'Not random at all': Elise Stefanik seeks probe into selection of judge Juan Merchan for Donald Trump's hush money trial

Else Stefanik highlighted Juan Merchan’s involvement in other cases connected to Donald Trump and his associates
Elise Stefanik has requested prob in the selection of Judge Juan Merchan for Donald Trump's hush money trial (Getty Images)
Elise Stefanik has requested prob in the selection of Judge Juan Merchan for Donald Trump's hush money trial (Getty Images)

MANHATTAN, NEW YORK: Republican Elise Stefanik, who represents New York, has formally requested that the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct and an inspector general to look into why Judge Juan Merchan was chosen to oversee the trial concerning Donald Trump’s alleged hush money payments.

Elise Stefanik questions 'infinitesimally small' likelihood of Juan Merchan's selection for three Donald Trump cases 

Stefanik highlighted Merchan’s involvement in other cases connected to Trump and his associates, emphasizing the “infinitesimally small” likelihood of one judge being assigned three specific criminal cases.

Stefanik expressed suspicion over the selection process, suggesting it was not as “random” as it should have been.

WASHINGTON, DC - NOVEMBER 15: Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY) questions former U.S. Ambassador to Ukraine
Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY) expressed suspicion over the selection process, suggesting it was not as “random” as it should have been (Getty Images)

“One cannot help but suspect that the ‘random selection’ at work in the assignment of Acting Justice Merchan, a Democrat Party donor, to these cases involving prominent Republicans, is in fact not random at all,” Stefanik wrote in the letter, according to NBC News.

Elise Stefanik: The simple answer why Judge Juan Merchan was assigned is to increase Donald Trump's chances of being convicted  

Stefanik maintained that the decision to assign Merchan, who has donated to the Democratic Party, appears to be a deliberate move to influence the outcome against Trump, the Trump Organization, and Steven Bannon.

(Juan Merchan/LinkedIn)
Elise Stefanik maintained that the decision to assign Juan Merchan, who has donated to the Democratic Party, appears to be a deliberate move to influence the outcome against Doanld Trump (Juan Merchan/LinkedIn)

"The simple answer to why Acting Justice Merchan has been assigned to these cases would seem to be that whoever made the assignment intentionally selected Acting Justice Merchan to handle them to increase the chance that Donald Trump, the Trump Organization, and Steven Bannon would ultimately be convicted," she wrote further. 

Despite these allegations, the authority responsible for supervising judges has clarified that there is no need for Merchan to withdraw from the case due to potential conflicts of interest as some critics have suggested.

Donald Trump gets bored as prosecution stretches closing arguments 

Amid the hush money closing arguments which began on Tuesday, May 28, in Manhattan, the former president seemed to have gotten bored when the prosecution took the turn. 

The defense team concluded its closing arguments after more than two hours, seeking to undermine the credibility of a key witness and former Trump fixer, Michael Cohen by accusing him of lying on all fronts about Trump. 

Trump wrote, "BORING!" as the prosecutor Joshua Steinglass delivered the closing arguments trying to convince the jury that Trump was guilty. The arguments were expected to stretch till late evening. 



 

Internet users were quick to acknowledge Trump's message on Truth Social and give their opinion about the trial. 

"You’re not five years old. This isn’t presidential behavior. It’s pathetic," one wrote on X. "It must be going well for the prosecutor," joked another. 

"Boring is right. Finally some self reflection from the Donald!" wrote one more. "Just wait until you check in at Rikers Island! #LockHimUp," wrote another. 



 



 



 



 



 

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Trump claimed Abdul El-Sayed lacked support and said Haley Stevens tried working with him before breaking away
2026-11-01T07:45:06.000Z
Max Miller's re-election bid faced financial pressure after weak fundraising, while a House Ethics probe and upcoming custody trial added to his challenges
2026-11-01T06:20:42.000Z
Ted Cruz dismissed claims that polls were inaccurate, warning that Democrats were significantly outpacing Republicans in voter turnout
2026-11-01T05:52:43.000Z
Mike Rogers mocked Abdul El-Sayed’s Michigan ties with a birthday basket containing Dubai chocolates, a football, a toy truck and a black T-shirt
2026-11-01T05:30:15.000Z
Alina Habba reportedly secured a $50 million deal with Julio Herrera Velutini's family shortly before Trump pardoned the Venezuelan banking tycoon
2026-11-01T05:22:51.000Z
Trump described Lauren Boebert as an 'America First Patriot' and a 'MAGA Warrior', praising her work representing Colorado's 4th Congressional District
2026-11-01T05:10:27.000Z
Federal prosecutors issued grand jury subpoenas to donors as Mary Peltola denied allegations of recruiting a rival candidate
2026-11-01T04:53:53.000Z
Haley Stevens urged Abdul El-Sayed to apologise for suggesting Israel was behind Michigan's funding problems in schools, healthcare and childcare
2026-11-01T04:24:36.000Z
Judge Jennifer Rochon said the taxpayer-funded advertisement directly urged voters to support one political party over another ahead of the election
2026-11-01T02:42:29.000Z
'President Trump will continue to press forward in his powerhouse lawsuit against the Wall Street Journal and all of the other defendants,' Trump's legal team said
2026-11-01T02:23:09.000Z