'Guilty as sin': Internet shreds Donald Trump as hush money trial judge calls him out for making false claims about gag order

Judge Juan Merchan refuted Donald Trump's claim, emphasizing that the gag order does not prevent him from taking the stand in the hush money trial
PUBLISHED MAY 5, 2024
Donald Trump claimed a gag order prevented him from testifying in the hush money trial (Getty Images)
Donald Trump claimed a gag order prevented him from testifying in the hush money trial (Getty Images)

NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK: Donald Trump, who previously asserted his willingness to testify in his own defense during the hush money trial, claimed he is unable to do so due to a gag order on Thursday, May 2.

Addressing reporters outside the courtroom, the ex-POTUS said, "I’m not allowed to testify. I’m under a gag order. I’m not allowed to testify because this judge who’s totally conflicted, has me under an unconstitutional gag order."

(Juan Merchan/LinkedIn, Getty Images)
Judge Juan Merchan clarified that the gag order imposed on Donald Trump doesn't prohibit him from testifying (Juan Merchan/LinkedIn, Getty Images)

Judge corrects misunderstanding surrounding Donald Trump's ability to take the stand in hush money trial

Judge Juan Merchan swiftly corrected Trump's assertion, clarifying that the gag order "only applies to extrajudicial statements" and "does not prohibit you from taking the stand."

CNN's fact-check reporter Daniel Dale also debunked the former president's assertion while talking to Jake Tapper, host of 'The Lead', on the same day. 

Dale asserted, "That is just a lie," noting that Trump is "absolutely permitted to testify in his own defense and this false claim, this lie, is part of a pattern of former President Trump grossly exaggerating what the gag order actually says."



 

Under the terms of the gag order, Trump is restricted from discussing certain aspects of the case, such as jurors, potential witnesses, and court staff.

However, he remains free to address other aspects, including individuals involved in the trial, such as Judge Merchan and Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg, both of whom have faced Trump's criticism.

Dale further stated, "So this claim that the gag order means he can’t testify, it’s just conjured out of thin air," adding, "Trump has gone from saying that he will testify, to he maybe will testify, to if it’s necessary, to now, ‘Whoa, whoa, I can’t testify, it’s out of my hands.’ But it’s in his hands. He can testify and he’s just making stuff up."

The ex-POTUS' potential testimony would mark a significant moment in legal proceedings, considering the rarity of former presidents testifying in court.

Trump, who finds himself embroiled in a legal battle with 34 criminal counts, has previously shown reluctance to testify in various instances, including the E Jean Carroll defamation trial and the second impeachment trial.

The ongoing hush money trial revolves around Trump falsifying business records to bury a $130,000 payment made to Stormy Daniels in 2016 with the help of his former attorney, Michael Cohen, ahead of the presidential election.

Daniels and Cohen are both expected to testify in the trial in which Trump's defense team, led by attorneys Todd Blanche and Susan Necheles, faces off against prosecutors Susan Hoffinger and Joshua Steinglass, representing Manhattan DA Bragg.

(Getty Images)
Donald Trump claimed Judge Juan Merchan had imposed an 'unconstitutional gag order' on him (Getty Images)

Internet reacts to Donald Trump claiming he can't testify in hush money trial due to gag order

One noted, "You don't have to be a Havard Law graduate to know that a gag order has nothing to do with testifying in court. Yet Mar-a-Lago Fats @realDonaldTrump had to lie about this, too."

"Hey MAGAs your boy was caught lying as usual. You should all be so proud," wrote another and a person added, "He’s a chicken s***. He won’t even testify on his own behalf. We know he’s guilty as sin."

Someone else declared, "TRUMP IS TRAPPED!!!!!!" "I don’t know how anyone thinks this p***k is tough, he’s a coward who uses everyone to do his bidding and then leaves them hanging. He’s a fraud and a coward. he won’t take the stand, FRAUD," fumed an individual. 



 



 



 



 



 

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online. 

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Most Americans doubt the integrity of the 2026 midterms, with skepticism fueled by Trump’s push for a federal role in state elections
2 hours ago
Republicans said the airport should bear Trump’s name since he made Florida his permanent residence, becoming the first president to do so
4 hours ago
Trump joked that he briefly considered awarding himself the Congressional Medal of Honor, the nation’s highest military honor
4 hours ago
Trump says his pressure tactics and tariff threats forced Macron to raise drug prices, lowering costs for Americans
4 hours ago
Trump personally corrected a supporter’s Presidential Lifetime Award, claiming Biden’s signature was an autopen and lacked authenticity
5 hours ago
Trump framed the legislation as an election integrity measure and accused Democrats of resisting voter ID rules for partisan reasons
5 hours ago
President Donald Trump spoke for more than an hour at Coosa Steel Corporation, which he said benefited from his aggressive tariff policies
6 hours ago
Trump’s move sparks praise from House Oversight Republicans, signaling a push for transparency on UFOs and extraterrestrial life
6 hours ago
The banner features the slogan 'Make America Safe Again,' reflecting the administration’s focus on violent crime and immigration enforcement
6 hours ago
Trump labeled Kamala Harris and Joe Biden as 'morons' while emphasizing that his 2020 election victory was crucial for the nation’s survival
7 hours ago