Jonathan Turley discusses Trump's conviction with Jeanine Pirro, calls hush money trial 'abuse' of justice system

Jeanine Pirro shared the path that lies ahead for Donald Trump's defense team as Jonathan Turley calls his conviction in hush money trial 'popular justice' of Manhattan
PUBLISHED JUN 2, 2024
Jonathan Turley and Jeanine Pirro discussed the conviction of Donald Trump in the hush money trial on May 31, 2024 (Screengrab/Fox News and Getty Images)
Jonathan Turley and Jeanine Pirro discussed the conviction of Donald Trump in the hush money trial on May 31, 2024 (Screengrab/Fox News and Getty Images)

NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK: Fox News contributor Jonathan Turley and 'The Five' host Judge Jeanine Pirro discussed the guilty verdict against former president Donald Trump in the criminal hush money trial on the Friday, May 31 episode of 'America Reports'. 

Trump was unanimously found guilty by a 12-member jury panel on 34 felony counts of falsifying business records. The verdict is made historic by the fact that it is the first time a former president of the United States has been convicted of a crime.

The penalties faced by Trump on each count include a fine and up to four years in prison. The presumptive GOP nominee is scheduled to be sentenced on July 11, four days ahead of the Republican National Convention.

Former President Donald Trump and his attorney Todd Blanche exit the courthouse and speak to media after Trump was found guilty following his hush money trial at Manhattan Criminal Court on May 30, 2024 in New York City. The former president was found guilty on all 34 felony counts of falsifying business records in the first of his criminal cases to go to trial. Trump has now become the first former U.S. president to be convicted of felony crimes. (Photo by Mark Peterson - Pool/Getty Images)
Donald Trump and his attorney Todd Blanche exit the courthouse and speak to media after the former president was found guilty following his hush money trial at Manhattan Criminal Court on May 30, 2024, in New York City (Mark Peterson - Pool/Getty Images)

Jeanine Pirro's take on legal recourses for Trump moving forward

Jeanine Pirro mentioned that Donald Trump's defense team has the opportunity to make a motion for post-conviction in front of Judge Juan Merchan stating that the verdict goes against the evidence, but felt it would not be enough to offer them any relief.

"Once the sentencing occurs, they can appeal to the Appellate Court to try to stay that sentencing until the appeal has been ended or perfected," she said. "The appellate division handles it first, and it would probably take from six months to a year (before) moving to the Court of Appeals."

"Although Mark Levin is talking about possibly taking it to the Supreme Court on a Common Writ ... But the normal process would be (Trump) would be sentenced on the 11. There is a wide panel of sentencing options that Judge Merchan has ... From four years (in prison) max on class E felony counts to simply suspending a sentence or saying there will be no punishment in terms of jail time but simple probation or maybe even a conditional discharge," Pirro added.



 

Jonathan Turley's take on Donald Trump's conviction

Turley claimed that the conviction of Donald Trump was simply "popular justice" and not something that is expected of a well-functioning legal system.

"Well, there's an irony, of course, because you just had a special counsel (Robert Hur) who said, I'm not indicting the president (Joe Biden) because he's an elderly man with a failing memory… So there is that irony," he said.

"Look, we agree on this, the justice system being the touchstone of all Americans. But this was an abuse," continued Turley.

"And I think that people who are fair-minded would say this was a basically popular justice of Manhattan, but it wasn't the justice we look forward to in our legal system."

MORE STORIES

Chuck Schumer said the Trump admin’s fight to block food aid and justify flight cuts showed vindictive politics at play amid the ongoing shutdown
5 hours ago
John Thune said Democrats’ proposal to extend Obamacare padded insurance companies’ profits and that the only solution was reopening the government
6 hours ago
President Donald Trump called Obamacare the 'worst healthcare' in the world, urged its termination, and reiterated his call to scrap the filibuster
9 hours ago
JD Vance called the ruling 'absurd' as Donald Trump defended his stance, and the administration vowed to appeal the order for full SNAP funding
1 day ago
Karoline Leavitt faced a barrage of questions on Tuesday, November 5, after reporters learned that Trump had an MRI
3 days ago
Gavin Newsom won big as voters approved Proposition 50, boosting Democrats’ seats and his national profile ahead of a possible 2028 run
3 days ago
Chris Cuomo admitted he wanted Andrew Cuomo to win but said Democrats in New York now want a different kind of leader for their party
3 days ago
Zohran Mamdani was hailed as one of the biggest highlights in a night of Democratic electoral wins
3 days ago
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez praised Zohran Mamdani’s 'heroic effort,' saying his win showed a new generation uniting Democrats to stand up to the admin
3 days ago
Zohran Mamdani wins 2025 NYC mayoral race, becoming first South Asian to lead the city
3 days ago