Carlton McPherson: Alleged subway 'pusher' has history of mental illness and criminal record since age 16

Carlton McPherson: Alleged subway 'pusher' has history of mental illness and criminal record since age 16
Carlton McPherson, 24, was apprehended after the fatal shoving (NYPD/Getty Images)

Warning: This article contains a recollection of crime and can be triggering to some, readers’ discretion advised.

EAST HARLEM, NEW YORK: Carlton McPherson, 24, has been identified as the suspect accused of pushing a victim to their death in front of an oncoming train on Monday night, March 25.

The tragic incident occurred at the 125th Street station at Lexington Avenue in East Harlem, where McPherson allegedly shoved a 45-year-old man onto the tracks as a 4 train approached around 7 pm. Authorities describe the attack as unprovoked, with the victim yet to be identified. 

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - APRIL 12: Members of the NYPD investigate an incident on an uptown 4 subway aft
The train was unable to stop in time and fatally struck the individual, whose identity has not been released (Getty Images)

Carlton McPherson's disturbing criminal history

With a lengthy criminal record dating back to the age of 16 and a documented history of mental illness, McPherson's troubled past paints a disturbing picture.

Sources reveal that McPherson was previously arrested in October 2023 for assault but was released on bond. He is expected to appear in court on that charge in July, according to reports from the New York Post.

Carlton McPherson was arrested in October 2023 for assault but was freed on bond and is expected back in court on that charge in July (NYPD)
Carlton McPherson was arrested in October 2023 for assault but was freed on bond and is expected back in court on that charge in July (NYPD)

Terrified New Yorkers recall tragedy

The aftermath of the incident caused severe disruptions to subway services, with both uptown and downtown trains experiencing delays. As officers descended on the scene, witnesses expressed shock and sorrow over the senseless act of violence.

"I felt like a pit in my stomach when I heard it, and just felt really sad for the person that it happened to," said Brendan Daniel.

Subway safety measures show promise amidst tragic incident

The tragedy unfolded just hours after NYPD Transit leaders announced their "continued commitment" to "public safety" in the community. Chief of Transit, Mike Kemper, cited recent measures, including the deployment of National Guard troops and State Police officers into the subway system, as part of efforts to combat crime.

"The results of these investments over the last couple months have been encouraging," Kemper stated. The Chief of Transit noted encouraging results, with overall subway crime down by 15.5 percent for the month of March compared to last year.

Share this article:  Carlton McPherson: Alleged subway 'pusher' has history of mental illness and criminal record since age 16