newsmax interview on Tuesday, December 22, Dershowitz began by taking issue with host Greta Van Susteren's description of the Epstein survivor.

Alan Dershowitz calls Epstein survivor a 'total nut job'

Alan Dershowitz said during the interview, "Can I correct something you said? You said that the woman... was vindicated? She wasn't vindicated! This is Maria Farmer. She is a complete and total nut job."

"Of course, the FBI didn't believe her in 1996! She's a complete nutcase except to CNN. CNN has her on every day," he added. Meanwhile, host Greta Van Susteren said, "And apparently to me, because I took the bait too," noting that she had interviewed Farmer.

However, Dershowitz added, "Maria Farmer said she saw me once in Jeffrey Epstein's house before I ever met Jeffrey Epstein! I mean, she sees ghosts! This is a completely non-credible nut case that nobody should believe! Just because it's in the files doesn't make it true!" 

In this handout, the mug shot of Jeffrey Epstein, 2019. (Photo by Kypros/Getty Images)
In this handout, the mug shot of Jeffrey Epstein, 2019 (Kypros/Getty Images)

"The same women, the same, what do they call themselves, survivors who claim that they want transparency. They want transparency for thee, but not for me. They don't want transparency about the women who themselves were procuring young girls for Jeffrey Epstein and getting paid $250. They don't want that kind of transparency," he mentioned.

Additionally, Dershowitz acknowledged that there were "real victims" in the Epstein case but downplayed their stories.

He complained, "Because no congressman, senator, and except for you and a few other people, no member of the media is prepared to get up and say, I doubt the words of these accusers, I doubt the words of these victims, I doubt the words of these survivors!" 

Friend of Presidents, the ultra-rich and the elite of Wall Street's bankers Jeff Epstein remains an enigma to many in the world of finance despite handling portfolio's estimated to be worth over $15 billion. (Photo by Rick Friedman/Corbis via Getty Images)
A picture of disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein (Rick Friedman/Corbis via Getty Images)

Meanwhile, an Susteren said, "I mean, you're telling me that I got it wrong about this woman. I mean, how do I know that? Except that I'm lucky enough to have, you know, booked you."

Dershowitz mentioned, "If you dare, dare to suggest that some of these alleged victims and survivors are phonies, and they're making up stories for their own lining their own pocket, you're called a victim-shamer, and you're called an Epstein supporter. Well, I'm prepared to take that on. Where's the ACLU? They're supposed to defend civil liberties!"

Epstein survivor Jess Michaels says DOJ has broken law

Epstein survivor Jess Michaels believes there will be no more context or explanations by the authorities about the redactions in the newly released Epstein files.

During an interview with CNN, host Erika Hill asked Michaels, "Given the fact that it lasted so long, you and your fellow survivors have been fighting for so long not just for the release but to also have your voices heard. We did hear from Todd Blanche that there will be more coming. Do you believe that it will all come out? Do you also belive that there will be more context and explanation for these redactions?" 

Michael Jackson and Jeffrey Epstein seen together in this photo released by the Justice Department on Friday, December 19. (Department of Justice)
Michael Jackson and Jeffrey Epstein seen together in this photo released by the Justice Department on Friday, December 19, 2025 (Department of Justice)

"No. I think the law was clear that the deadline was 11:59 PM on December 19, and once that time frame was crossed, we have broken the law. The Department of Justice has broken the law," Jess Michaels said.

She added, "I see no dancing around that, no giving levy, because this has been going on, in recent years, for months, since the administration decided to seal everything and close the investigation."

Michaels also mentioned, "For many of us it has been going on for more than 30 years. I have been living with PTSD since 1991."

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The Michigan representative’s anger stems from the death of Renee Nicole Good, an ICE agent, during a protest on January 7 in Minneapolis
53 minutes ago
Senate Republicans blocked a war powers measure limiting Donald Trump’s Venezuela authority after WH pressure, with JD Vance breaking the tie
1 hour ago
'We have been told that the killing in Iran is stopping, it has stopped, it’s stopping', President Donald Trump said during a bill signing event
6 hours ago
President Donald Trump warned that sanctuary cities like New York would lose federal dollars unless they changed immigration policies
6 hours ago
Secret Service agent Thomas Escoto was suspended after journalist James O'Keefe's video revealed sensitive details about JD Vance's location and plans
9 hours ago
In an all-caps post, Donald Trump claimed that sanctuary policies 'breed crime and violence', escalating his clash with local governments
11 hours ago
Federal authorities have placed the FBI in sole charge of the Minneapolis ICE shooting probe, limiting Minnesota law enforcement’s involvement.
23 hours ago
President said federal payments will be frozen starting February 1 for jurisdictions that refuse to cooperate with immigration enforcement
1 day ago
Former President Bill Clinton skipped a House Oversight deposition in the Epstein probe, prompting Republicans to move toward contempt proceedings
1 day ago
White House said protections for Somalis living in the US will expire on March 17, 2026, with DHS Secretary Kristi Noem citing improved conditions in Somalia for ending TPS
1 day ago