Michael Knowles rebukes Harry Sisson for saying Renee Good’s SUV contact with ICE agent a ‘bump’

Drawing a comparison with what Renee Good did, Sisson asked Knowles 'If I tapped on your shoulder, can you shoot me in the face?'
Conservative commentator Michael Knowles and liberal social media personality Harry Sisson had an on-air clash over the fatal shooting of Renee Good (X/@michaeljknowles)
Conservative commentator Michael Knowles and liberal social media personality Harry Sisson had an on-air clash over the fatal shooting of Renee Good (X/@michaeljknowles)

MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA: Conservative commentator Michael Knowles and liberal social media personality Harry Sisson had an on-air clash over the fatal shooting of Renee Good.

The argument erupted during a recent debate on the PBD Podcast hosted by Patrick Bet-David, where the pair locked horns over the circumstances surrounding the January 7 shooting.

Debate over ICE agent–Renee Good interaction

The exchange gained traction after Knowles posted a clip of the debate to X.

At the center of the clash was Sisson’s claim that Good was “murdered” by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officer.

Knowles wasted little time challenging that description.

“You just said, Harry, that Renee Good was murdered by an ICE officer. Do you not think being hit by an SUV is justification for using deadly force?” he asked.

911 dispatch records reveal a scene of total distress and a lack of coordination between federal agents and local authorities after the shooting of Renee Macklin Good (@Breaking911/X)
911 dispatch records reveal a scene of total distress and a lack of coordination between federal agents and local authorities after the shooting of Renee Macklin Good (@Breaking911/X)

Knowles cited body camera footage and witness reports that documented the moment Good’s vehicle made contact with an agent.

Sisson pushed back, arguing that video evidence suggested the incident was far less severe than Knowles portrayed.

“If you're looking at the footage frame-by-frame... her SUV bumped the officer, which still does not justify [deadly force],” he responded.

Michael Knowles rebukes Harry Sisson

Knowles, however, repeatedly steered the conversation back to the fundamental question of physical contact between Good and the officer.

“Did Renee Good hit the officer with her SUV? Yes or no,” he pressed.

Sisson again described the collision as minor and that it amounted to a “bump." He asked, “If I tapped on your shoulder right now, can you shoot me in the face?”

Knowles fired back, “If you tapped me with your SUV, I probably would.” 



Inside the fatal Minneapolis encounter

Renee Good, a 37-year-old mother of three from Minneapolis, was shot and killed on January 7 during a massive immigration enforcement operation in south Minneapolis.

The raid involved approximately 2,000 federal agents and was described by the Department of Homeland Security as the “largest immigration operation ever.”

Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said agents had been working to push a vehicle out of heavy snow when protesters gathered at the scene, including Good. Officials said she blocked officers using her SUV and refused orders to exit the vehicle.

US Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem speaks during a press conference at One World Trade Center on January 08, 2026 in New York City. Following yesterday's fatal shooting of a woman by an ICE agent during a confrontation in Minneapolis, Noem addressed the Trump administration's ongoing immigration enforcement efforts in New York City. (Photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)
US Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem speaks during a press conference at One World Trade Center on January 08, 2026 in New York City (Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)

According to DHS officials, Good escalated the situation when she allegedly used her vehicle as a weapon. Authorities claimed she “weaponized her vehicle” and attempted to strike agents in what they characterized as an “act of domestic terrorism.”

Video footage from the encounter reportedly shows multiple ICE agents surrounding Good’s vehicle after it came to a stop in the roadway. Authorities said that as Good attempted to drive away, she struck ICE deportation officer Jonathan Ross.



Ross then fired at least three shots into the vehicle, one of which hit Good in the head. Her SUV subsequently crashed into a parked vehicle and a nearby light post. She was later pronounced dead at a local hospital.

RELATED TOPICS MINNEAPOLIS ICE SHOOTING FALLOUT

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Whoopi Goldberg questioned the timing of the FAA ground stop, Microsoft outage, JPMorgan Chase disruption and Apple update-related service problems
2026-11-18T08:07:10.000Z
Jennifer Welch and Angie Sullivan faced mounting backlash after laughing at a joke about the late conservative activist on their podcast
2026-11-10T04:26:57.000Z
'We do not condone violence of any kind, and we are no longer sponsors of this podcast,' a Cash App spokesperson said
2026-11-07T08:51:24.000Z
Abdul El-Sayed said the experience taught him a lesson and added that he was willing to apologize when he made mistakes
2026-11-06T08:33:16.000Z
Donald Trump texted Greg Gutfeld during a live Fox News show, asking him to pass along a message to Jessica Tarlov
2026-11-04T01:54:28.000Z
Show producer Brian Teta said 'The View' co-hosts would skip Halloween costumes in 2024 because the episode fell too close to the election, Joy Behar revealed
2026-10-27T02:48:28.000Z
White House Counsel Will Scharf demanded corrections and an apology from Politico, warning of consequences over three reports on Susie Wiles
2026-10-23T08:46:11.000Z
Joy Behar said she would welcome Donald Trump back to ‘The View’ despite recently questioning his health and saying he seemed unwell
2026-10-18T04:24:09.000Z
Trump addressed the situation earlier on Friday, saying he had personally urged Zacharia to think carefully about whether she wanted to remain in the job
2026-10-16T21:16:07.000Z
An unnamed White House official urged Katie Zacharia to improve quickly, invoking Anthony Scaramucci’s 10-day tenure as communications director
2026-10-15T07:44:56.000Z