Fact Check: Will Trump be the first presidential candidate to run for office from prison?
WASHINGTON, DC: After his landmark felony conviction, former president and presumptive Republican nominee Donald Trump is currently awaiting sentencing. Even if this results in time behind bars, it does not signal the end of his campaign for the White House.
Remarkably, Trump won't be the first presidential candidate to run for office while imprisoned. That historical milestone belongs to Eugene V Debs, who campaigned on the Socialist Party ticket in 1920 and garnered nearly a million votes, or about 3 percent, as per Associated Press.
Who was Eugene V Debs?
Debs, born in 1855, was as a powerful advocate for labor rights even at a young age. A dedicated union leader, Debs was first imprisoned in 1894 for defying a federal injunction during the Pullman rail strike.
Debs' commitment to labor causes evolved into a fervent support for socialism. As a founding member of the Socialist Party of America, he ran for president in 1900, 1904, 1908, and 1912. His activism led to his imprisonment in 1918 for violating the Sedition Act by speaking out against American involvement in World War I.
Despite being incarcerated in a federal prison in Atlanta, Debs’ profile remained high. His imprisonment became a rallying point for his party, and in 1920, he was nominated once again as the Socialist Party's presidential candidate. His campaign, although constrained by his imprisonment, gained significant traction.
Debs' supporters turned his imprisonment into a symbol of defiance, using his convict number on campaign buttons and relying on surrogates to speak on his behalf. A film clip of Debs learning of his nomination was shown across the country, adding to his campaign's novelty and credibility.
"The fame of Debs and the novelty of him running for president from prison gave him a sort of purchase," said Thomas Doherty, professor of American Studies at Brandeis University. "It was a credible campaign, considering you're running from prison."
Donald Trump's legal battle and campaign strategy
Trump was found guilty of falsifying business records to hide a $130,000 payment to adult film star Stormy Daniels in exchange for her silence before the 2016 presidential election.
The Manhattan jury delivered its guilty verdict after a six-week trial featuring testimony from over 20 witnesses. Sentencing was scheduled for July 11, putting Trump's political future in a state of flux. The potential sentence for his offenses range from probation to four years in prison for each count.
Norm Eisen, an expert who authored a book on Trump's 2020 election-related federal indictment and served as special counsel during Trump's first impeachment, analyzed similar cases prosecuted by the Manhattan district attorney's office.
He found that roughly 10% resulted in imprisonment, though the unique circumstances of Trump's case made comparisons challenging. Alternative sentences, such as home detention with an ankle bracelet, are also possible. This option would allow Trump to avoid jail time but remain under strict monitoring.
The road ahead for Donald Trump's campaign
Despite the looming possibility of imprisonment, Trump's campaign machinery continues to function. His conviction added a dramatic twist to an already controversial political journey.
Debs, though influential, was a fringe candidate, whereas Trump has already served as president and is the near-certain nominee of a major political party. The Republican Party faces a unique situation: rallying behind a convicted candidate whose legal troubles could either strengthen his base or create major challenges.
Trump's legal team and political advisors are preparing for all contingencies. The campaign could adopt strategies similar to Debs', utilizing surrogates and media appearances to maintain visibility and momentum.
