JD Vance's memoir faces backlash as Amazon and Goodreads restrict reviews after wave of criticism

The book marks Vance's second major publishing effort following 'Hillbilly Elegy'
Vice President JD Vance's new memoir became the center of controversy after review restrictions appeared on websites (Getty Images)
Vice President JD Vance's new memoir became the center of controversy after review restrictions appeared on websites (Getty Images)

WASHINGTON, DC: Vice President JD Vance's latest book has found itself at the center of an online controversy after two major platforms moved to restrict reviews following a flood of negative reactions from readers.

Vance's new memoir, 'Communion: Finding My Way Back to Faith,' was published by HarperCollins on June 16 and focuses on his conversion to Catholicism. The book marks his second major publishing effort following 'Hillbilly Elegy,' the memoir that helped make him a national figure.

However, discussion surrounding the book has shifted away from its content and toward the reaction it received online. By Friday, Amazon had limited reviews to verified purchasers, while Goodreads temporarily disabled ratings altogether, sparking debate among critics and supporters alike.



Amazon and Goodreads limit reviews of JD Vance's new memoir

According to a report by The Daily Beast, Amazon restricted reviews of Communion to verified purchasers only.

At the time, the book displayingreviews on the platform, including six five-star reviews and one two-star review.

Meanwhile, Goodreads took an even stronger step by disabling ratings entirely.

Visitors attempting to rate the book were met with a message stating that "rating this book is temporarily unavailable." Previous ratings were also no longer visible.

Vice President JD Vance speaks during a Turning Point USA event at Akins Ford Arena at the Classic Center in Athens, Ga., Tuesday, April 14, 2026. (Chip Somodevilla/Pool via AP)
Vice President JD Vance speaks during a Turning Point USA event at Akins Ford Arena at the Classic Center in Athens, Ga., Tuesday, April 14, 2026 (Chip Somodevilla/Pool via AP)

The move quickly drew attention online, particularly because Goodreads is owned by Amazon.

The restrictions appeared after a stream of highly critical reviews targeted the vice president's memoir, prompting speculation about whether the platforms were responding to review-bombing activity.

Goodreads guidelines state that ratings can be removed in specific situations, including cases where users are reviewing a book for reasons unrelated to its content or attempting to artificially influence its overall rating.

Harsh online reviews fueled debate around the book

The controversy gained momentum after the X account @HQNewsNow, which is affiliated with former Vice President Kamala Harris, shared screenshots that appeared to show reviews posted before Goodreads disabled ratings.

Several of the reviews were sharply critical of Vance.

"Why would anyone believe anything that comes from this man?" one reviewer wrote.



The same review continued, "He does not uphold Christian values, has lied to all Americans, does not respect his wife & his soul has been sold to the highest bidder."

Another review urged readers to avoid the memoir altogether.

"Save your time and money. Read anything else," the reviewer wrote.

A third critic added, "Dude wouldn't know religion if it or the pope hit him in the face."

Media reviews of JD Vance's memoir were also mixed

The criticism wasn't limited to user reviews.

Several media outlets also offered less-than-glowing assessments of Communion.

The Wall Street Journal described the memoir as "part religious memoir, part campaign book" and said it suffered from moments of "egregious sloppiness."

US Vice President JD Vance speaks during a pre-election rally in Budapest, Hungary, Tuesday, April 7, 2026. (AP Photo/Denes Erdos)
US Vice President JD Vance speaks during a pre-election rally in Budapest, Hungary, Tuesday, April 7, 2026 (AP Photo/Denes Erdos)

Meanwhile, The Cut took aim at the book's overall tone.

"Communion does [Vance] no favors, though, mostly in its sheer banality," the review stated.

The publication added that the memoir was "not even incendiary," while suggesting that Vance occasionally displayed contempt toward liberals throughout the book.

JD Vance tries to keep attention on the book during promotional tour

The controversy comes as Vance continues a nationwide promotional tour for Communion.

One of the most notable stops on that tour was an appearance on ‘The View’ on June 16, where he discussed the memoir and its themes.

During the interview, Vance attempted to shift attention back to the book itself.

This image released by ABC shows Vice President JD Vance, third from left, with co-hosts, from left, Sara Haines, Joy Behar, Ana Navarro, Sunny Hostin and Alyssa Farah Griffin during an appearance on
This image released by ABC shows Vice President JD Vance, third from left, with co-hosts, from left, Sara Haines, Joy Behar, Ana Navarro, Sunny Hostin and Alyssa Farah Griffin during an appearance on 'The View' in New York on Tuesday, June 16, 2026 (Lou Rocco/ABC via AP)

He described the memoir as "actually way less political than you might think."

However, much of the conversation focused on politics rather than religion or personal faith.

The panel questioned him on several major topics, including Jeffrey Epstein, immigration and the conflict involving Iran.

As the discussion continued moving away from the memoir, Vance eventually expressed frustration.

"Let's talk about the book, I'm here to sell books," he said.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Jacksonville International Airport reported 171 flight cancellations over the weekend, leaving travelers facing delays, extra layovers and rescheduled trips
2026-11-17T03:02:03.000Z
Chase customers faced delays in online transactions due to a technical issue, although the bank confirmed that accounts and funds remained accessible
2026-11-17T02:01:25.000Z
Robert and Janice Defilipi escaped with minor injuries but lost their luggage as the American Heritage sank into the Mississippi River
2026-11-16T08:14:32.000Z
NTSB investigator-in-charge Bart Barnum said the tanker experienced what officials described as a 'steering casualty' before the crash
2026-11-16T07:14:58.000Z
Katie Zacharia faced online mockery after sharing a promotional image, then defended its origins before removing the post
2026-11-16T05:01:38.000Z
Musicians from Simple Plan, Hoobastank, and The Used performed some of their biggest hits while traveling to Florida for the Orlando stop of the Vans Warped Tour
2026-11-16T03:33:21.000Z
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said investigators were examining equipment linked to the November 13 communication failure that disrupted flights nationwide
2026-11-16T01:31:18.000Z
Welker also asked whether Americans could be assured that a similar breakdown would not happen again but Duffy declined to make that guarantee
2026-11-15T21:36:20.000Z
The objective is to convince Nvidia's directors to restore Huang to the top position, while also seeking backing from the White House
2026-11-15T20:53:52.000Z
Bessent said the board and its external legal advisers had 10 days to address the administration's concerns
2026-11-15T19:50:15.000Z