Fact check: Did Kamala Harris’ mom lie on immigration form and render her ineligible for US President?

On August 25, right-wing journalist Laura Loomer posted on X that newly 'obtained' documents could undermine Harris' presidential bid
PUBLISHED AUG 28, 2024
A claim has surfaced suggesting that Vice President Kamala Harris might be ineligible to run for the White House (Getty Images)
A claim has surfaced suggesting that Vice President Kamala Harris might be ineligible to run for the White House (Getty Images)

WASHINGTON, DC: A claim has surfaced of late suggesting that Vice President Kamala Harris might be ineligible to run for the White House because her mother Shyamala Harris allegedly lied on an immigration form about the number of children she had.

The claim has been widely promoted by right-wing journalist Laura Loomer, but it is unfounded and incorrect.

False claim about Shyamala Harris

On Sunday, August 25, Laura Loomer posted on X (formerly Twitter) that newly "obtained" documents could undermine Harris' presidential bid.

"Recently obtained immigration documents obtained by @LoomerUnleashed referencing Shyamala Gopalan Harris, the mother of Vice President @KamalaHarris, reveal serious issues that may lead to Kamala Harris's disqualification as a presidential candidate," she wrote.

According to Loomer, a document from the United States Department of Justice Immigration and Naturalization Service — form I-463 dated August 21, 1967 — supposedly showed that Shyamala Harris claimed to have only one child despite having two children by the specified date.

Loomer wondered why Shyamala would "lie" on an official immigration form - suggesting it could constitute immigration fraud.



 

Examining the facts of the claim about Kamala Harris

According to Snopes, a closer look reveals that the information Loomer presented is misleading. While the document she references is real, her interpretation is reportedly inaccurate. The document is part of a 154-page PDF containing redacted immigration files related to Shyamala Harris.

The file has been publicly available since 2020 and is hosted on the US Customs and Immigration Service website.

The details in the document are rather straightforward: August 21, 1967 marks the date on which the government approved Shyamala Harris’s petition to continue working in the United States as a noncitizen worker.

It's worth noting that her application was filed on January 17, 1967. At that time, Shyamala Harris indeed had only one child. Kamala Harris's younger sister Maya Lakshmi Harris was not born until January 30, 1967. Therefore, the claim that Shyamala Harris "lied" is false; her statement that she had one child was accurate when she submitted the form.

Loomer's post — which highlights the date of August 21, 1967, and the declaration of one child — failed to account for these facts.

(X/@lauraloomer)
The document was shared by Laura Loomer (X/@LauraLoomer)

Eligibility to serve as US President

This is not the first time such claims have surfaced. Snopes has debunked multiple allegations questioning Harris’ eligibility to run for president based on misinformation about her parents' immigration status. However, these claims are unfounded because they misunderstand the basic requirements for eligibility for the US presidency.

Article II, Section 1 of the US Constitution clearly outlines the criteria for presidential eligibility: "No person except a natural born citizen, or a citizen of the United States, at the time of the adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the office of President; neither shall any person be eligible to that office who shall not have attained to the age of thirty-five years, and been fourteen Years a resident within the United States."

Harris meets all these requirements. Born on October 20, 1964, in Oakland, California, she is a natural-born citizen of the United States. She is over 35 years of age and has been a resident of the United States for well over 14 years. Therefore, her eligibility is unambiguous and secure under the Constitution.



 

Even if there were issues with Shyamala Harris's immigration documents (which there are not), they would not affect Kamala Harris's qualifications. This is because the constitutional requirements are based solely on the candidate’s own status, not their parents' paperwork or immigration status.

The evidence thus demonstrates that Kamala Harris's eligibility is beyond dispute, rendering the allegations against her "false."

MORE STORIES

On Tuesday, Senate Democrats blocked the GOP's eighth attempt to reopen the government
12 hours ago
California already allows trans athletes to compete in school sports based on their gender identity
15 hours ago
Pete Hegseth says 'Pentagon access is a privilege, not a right' as top outlets reject new media restrictions and risk losing credentials
1 day ago
Donald Trump said a very wealthy donor offered to personally cover troop pay if government shutdown funds fall short
1 day ago
The six people are from Argentina, Brazil, Germany, Mexico, Paraguay, and South Africa
1 day ago
President Donald Trump blamed Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer for the shutdown and confirmed ending several Democrat-backed federal programs
3 days ago
Donald Trump criticized Chuck Schumer over the shutdown and said he directed Pete Hegseth to use funds to ensure troops are paid on October 15
4 days ago
Several progressives who have long called for a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas have not yet commented on the agreement’s terms or timeline
6 days ago
Trump posted a scathing montage, accusing Democrats of shutting down the government to please their 'radical left' base
7 days ago
John Kennedy is calling out Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer over the tough spot he’s in amid government shutdown
7 days ago