Internet agrees Samuel Alito ‘compromised the judicial system’ as Steve Cohen introduces resolution to censure him over upside-down flag

Tennessee Democrat Steve Cohen emphasized holding Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito accountable for the incident
PUBLISHED MAY 24, 2024
Steve Cohen asserted that the flag incident was Samuel Alito's 'shameless demonstration of his political bias' (Getty Images)
Steve Cohen asserted that the flag incident was Samuel Alito's 'shameless demonstration of his political bias' (Getty Images)

WASHINGTON, DC: Nationwide furore erupted last week when reports surfaced that Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito had flown an upside-down American flag outside his home shortly after the January 6 insurrection at the US Capitol.

The controversial display, often associated with the 'Stop the Steal' movement's false claims of election fraud, prompted calls for Alito's censure and recusal from election-related cases. Tennessee Democrat Steve Cohen wasted no time introducing a House resolution to censure the conservative judge for violating ethics rules, as per The Hill.

Steve Cohen's resolution aims to address Samuel Alito's 'knowing violation of the federal recusal statute'

Cohen, who serves on the Judiciary Committee, stated that the resolution aimed to address Alito's "knowing violation of the federal recusal statute and binding ethics standards", which he argued called into question the Supreme Court's impartiality.

The New York Times first reported the incident, revealing that the upside-down flag had been briefly flown by Alito’s wife, Martha-Ann, in response to a neighbor’s offensive yard signs.

Justice Alito has distanced himself from the flag display, claiming no involvement and attributing the action solely to his wife. However, this explanation has done little to quell the criticism from Democratic lawmakers, who view the incident as a clear indication of political bias.

The reaction from Democratic circles was swift and fierce, with many expressing deep concern over the implications of the flag display.

WASHINGTON, DC - FEBRUARY 23:  U.S. Supreme Court Associate Justice Samuel Alito speaks during the G
Samuel Alito has distanced himself from the flag display, claiming no involvement and attributing the action solely to his wife (Getty Images)

Cohen voiced his concerns in a pointed statement, asserting that the incident demonstrated Alito's "shameless demonstration of his political bias".

He emphasized the necessity of holding Alito accountable to safeguard the integrity of the judiciary. "He literally flew a flag in front of his house showing the world he supported the January 6th insurrectionists," Cohen declared.

"What’s more, he continues to participate in litigation directly related to the 2020 election and the insurrection, in direct violation of the federal recusal statute and the Supreme Court’s own ethics rules," he added.

Cohen argued that Alito's actions undermined the impartiality of the Supreme Court and stressed the importance of maintaining public trust in the judiciary.

"There must be accountability to protect the integrity and impartiality of the High Court. We must protect the Constitutional rights to fair and impartial proceedings," he continued.

"Justice Alito should be censured for flagrant breaches of the law and court rules, and he must recuse himself from all other 2020 election and January 6th related litigation," Cohen concluded.

(Steve Cohen/Instagram)
Steve Cohen wants Samuel Alito to recuse himself from  2020 election and January 6 related litigation (Steve Cohen/Instagram)

Steve Cohen's resolution to censure Samuel Alito strikes a chord online

The online community quickly resonated with Cohen's resolution for censuring Alito following the upside-down flag incident.

One user on Facebook commented, "Good. Alito's behavior is inexcusable for a sitting SCOTUS justice whose impartiality is at the very least debatable now if called on to render an opinion about the events of Insurrection Day."

Another remarked, "Alito deserves censure for his glaring violation of all rules of ethics by siding with insurrectionists who rioted based on Trump's lies."

One user demanded, "Alito must be silence and/or removed. He is clearly Biased! He has compromised the Judicial System."

Another added, "Whatever the reason this was done, it was poor judgment on the part of Alito. Something that judges are NOT supposed to exercise."

Another comment criticized the lack of political objectivity expected of a Supreme Court judge: "As a Judge on the Supreme Court, he's supposed to be Politically objective! The next Riot will be at the Supreme Court for Liberty and Justice for ALL!!!"

Additional comments included calls for systemic changes, with one user writing, "The Supreme Court should have to follow all the same rules as any other Court in this land. We need rules and term limits. End life time appointments."

One user pointed out potential double standards: "If this were a 'liberal' judge, the hypocrites in the Party of Trump would be throwing fits and demanding they step down."

Another emphasized the importance of impartiality: "The SC justices are to be impartial and should not show any hint of bias. People should be reprimanded or disbarred regardless of left or right."

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

MORE STORIES

Bernie Moreno pressed Chuck Schumer for a written plan and income caps, prompting Schumer to say 'we can fix that later' before walking out
18 hours ago
Chuck Schumer said the Trump admin’s fight to block food aid and justify flight cuts showed vindictive politics at play amid the ongoing shutdown
1 day ago
John Thune said Democrats’ proposal to extend Obamacare padded insurance companies’ profits and that the only solution was reopening the government
1 day ago
President Donald Trump called Obamacare the 'worst healthcare' in the world, urged its termination, and reiterated his call to scrap the filibuster
1 day ago
JD Vance called the ruling 'absurd' as Donald Trump defended his stance, and the administration vowed to appeal the order for full SNAP funding
2 days ago
Karoline Leavitt faced a barrage of questions on Tuesday, November 5, after reporters learned that Trump had an MRI
4 days ago
Gavin Newsom won big as voters approved Proposition 50, boosting Democrats’ seats and his national profile ahead of a possible 2028 run
4 days ago
Chris Cuomo admitted he wanted Andrew Cuomo to win but said Democrats in New York now want a different kind of leader for their party
4 days ago
Zohran Mamdani was hailed as one of the biggest highlights in a night of Democratic electoral wins
4 days ago
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez praised Zohran Mamdani’s 'heroic effort,' saying his win showed a new generation uniting Democrats to stand up to the admin
4 days ago