Jessica Tarlov questions 'The Five' co-hosts over 'Jewish GOP senators' as she defends Harris over VP pick

Tarlov asked, 'If the Republican Party was such a safe space for them, why are there no Jewish Republican senators?'
Jessica Tarlov confronted her 'The Five' co-hosts' claims that Jewish Democrats have 'Stockholm Syndrome' (FoxNews/Getty images)
Jessica Tarlov confronted her 'The Five' co-hosts' claims that Jewish Democrats have 'Stockholm Syndrome' (FoxNews/Getty images)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: On Tuesday's episode of Fox News' 'The Five', Jessica Tarlov took a strong stance against her co-hosts' insinuations about Jewish Democrats.

Addressing claims that Jewish Democrats suffer from “Stockholm Syndrome,” Tarlov challenged the narrative and raised a provocative question: why are there no Jewish senators in the Republican Party?

Jessica Tarlov defends Harris’ running mate choice 

In the discussion, co-host Jesse Watters questioned Vice President Kamala Harris's choice of Minnesota Governor Tim Walz as her running mate instead of Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, who is Jewish.

Tarlov, who is Jewish herself, responded, “Well, I don’t think it’s because she doesn’t like Jews. She’s married to one.”


PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA - JULY 04: Governor of Pennsylvania Josh Shapiro is seen at the Celebration of Freedom Ceremony during Wawa Welcome America on July 04, 2023 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Gilbert Carrasquillo/GC Images)
Governor of Pennsylvania Josh Shapiro  (Getty images)

Tarlov acknowledged the presence of antisemitism within the Democratic Party but argued that other factors contributed to Shapiro not being selected.

She pointed out issues such as chemistry and Shapiro’s support for school vouchers, which displeased teachers' unions.

Tarlov criticizes Republican Jewish representation 

According to her, labor leaders preferred Walz and Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear.

Further elaborating, Tarlov said, “I don’t think that’s because he is a Jew, I think it’s because he wasn’t as strong on labor issues. A majority of American Jews are Democrats and Donald Trump has, he called Doug Emhoff a ‘crappy Jew’ last week.”

As Watters laughed at the comment, Tarlov sharply responded, “That’s hilarious. Jews find that hilarious… It’s not funny.”



 

Tarlov then pivoted to a critique of the Republican Party’s stance on Jewish representation.

“I want to say something about the Republican Party and Jews. If the Republican Party was such a safe space for them, why are there no Jewish Republican senators? There are nine, they’re all Democrats, and Chuck Schumer is a Jew and he’s the leader of our party.”

She further highlighted that among the 26 Jewish congresspeople, only two are Republicans.

Tarlov clashes with Gutfeld over accusations of Stockholm Syndrome

When co-host Greg Gutfeld mocked Tarlov’s position, suggesting “Stockholm Syndrome” as the explanation, Tarlov pushed back, “Okay, well all of the Jewish Americans that vote for Democrats are idiots to you guys, is that correct?”

Gutfeld’s response was, “You said it,” prompting him to urge Tarlov to retract her statement.

The exchange underscored the intense debate surrounding party affiliations and Jewish representation in American politics.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Harmeet Dhillon said she had contacted White House chief of staff Susie Wiles roughly three weeks before Election Day to discuss returning to her private legal practice
2026-11-05T19:47:18.000Z
Ilhan Omar took an indirect swipe at critics who had doubted their ability to enter politics and challenge the established order
2026-11-05T07:43:44.000Z
Ron DeSantis warned Republicans to rethink their strategy after 2026 midterm losses, saying even George Washington would lose as a GOP candidate
2026-11-05T06:38:45.000Z
'I do believe undeniably that the history and the environment was worsened by the prices at the pump,' Karoline Leavitt said
2026-11-05T05:48:03.000Z
Barack Obama urged Democrats to use their new congressional majority to push for changes and limit the impact of Donald Trump's remaining two years in office
2026-11-05T05:20:41.000Z
Hakeem Jeffries outlined his priorities on affordability, accountability and American values in a letter seeking support from incoming lawmakers
2026-11-05T05:01:06.000Z
Trump spent about 25 minutes discussing White House construction and other renovation projects before addressing Republican losses in the midterms
2026-11-05T04:30:10.000Z
Donald Trump also defended his handling of the Iran conflict, insisting he would not have made different decisions
2026-11-05T04:00:26.000Z
Although Mike Johnson secured re-election to his Louisiana House seat, it remains unclear whether he will complete his full two-year term
2026-11-05T03:31:51.000Z
A White House official hinted Donald Trump could hold Pete Hegseth accountable, saying, 'That will play out in the lame duck'
2026-11-05T02:52:32.000Z