Alaska judge rules 'good-faith' requirement unlawful, clearing way for Dan Sullivan's Senate bid

Alaska judge ordered second Dan Sullivan onto Senate ballot despite voter confusion concerns
State attorneys told the court it was unprecedented to have two candidates with nearly identical names from the same political party seeking the same office (Sullivan for Senate, Brandon Bell-Pool/Getty Images)
State attorneys told the court it was unprecedented to have two candidates with nearly identical names from the same political party seeking the same office (Sullivan for Senate, Brandon Bell-Pool/Getty Images)


ANCHORAGE, ALASKA: An Alaska judge ruled that election officials unlawfully added a "good-faith" requirement to candidate qualifications, clearing Dan J Sullivan to appear on the state's Senate primary ballot alongside incumbent Republican Sen Dan Sullivan.

The decision immediately drew a response from the Alaska Division of Elections, which appealed to the Alaska Supreme Court. With ballots scheduled to begin printing by midday Tuesday, the case is now on an expedited timeline.

Judge rejects Alaska's good-faith ballot standard

Anchorage Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews overturned the Division of Elections' decision to disqualify Dan J Sullivan, a 70-year-old retired teacher from Petersburg, after finding the agency relied on a qualification that does not exist in law, as per the Anchorage Daily News report.

Sen. Dan Sullivan (R-AK) speaks as United States Northern Command and North American Aerospace Defense Command (USNORTHCOM) Commander Gen. Gregory Guillot, Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Homeland Defense and Americas Security Affairs Mark Ditlevson, and Department of War Principal Deputy General Counsel Charles Young III, appear at a Senate Committee on Armed Services hearing on Capitol Hill on December 11, 2025 in Washington, DC.
An Alaska judge put Dan J Sullivan back on Senate ballot, triggering an emergency appeal (Getty Images)

"Because the Court has determined the Division's decision to exclude Mr Sullivan from the primary ballot was based on a 'good-faith' requirement that does not appear in the Constitution, the Alaska Statutes, or the implementing regulations adopted by the Division, the Division's decision must be reversed," Matthews wrote.

Division Director Carol Beecher had concluded Sullivan's declaration of candidacy was not filed in good faith after formal complaints from the Alaska Republican Party and the National Republican Senatorial Committee.

The complaints alleged Democrats had encouraged Sullivan to run in hopes of helping the incumbent senator's leading opponent, former Democratic Rep Mary Peltola.

State argued challenger sought to confuse voters

As per the report, State attorneys told the court it was unprecedented to have two candidates with nearly identical names from the same political party seeking the same office.

They argued Alaska has constitutional authority to administer elections and claimed Dan J Sullivan was attempting "deliberately to confuse voters" by running as a Republican against Sen Dan Sullivan.

The incumbent senator has also argued that the challenger was trying to trick voters. Dan J Sullivan denied that accusation, saying he entered the race because he believes the senator has done a poor job serving Alaskans.

ANCHORAGE, ALASKA - NOVEMBER 08: Rep. Mary Peltola (D-AK) speaks to supporters at a watch party on November 08, 2022 in Anchorage, Alaska. Rep. Mary Peltola (D-AK) is running against former Republican Gov. Sarah Palin and others in Alaska's at-large congressional district. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
Mary Peltola speaks to supporters at a watch party on November 08, 2022 in Anchorage (Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

Matthews rejected the state's argument, writing, "The Director's assertion that Mr Sullivan seeks to confuse or misguide voters is not supported by a preponderance of evidence."

He added that election officials "accepted at face-value the assertions of the complaint, and disregarded Mr Sullivan's assertions."

Alaska Supreme Court to hear appeal

Jeffrey Robinson, Sullivan's attorney, argued that his client met every constitutional qualification required to run for the Senate. He also noted that Alaska regulations already provide a solution for candidates with similar names by requiring middle initials on ballots.

The Constitution requires Senate candidates to be at least 30 years old, have been US citizens for at least nine years and live in the state at the time of the election.

Matthews, who earlier cited the case's "great public interest" when expediting proceedings, issued his ruling less than 48 hours after oral arguments.

In his decision, he wrote that Beecher "found that Mr Sullivan lacked a particular quality or fitness, specifically a 'good-faith' intention, and for this reason alone de-certified his candidacy for office."

"Because the Director relied on a qualification outside of the three qualifications specified in Article 1 of the Constitution, the court finds that the Division's 'good-faith' requirement is unlawful," Matthews wrote.

The Alaska Supreme Court has scheduled a hearing for 10 am Monday as the state seeks to overturn the ruling before primary ballots are printed.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Washington has attributed the Marine barracks bombing of 1983 to Hezbollah, which receives backing from Iran
2026-11-17T21:46:22.000Z
In its response, the NSA linked the problem to routine upkeep of its systems rather than an external intrusion
2026-11-17T21:07:10.000Z
The banking complaints came just days after two separate outages affected technology and air travel
2026-11-17T19:36:25.000Z
'I did not live up to the standards expected of everyone at Nvidia, and I have made serious mistakes in my personal life. I created problems for the Board that I deeply regret,' Huang said
2026-11-17T18:02:40.000Z
Bahrain had also reported incoming Iranian drones on Sunday, November 15
2026-11-17T15:32:56.000Z
The woman's husband warned officers, 'She's pregnant with child,' before they threw her to the ground and handcuffed her while she lay on her stomach
2026-11-17T08:00:20.000Z
The White House move followed the November 13 outage as Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy sought $50 billion for FAA upgrades
2026-11-17T06:46:59.000Z
United Airlines offered free rebooking, meals for delays of three hours or more, and hotel stays for overnight disruptions, but no cash compensation
2026-11-17T05:55:09.000Z
Congress allocated $12.5B for FAA upgrades, but Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said more funding is needed to replace its network and software
2026-11-17T05:52:28.000Z
The widespread system outage impacted fewer than 150 flights, United Airlines spokesperson Leslie Scott said
2026-11-17T04:59:42.000Z