Fact Check: Did Melania Trump plagiarize her UN speech from author CJ Cherryh?
WASHINGTON, DC: A rumor has been floating around that first lady Melania Trump lifted lines straight from sci-fi heavyweight CJ Cherryh’s work.
During her September 23 United Nations General Assembly speech, the FLOTUS reportedly said, “As children, we all played marbles, flew paper airplanes, and ran with a thin string in our hand watching our kites lift off. Great minds have turned marbles into microchips, paper airplanes into drones, and kites into satellites.”
Screenshots that made the rounds on Bluesky and Facebook paired that line with a claim that it first appeared in Cherryh’s 1981 novel 'Downbelow Station.' Some even tossed in an AI-generated “gotcha” claiming Cherryh wrote those exact words.
Context of the claim
Earlier this week, Melania Trump graced the UN stage to introduce her new children’s initiative, 'Fostering the Future Together.' Almost immediately, posts spread online suggesting part of her speech had been ripped from the pen of Carolyn Janice Cherry (better known as CJ Cherryh).
The screenshot in question showed the so-called “plagiarized” passage. Except, even that wasn’t a faithful copy of Trump’s remarks.
“As children, we all played marbles, threw paper airplanes, and ran with a thin string in our hand, watching our kites lift off. Great minds have turned marbles into microchips, paper airplanes into drones, and kites into satellites," the viral version read.
In reality, Trump said “flew paper airplanes" and not "threw paper airplanes." Small detail, but important when your whole case hinges on exact words.
Fact Check: False
Cherryh never wrote those lines in 'Downbelow Station.' Snopes dug into the book and searched keywords like “drones,” “kites,” and “satellites.” But nothing even remotely close turned up.
The actual passage from Trump’s speech reads, “As children, we all played marbles, flew paper airplanes, and ran with a thin string in our hand watching our kites lift off. Great minds have turned marbles into microchips, paper airplanes into drones, and kites into satellites.
"Innovation is wonderful. Our nations benefit from advancements in technology, saving lives, expanding access to knowledge, connecting people, and, of course, safety. Nothing comes before safety. We must safeguard healthy environments for our children, protect their personal freedom, their confidence, and motivation. Safety multiplies innovation.
"Since technology is evolving at a pace that exceeds lawmaking, we must identify simple solutions to protect our children's ingenuity. Remember, our next generation will also teach to revolutionize how we live, travel, design, and connect. The moment is now. I'm establishing 'Fostering the Future Together.'
"A global coalition of nations committed to the well-being of children through the promotion of education, innovation, and technology. Fostering the Future Together's mission is to ensure that every child can flourish in the digital era. I will be hosting Fostering the Future Together's inaugural meeting at the White House during the first quarter of 2026.”
After reviewing the novel in question, Snopes confirmed the inspirational riff about marbles and kites wasn’t in Downbelow Station.
The author herself took to her verified Facebook page to respond to the claim. She admitted she couldn’t recall ever writing such a passage, but winked at the idea anyway.
“Re Melania Trump's speech, I've read the quote, tried to place it within my memory of Downbelow Station, and facetiously suggest I should be given great credit for pre-inventing the 'drone' phenom back in 1980— in other words, there may have been a paraphrase of what I said—I haven't had a chance to look it up," she wrote. "But any recent reader, if you notice any similar passage, let us all know.”
She also couldn’t resist calling out the sloppy viral screenshot.
“I can only say — they say there's no such thing as bad publicity; well, I suppose not. AND BEFORE ALL ELSE...I also know the difference between threw and through [referring to the misspelled and misstated screenshot], ran and run, and would not propose 'a' string governing multiple kites. Just sayin’," Cherryh quipped.
