James Carville slams CNN host for likening Democrats to January 6 rioters: 'I am not a criminal'

James Carville said that the country is being led by someone who, in his view, is behaving in the same way a traitor would if placed in the presidency
James Carville insisted that supporting a flawed candidate through the democratic process is fundamentally different from engaging in criminal acts (Getty Images)
James Carville insisted that supporting a flawed candidate through the democratic process is fundamentally different from engaging in criminal acts (Getty Images)


WASHINGTON, DC: Democratic strategist James Carville pushed back hard after CNN host Michael Smerconish compared his anti-Trump election strategy to the mindset behind the January 6 Capitol riot.

The heated exchange unfolded on Saturday, May 30, during a debate over Democratic support for Graham Platner, a candidate challenging Republican Sen Susan Collins in Maine. Smerconish accused Democrats of ignoring Platner’s controversial past simply because he opposes President Donald Trump.

CNN host clashes with James Carville 

Smerconish pointed to resurfaced Reddit posts involving veterans and Platner’s previously reported Nazi-linked tattoo while arguing Democrats have a “blindspot” when it comes to candidates who can help defeat Republicans.

Carville acknowledged the controversy but made clear where he stands politically.

(X @smerconish)Michael Smerconish later clarified that he was criticizing James Carville’s willingness to align with 'anybody who’s on your team' against Trump because 'the stakes are so high' (X @smerconish)

“I’ll never get a tattoo because I always changed my mind about things. But I think if you ask me, has he said some things that are highly controversial? Yes,” Carville said.

He then doubled down on his broader political goal. “But what is the most important thing to do in America? And that is to oppose Trump as vigorously as possible at every level,” Carville added. “And the most important tool we have at our disposal is to win elections. Therefore, I don’t know what supersedes that. I just don’t.”

That prompted Smerconish to compare Carville’s mindset to people involved in the January 6 Capitol attack.

“Okay, to me, respectfully, it’s the same mindset that explains people who breached the Capitol on January 6th,” Smerconish said. “I mean, they were similarly warped in their thinking that it’s all on the line.”

James Carville says he is not a criminal

“I completely disagree with the premise. Voting for Graham Platner is not a felony,” Carville argued. “Breaking into the Capitol is a felony, and when you want to defend the objectivity so much that you’re comparing people voting for a flawed person and assaulting police officers.”

Smerconish later clarified that he was criticizing Carville’s willingness to align with “anybody who’s on your team” against Trump because “the stakes are so high.”

James Carville attends the Carville: Winning is Everything, Stupid! Q&A during the 27th SCAD Savannah Film Festival on October 31, 2024 in Savannah, Georgia. (Cindy Ord/Getty Images for SCAD)
James Carville attends the Carville: Winning is Everything, Stupid! Q&A during the 27th SCAD Savannah Film Festival on October 31, 2024 in Savannah, Georgia (Cindy Ord/Getty Images for SCAD)

But Carville did not back down. “Well, again, I might have Trump Derangement Syndrome, but I am not a criminal, okay?” he shot back. “I’ll agree with that and I think my preference is Democrats at every point nominate the most electable person.

Carville ended the exchange by once again stressing how strongly he views the political stakes surrounding Trump.

“I think we’re going to have a good year, but I can’t apologize for that which I profoundly and deeply believe,” he said. “We are being led by a person who, if not a traitor himself, is doing exactly everything that a traitor would do if they got in a job.”

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Jennifer Welch and Angie Sullivan faced mounting backlash after laughing at a joke about the late conservative activist on their podcast
2026-11-10T04:26:57.000Z
'We do not condone violence of any kind, and we are no longer sponsors of this podcast,' a Cash App spokesperson said
2026-11-07T08:51:24.000Z
Abdul El-Sayed said the experience taught him a lesson and added that he was willing to apologize when he made mistakes
2026-11-06T08:33:16.000Z
Donald Trump texted Greg Gutfeld during a live Fox News show, asking him to pass along a message to Jessica Tarlov
2026-11-04T01:54:28.000Z
Show producer Brian Teta said 'The View' co-hosts would skip Halloween costumes in 2024 because the episode fell too close to the election, Joy Behar revealed
2026-10-27T02:48:28.000Z
White House Counsel Will Scharf demanded corrections and an apology from Politico, warning of consequences over three reports on Susie Wiles
2026-10-23T08:46:11.000Z
Joy Behar said she would welcome Donald Trump back to ‘The View’ despite recently questioning his health and saying he seemed unwell
2026-10-18T04:24:09.000Z
Trump addressed the situation earlier on Friday, saying he had personally urged Zacharia to think carefully about whether she wanted to remain in the job
2026-10-16T21:16:07.000Z
An unnamed White House official urged Katie Zacharia to improve quickly, invoking Anthony Scaramucci’s 10-day tenure as communications director
2026-10-15T07:44:56.000Z
Ken LaCorte, who ran FoxNews.com for a decade, accused the network of 'journalistic malpractice' for failing to cover the allegations
2026-10-13T09:14:08.000Z