Rachel Maddow grills Kamala Harris for saying she would've picked Pete Buttigieg as VP if he weren’t gay

Kamala Harris revealed she would have picked Pete Buttigieg as running mate but felt America wasn’t ready for a Black woman and a gay man
PUBLISHED SEP 23, 2025
Kamala Harris admitted she may have been too cautious in not choosing Pete Buttigieg as her running mate because he is gay (@msnbc/YouTube/Screengrab)
Kamala Harris admitted she may have been too cautious in not choosing Pete Buttigieg as her running mate because he is gay (@msnbc/YouTube/Screengrab)

WASHINGTON, DC: Rachel Maddow pressed former Vice President Kamala Harris​ over a controversial claim in her upcoming book, '107 Days', in which Harris wrote that she would have chosen Pete Buttigieg as her 2024 running mate if he weren’t gay. 

Maddow, who is openly gay, appeared visibly uncomfortable with the remark and referenced Buttigieg’s own frustration, along with reactions from others. As she challenged Harris, Maddow struggled to frame the question directly but made clear the emotional weight behind it.

What did Kamala Harris say about Pete Buttigieg?

ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA - NOVEMBER 21: U.S. Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg speaks to questions during a news conference at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport November 21, 2024 in Arlington, Virginia. Transportation officials held news conference to discuss the busy Thanksgiving Air Travel. (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)
Pete Buttigieg speaks to questions during a news conference at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport November 21, 2024 in Arlington, Virginia. Transportation officials held news conference to discuss the busy Thanksgiving Air Travel (Alex Wong/Getty Images)

Harris shares a candid reflection about Pete Buttigieg in her upcoming memoir '107 Days.' In the book, she reveals that Buttigieg, “would have been an ideal partner, if I were a straight White man.”

She explains that choosing a gay running mate at the time would have been “asking a lot of America.” Harris writes, “But we were already asking a lot of America: to accept a woman, a Black woman, a Black woman married to a Jewish man.”

“Screw it, let’s just do it. But knowing what was at stake, it was too big of a risk,” she wrote. “And I think Pete also knew that – to our mutual sadness.”

Kamala Harris defends her statements in '107 Days'

ASTON, PENNSYLVANIA - OCTOBER 23: Democratic presidential candidate, U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris speaks during a CNN Presidential Town Hall at Sun Center Studios on October 23, 2024 in Aston, Pennsylvania. With less than two weeks to Election Day, Harris spent the day in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania and made a visit to Famous 4th Street Delicatessen to greet supporters. (Photo by Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)
Former US Vice President Kamala Harris speaks during a CNN Presidential Town Hall at Sun Center Studios on October 23, 2024 in Aston, Pennsylvania (Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)

Rachel Maddow pressed Kamala Harris on her remarks from '107 Days', saying, “I guess I'd ask you to just elaborate on that a little bit... it's hard to hear with you, the first woman elected vice president... to say that he couldn't be on the ticket effectively because he was gay, is hard to hear.”

Harris quickly pushed back, replying, “No, no, no, that's not what I said, that he couldn't be on the ticket because he is gay.”

She went on to clarify that her decision wasn’t based on prejudice, but rather on political timing. In a detailed response, Harris explained the high-pressure context of the election and her concern over how Donald Trump might exploit their identities.

“My point is, as I write in the book,” she said, “is that I was clear that in 107 days, in one of the most hotly contested elections for president against someone like Trump, who knows no floor... To be a Black woman running for president, and as a vice presidential running mate, a gay man. With the stakes being so high, it made me very sad. But I also realized it would be a real risk.”

Kamala Harris expresses her long-standing support for LGBTQ+ rights

Former US Vice President Kamala Harris delivers a keynote address during the Emerge 20th Anniversary Gala at the Palace Hotel on April 30, 2025, in San Francisco, California. Kamala Harris delivered her first public speech since leaving office in January (Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
Former US Vice President Kamala Harris delivers a keynote address during the Emerge 20th Anniversary Gala at the Palace Hotel on April 30, 2025, in San Francisco, California. Kamala Harris delivered her first public speech since leaving office in January (Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

Harris went on to defend her long-standing support for LGBTQ+ rights, telling Maddow, “You know, I've been an advocate and an ally of the LGBT community my entire life.” Maddow nodded in acknowledgment, seemingly indicating that she wasn’t questioning Harris’s allyship.

Harris then reiterated that her decision wasn’t rooted in bias, but rather in the limited time and high stakes of the campaign. She said, “So it wasn't about any prejudice on my part, but we had such a short we had such a short period of time. And the stakes were so high.”

She praised Buttigieg as a “phenomenal public servant” and admitted that she may have erred on the side of caution. “But when I had to make that decision with two weeks to go — and maybe I was being too cautious…we should all talk about that. Maybe I was, but that's the decision I made,” she said, adding that the choice brought her “a great deal of sadness,” especially given the risk involved.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

JD Vance cited last year’s March for Life remarks, saying he practices what he preaches after declaring in 2025 he wants 'more babies' in America
15 minutes ago
Lara Trump claimed that Tim Walz and Jacob Frey 'stopped caring a long time ago about their constituents and their citizens'
28 minutes ago
The Kennedy Center is seeking a new soloist after Renee Fleming withdrew from scheduled performances amid leadership turmoil
48 minutes ago
Federal authorities said that the child's father was an immigrant from Ecuador and accused him of unlawfully re-entering the United States
52 minutes ago
The murder rate’s decline follows a period of elevated violence during the Covid-19 pandemic
1 hour ago
JD Vance made the claims during an interview, citing information shared with him by the head of the US Small Business Administration
1 hour ago
After charges were dismissed, Don Lemon said DOJ efforts won’t silence him and vowed to keep reporting despite threats of renewed prosecution
2 hours ago
Keir Starmer also condemned Trump’s remarks as 'insulting and frankly appalling,' saying he would have apologized if he had spoken in such a manner
2 hours ago
Prosecutors argued that the women had plans to flee, knowing that they were under investigation for the January 18 church protest
2 hours ago
Laura Loomer’s public attack on JD Vance highlights growing fractures inside Trump’s political base ahead of the midterms
3 hours ago