Kash Patel’s tribute to Charlie Kirk could complicate prosecution of suspect, warns legal expert

WASHINGTON, DC: FBI Director Kash Patel’s farewell words to slain conservative activist Charlie Kirk, saying he would see him “in Valhalla,” could complicate the case against the suspect accused of killing him, a former prosecutor warned on Saturday, September 13.

The remarks, made after Tyler Robinson was arrested for Kirk's fatal shooting at Utah Valley University, sparked debate both in legal circles and online.

Kash Patel’s tribute could impact impartiality in court

Speaking on CNN, Robert James, former district attorney for DeKalb County in Georgia, said comments such as the one made by Kash Patel complicate high-profile cases like Charlie Kirk's.

“You have to be careful when you're running an investigation as a law enforcement officer,” said James. 

“Impartiality is very important when you're looking at facts and determining who did what, what the motivation was, and that sort of thing," the former district attorney added.

James further mentioned, "So you never want to put yourself in a position where lawyers get involved and then you open yourself up to cross-examination in a courtroom about your perception or perspective, and it happens in high-profile homicide cases all the time.”

He pointed to examples from his own experience.

“For instance, I've prosecuted cases where police officers were killed, and the same police department investigated those cases and it's always a question when the officers are on the stand, whether or not their opinions are slanted or motivated by the grief or anger of what happened, and so it's the same type of scenario here, so you have to be careful,” James stressed.

Kash Patel faces criticism for handling of Charlie Kirk's case

Charlie Kirk was shot and killed on Wednesday while speaking at Utah Valley University. The suspect, 22-year-old Utah resident Tyler Robinson, was apprehended on Friday after his family turned him in.

At a press conference after Robinson’s arrest, Patel said, “To my friend Charlie Kirk, rest now brother, we have the watch and I’ll see you in Valhalla.”

The comments drew attention partly because Patel is Hindu and Kirk was an evangelical Christian.

On top of that, Patel had already faced criticism for his role in the case. Shortly after Kirk's death on Wednesday, he issued a statement claiming that the shooter was in custody but soon retracted it. The information turned out not to be true, and Robinson was arrested more than a day later.

MAGA conservators join list of critics

Among those voicing concern about Kash Patel’s handling of the case were conservative figures Christopher Rufo, Erick Erickson, and Steve Bannon.

They joined a chorus of critics who accused the FBI director of mismanaging the investigation and raising doubts about the bureau’s impartiality.

Rufo, an influential right-wing activist and senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, a conservative think tank, posted on X (formerly Twitter) on Friday that it was “time for Republicans to assess whether Kash Patel is the right man to run the FBI.”

“We would be wise to take a moment and ask whether Kash Patel has what it takes to get this done,” Rufo wrote.

“I’ve been on the phone the last few days with many conservative leaders, all of whom wholeheartedly support the Trump Administration and none of whom are confident that the current structure of the FBI is up to this task," he added.

 Erickson responded in support of the sentiment, writing, “He’s right. The FBI situation is concerning.”

Banon also criticized the FBI's role while speaking on 'Bannon’s War Room'.

On the arrest of Robinson, the former Donald Trump advisor said, “It appears the kid had said something to the family, the family confronted him, and the family turned him in. I’m not seeing the great law enforcement work. They all came together, I got that. But this was not great law enforcement work.”