Judge shuts down WHCD shooter's bid to remove Jeanine Pirro and Todd Blanche from prosecution

Defense lawyers argued prosecutors were conflicted after attending the event where Allen allegedly plotted attacks on President Trump and officials
US District Judge Trevor McFadden rejected alleged WHCD gunman Cole Tomas Allen's bid to remove senior Trump administration Justice officials from his criminal case (Cole Allen/LinkedIn)
US District Judge Trevor McFadden rejected alleged WHCD gunman Cole Tomas Allen's bid to remove senior Trump administration Justice officials from his criminal case (Cole Allen/LinkedIn)

WASHINGTON, DC: A federal judge has dealt a decisive procedural blow to alleged White House Correspondents' Dinner gunman Cole Tomas Allen, flatly rejecting his high-stakes legal gambit to force the Trump administration’s highest-profile justice officials off the case.

In an 18-page opinion issued on Monday, June 22, in the afternoon, US District Judge Trevor McFadden denied the defense’s motion to disqualify Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche and Washington US Attorney Jeanine Pirro from leading the high-profile courtroom drama.

Defense lawyers had aggressively argued that both prosecutors were hopelessly compromised due to their personal attendance at the April 25 black-tie press gala, where the 31-year-old California schoolteacher allegedly attempted to execute a sweeping assassination plot against President Donald J Trump and his cabinet.

WASHINGTON, DC - APRIL 16: U.S. District Judge Trevor McFadden walks outside the E. Barrett Prettyman United States Court House on April 16, 2025 in Washington, DC. McFadden, appointed by U.S. President Donald Trump, has recently sided with the Associated Press, ordering the White House to reinstate their access to presidential coverage. (Photo by Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)
The court ruled there was no legal basis to disqualify senior Justice Department officials from overseeing the politically charged prosecution (Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)

The defense team raised grave concerns that Pirro’s personal friendship with the president and the prosecutors' proximity to the exchange of gunfire transformed them into trial witnesses or legal victims.

However, McFadden dismantled that theory, ruling that the only individuals proximately harmed were Trump and the Secret Service agent struck in his ballistic vest, leaving zero structural basis to screen the primary justice leadership from the prosecution.

Judge preserves administration's lead trial team 



"They are unlikely to be trial witnesses, nor do they meet the legal definition of victims," McFadden wrote, preserving the administration's premier trial team.

The decision keeps the case moving smoothly toward a massive evidentiary discovery phase expected to yield gigabytes of digital forensic logs.

According to federal indictments, Allen traveled across state lines armed with a 12-gauge pump-action shotgun, a semi-automatic handgun, and multiple knives, booking a room ten stories above the Hilton ballroom.

Minutes before sprinting through the upper-level security checkpoint at nine miles per hour, Allen allegedly distributed a digital manifesto under the alias "Friendly Federal Assassin," explicitly listing 13 cabinet officials in the line of presidential succession as his primary targets.

Prosecution pursues potential life sentence case

Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche speaks to a reporter outside the White House, Wednesday, May 27, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein)
Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche speaks to a reporter outside the White House, Wednesday, May 27, 2026, in Washington (AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein)

The ruling allows Pirro and Blanche to maintain total executive command over the multi-count prosecution, which carries a maximum penalty of life in prison.

Both officials had previously joined the president for an immediate West Wing press conference hours after the suspect was subdued on the magnetometer floor.

Following Monday's judicial victory, Pirro re-emphasized that the Justice Department will show zero tolerance for individuals who travel to the District of Columbia to engage in antielection or anti-democratic acts of political violence.

With the suspect already pleading not guilty to charges of attempted presidential assassination and assault on a federal officer, the court's refusal to mandate an administrative recusal ensures the White House maintains an ironclad grip on the legal narrative.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Trump signed executive orders expanding access to federal lands for hunters and anglers and easing certain fishing and boating restrictions
23 minutes ago
Donald Trump called the Kennedy Center 'very dangerous,' while Joyce Beatty’s lawyers warned its temporary closure could become a two-year shutdown
1 hour ago
President Trump said in an interview that he faced a major decision ahead of a meeting with six Gulf leaders
5 hours ago
Marjorie Taylor Greene's criticism extended beyond the Iran war and fuel prices in her Thursday video message
7 hours ago
The senators are seeking details on military operations, damaged bases, and depleted equipment after seven months of fighting
8 hours ago
The legal fight centers on Trump's effort to put his name on the Kennedy Center, which a judge blocked
10 hours ago
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said the US was open to discussing AI risks with China during upcoming meetings in New York
11 hours ago
During his remarks, Donald Trump discussed North Carolina’s crime rates and its response to Hurricane Helene in 2024 before bringing up Lara Trump
18 hours ago
Nancy Mace said her vote reflected GOP vulnerability, adding that she was surprised more Republicans did not support the Iran war powers resolution
19 hours ago
Donald Trump called Iryna Zarutska’s fatal stabbing on a train disturbing, saying he had watched security footage of the attack several times
20 hours ago