Judge Juan Merchan admits Stormy Daniels is a 'difficult to control' witness as he denies Trump's mistrial bid

Donald Trump's attorney made a plea for mistrial as Stormy Daniels gave a graphic account of her alleged sexual encounter with the ex-POTUS
Judge Juan Merchan presides over Donald Trump's hush money trial involving Stormy Daniels (Getty Images, Juan Merchan/LinkedIn)
Judge Juan Merchan presides over Donald Trump's hush money trial involving Stormy Daniels (Getty Images, Juan Merchan/LinkedIn)

NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK: Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Juan Merchan denied Donald Trump’s bid for a mistrial on Tuesday, May 7, despite acknowledging Stormy Daniels’ challenging demeanor as a witness.

The star witness’ testimony regarding an alleged affair with Trump in 2006 was deemed "difficult" for prosecutors to manage, a sentiment echoed by Judge Merchan himself.

Stormy Daniels rocks the Manhattan courtroom with a graphic testimony

Trump’s defense attorney, Todd Blanche, made a plea for a mistrial during a break in hush money trial proceedings, arguing that Daniels’ testimony was unduly prejudicial to his client.

While Merchan rejected this motion, he conceded that certain aspects of her testimony could have been omitted, saying, "I believe that the witness was very difficult to control."

Throughout Daniels' testimony, the 77-year-old MAGA strongman remained engaged, jotting notes on a legal pad and exchanging words with his defense team.

Blanche contended that Daniels’ assertion of an "imbalance of power" between herself and Trump could unfairly sway the jury, although it was unrelated to the charges the ex-POTUS faces regarding falsifying business records.

In an effort to maintain focus, prosecutors conferred with Daniels outside the courtroom as she resumed her testimony later in the day.

Daniels recounted her initial encounter with Trump at a celebrity golf tournament in Lake Tahoe, Nevada, in July 2006. She described their meeting as brief, recalling Trump’s age being comparable to her father’s.



 

The jury, visibly attentive, was presented with a photograph of Daniels and Trump together during the tournament. She went on to narrate subsequent encounters, including Trump’s invitation to dinner and discussions ranging from her career to sexually transmitted diseases.

Amid objections from Trump’s legal team, Daniels described her interactions with the former president in detail. She recounted moments of humor and discomfort, including Trump’s alleged proposition for her to appear on his TV show, 'The Apprentice', and their brief sexual encounter.

She further described their intimate encounter in his opulent hotel suite, claiming they had sex in the "missionary position." Notably, the presumptive Republican presidential nominee at the time allegedly did not wear a condom.

Despite objections and warnings from the judge about "unnecessary" detail, Daniels persisted in her testimony, elaborating on her encounters with Trump, including subsequent communications via the ex-POTUS' bodyguard, as per the New York Post.

Cross-examination of Daniels is scheduled to continue on Thursday morning.

Pictured (L-R): Stormy Daniels, Donald Trump (Getty Images)
Stormy Daniels didn't shy away from sharing details about her alleged affair with Donald Trump during her hush money testimony (Getty Images)

Internet reacts to Judge Juan Merchan denying Donald Trump's mistrial bid

One expressed, "This judge is possibly the most corrupt piece of work sitting on the bench in America. There are probably others, they just haven't become high profile yet. But this guy, he has his own cheering section in hell," and another echoed, "This judge needs to go."

"He's a paid democratic puppet," claimed a person, as someone else fumed, "Difficult to Control? The prosecutors and the political hack in the black dress wanted exactly that 'testimony.'"



 



 



 



 

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.  

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Trump wanted Maria Bartiromo to replace Karoline Leavitt as White House press secretary, but a key issue reportedly stopped the plan
2026-10-17T16:27:24.000Z
Trump said that the Lindsey O Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act of 2026 lets him reverse sanctions provisions for any foreign person
2026-10-17T15:29:56.000Z
Ilhan Omar has reportedly not been seen in public since Monday, October 12, when federal agents searched her Washington, DC, home
2026-10-17T08:03:31.000Z
Kristi Noem was appointed special envoy in March after her removal as HSS amid scrutiny of her leadership and Corey Lewandowski’s influence
2026-10-17T07:55:06.000Z
Trump revisited Barack Obama’s promise that Americans could keep their doctors under the Affordable Care Act during his rally in Dalton, Georgia
2026-10-17T06:49:31.000Z
DHS Secretary credited Trump’s border security policies for the decline, saying the latest figures reflected his efforts to strengthen enforcement
2026-10-17T06:28:54.000Z
The judge ruled that Brennan lacked standing to sue because he had not shown that officials were likely destroying records relevant to a potential defense
2026-10-17T06:00:57.000Z
Politico’s Daniel Lippman reported that a White House official told him Trump had privately said Zacharia 'had no talent and shouldn’t be on television'
2026-10-17T05:17:52.000Z
The Justice Department rejected the allegations, with spokesperson Emily Covington saying the defense team’s letter contained 'false allegations and inaccuracies'
2026-10-17T04:53:53.000Z
The sanctions pause has drawn attention because the proposed diesel deal could affect Ukraine’s position in its ongoing war with Russia
2026-10-17T04:19:38.000Z