The tragic story of Valerie Tindall: Body found on neighbor's yard after 6-month search for missing teen

The human remains, suspected to be of the missing teenager Valerie Tindall, were found buried in her neighbor's property in Indiana
PUBLISHED NOV 30, 2023
Patrick Scott (R) has been arrested after Valerie Tindall's (L) body was discovered on his property (Rush County Sheriff's Department, Rush County Jail)
Patrick Scott (R) has been arrested after Valerie Tindall's (L) body was discovered on his property (Rush County Sheriff's Department, Rush County Jail)

ARLINGTON, INDIANA: Valerie Tindall, 17, was last seen on June 7 and has been missing for six months.

On November 28, a barrel containing human remains was discovered buried underneath a pile of rubble in the yard of her neighbor, Patrick Scott, reported The Sun.

The Rush County Sheriff’s Department has not yet specified whether the remains belong to Tindall, and are waiting for the coroner's report for confirmation.

Scott, 59, who had been previously identified as a person of interest, was arrested and charged with murder following the discovery of the body. He is being held at the Rush County Jail, Rushville County Sheriff Allan Rice said in a press conference on November 29.

According to USA Today, Tindall was last seen with Scott, who also employed her for his lawn care business.

Patrick Scott's property was searched multiple times

Law enforcement officials had investigated the property of the accused with more than 50 search warrants in the last six months.

The Rush County Sheriff’s Department reportedly stated that the human remains in question were discovered on the property less than a hundred yards from the Tindall family home's backdoor.

Valerie Tindall's mom says Scotts were family friends

Speaking with Fox59, the victim's mother Shena Sandefur said that someone overheard Scott telling Tindall that he would take her to Indianapolis for lunch on the day of her disappearance.

“We moved away from Indy to get away from violence. And we moved across the street from her predator,” the distraught mother told the outlet.

Sandefur revealed that Scott acted like a "jealous boyfriend" around Tindall. He even allegedly went so far as to track her phone.

The victim was also friends with Scott's granddaughter.

Patrick Scott misinformed police about the victim

Back in late June, Scott was charged with giving false information to investigators. He was reportedly caught lying and could not keep his story straight about his last encounter with Tindall.

The murder accused finally claimed to have dropped Tindall off in Homer, a town roughly five miles south of Arlington. She then got into a car with an unknown male, he claimed.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Washington County Sheriff Nate Brooksby said that the conditions during Tyler Robinson's arrest were relaxed and comfortable
Sep 18, 2025
DeCarlos Brown Jr, who is accused of fatally stabbing Iryna Zarutska, confessed the reason for the attack in a phone call from jail to his sister
Sep 11, 2025
The former Centerville Mayor is facing three class A felony murder charges, each carrying a minimum sentence of death or life imprisonment
Jun 1, 2024
In a recent interview, Oregon murder suspect Jesse Lee Calhoun's ex-girlfriend, Krista Sinor, recalled his fits of rage
May 19, 2024
Michael Francis described John-Paul Miller as someone who tried to buy love and expected something in return for his favors
May 19, 2024
Ryan Babcock has been indicted on charges of attempted second-degree murder, aggravated assault, three counts of reckless endangerment, and vandalism
May 19, 2024
A student at Kennesaw State University in Georgia was fatally shot by an armed intruder on May 18
May 19, 2024
Jaylin Brazier admitted he panicked and disposed of Zion Foster's body in a dumpster after she died suddenly while they were smoking marijuana
May 19, 2024
Devin Montgomery drew a firearm and discharged it several times at officers who were trying to engage him on May 16 at an apartment complex
May 19, 2024