Trump's birthright citizenship loss is fueling a much bigger conservative campaign

Trump allies say the Supreme Court loss is only the beginning, outlining a long-term strategy to reshape birthright citizenship law
Conservative lawyers and former Trump officials say the fight over birthright citizenship will continue through courts, academia and future legislation. (Joe Raedle/Getty Images)
Conservative lawyers and former Trump officials say the fight over birthright citizenship will continue through courts, academia and future legislation. (Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

WASHINGTON, DC: President Donald Trump's Supreme Court loss over birthright citizenship has done little to slow his allies, who are already laying out a long-term campaign to keep the issue alive, according to a Politico report.

DULUTH, MN - SEPTEMBER 30: President Donald Trump leaves after speaking during a campaign rally at t
President Donald Trump's allies are planning a long-term campaign to keep the birthright citizenship debate alive after the Supreme Court rejected his broader effort to end the policy. (Getty Images) 

At a recent gathering near Capitol Hill, conservative lawyers, former Trump officials and immigration advocates compared the fight to the decades-long effort that ultimately overturned Roe v. Wade. 

Their plans include future lawsuits, legislation, legal scholarship and judicial appointments, while the White House continues pursuing narrower executive actions.

Conservatives map out long game

At a gathering near Capitol Hill, conservative lawyers and former Trump officials discussed ways to keep birthright citizenship at the center of legal and political debate through future court cases, academic research and legislation. 

Mike Davis said conservatives now see birthright citizenship as a decades-long legal fight, comparing it to the campaign that ultimately overturned Roe v. Wade. (x/@mrddmia)

"They turned birthright citizenship into the next Roe v. Wade, that we're going to have to spend the next 50 years overturning," said Mike Davis, founder of the Article III Project, a legal organization aligned with Trump.

Iowa Solicitor General Eric Wessan said the ruling would draw sustained attention from legal scholars, keeping the constitutional debate active in academic circles.

White House presses ahead anyway

The administration did not ask the Supreme Court to rehear the case. Instead, Trump signed new executive orders that narrow who qualifies for birthright citizenship under specific circumstances.

(Getty Images)
The White House has shifted to narrower executive actions targeting specific categories of birthright citizenship after the Supreme Court ruling. (Getty Images)

The measures target children born to foreign diplomatic staff, people identified as "alien enemies" and women who enter the United States primarily to give birth. Stephen Miller said the administration's goal was to reduce cases where people receive citizenship benefits despite what officials consider ineligible circumstances.

Courts remain only one front

Conservative advocates say they also want lawmakers to introduce new legislation, encourage constitutional amendments and make birthright citizenship a priority issue when evaluating future judicial nominees. 

ATLANTA, GEORGIA - JANUARY 19: John Eastman sits in Fulton Superior Court in Atlanta during a hearing on January 19, 2023 in Atlanta, Georgia. (Photo by Jason Getz-Pool/Getty Images)
Conservative legal groups say future court cases, legislation and judicial appointments will all play a role in continuing the birthright citizenship campaign. (Jason Getz-Pool/Getty Images)

John Eastman argued the legal setback had expanded public debate rather than ending it, while New York University law professor Melissa Murray said Republicans were likely to continue testing the boundaries of birthright citizenship through both incremental and broader legal efforts.

Speakers at the gathering said they want birthright citizenship debated in law schools, challenged through future lawsuits and included in legislation and constitutional amendment proposals. Mike Davis also argued the issue should become a priority when future Supreme Court nominees are considered.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The appeal challenged a federal court ruling in Washington that blocked the policy for 28 transgender service members who sued against their removal
29 minutes ago
The meme Trump shared also listed him, Washington, Lincoln, Jefferson, and Reagan as presidents who 'built' the country
44 minutes ago
As per sources cited in a Zeteo report, Miller has shown Harp videos and other content that subsequently appeared on Trump’s Truth Social account
1 hour ago
President Donald Trump tied the naming dispute to his broader criticism of Kathy Hochul and her handling of New York's relationship with Canada
1 hour ago
The judge also criticized Trump’s lawyers for waiting until after unfavorable developments in state court before seeking federal intervention
2 hours ago
Donald Trump said the September 11 ceremony should remain focused on victims and families, while the Times defended its reporting
2 hours ago
The Artemis II crew has proposed to name a lunar crater 'Carroll' to honor mission commander Reid Wiseman’s late wife, who died of cancer in 2020
3 hours ago
President Donald Trump said the venture will boost US energy supplies, cut gas prices and channel over $100 billion into Venezuela's economy
3 hours ago
This development comes as JD Vance and Marco Rubio remain prominent potential Republican contenders for the 2028 race
5 hours ago
The Texas senator was among those lobbying Trump over the location as the president announced plans for the new space academy
9 hours ago