'MAGA clown show': Trump trolled after lawyers subpoena wrong 'Jeremy Rosenberg' ahead of hush money trial

The mishap, unveiled by prosecutors on April 9, has drawn attention to a Brooklyn man entirely unrelated to the impending trial
Donald Trump's lawyer's attempt to subpoena crucial evidence in the hush money case went hilariously awry as court papers were served to the wrong individual (Getty Images)
Donald Trump's lawyer's attempt to subpoena crucial evidence in the hush money case went hilariously awry as court papers were served to the wrong individual (Getty Images)

NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK: In a bizarre twist to the legal saga surrounding former President Donald Trump, his lawyer's attempt to subpoena crucial evidence in the "hush money" case went hilariously awry as court papers were mistakenly served to the wrong individual.

The mishap, unveiled by prosecutors on Tuesday, April 9, has drawn attention to a Brooklyn man entirely unrelated to the impending trial.

A comedic turn of events

The fiasco unfolded when Todd Blanche, representing Trump in the ongoing legal battle, dispatched a subpoena in March purportedly targeting Jeremy Rosenberg, a former District Attorney Supervising Rackets Investigator.

The subpoena aimed to procure files pertinent to Trump's one-time confidant-turned-adversary, Michael Cohen.

However, the recipient of the subpoena turned out to be a different Jeremy Rosenberg, a Brooklyn resident who had nothing to do with the case.

Amusingly, the misidentified Rosenberg responded to Trump's legal team, stating, "I don't have any files for you," in what seemed like a lighthearted exchange.

He further noted that the provided phone number was disconnected and humorously indicated his intent to keep the $15 intended to cover the delivery expenses.

Blanche, a seasoned former prosecutor, expressed dissatisfaction earlier this week, accusing the man they believed to be Rosenberg of displaying a "flippant and dismissive approach" to the request  “despite ample experience with the criminal justice system that should have instilled in him respect for this process and a criminal defendant’s rights.”

However, prosecutors clarified that Trump's lawyers had indeed served court papers on the wrong individual.

Matthew Colangelo, representing the prosecution, affirmed the error in a filing, stating, "The people believe the defendant has served the incorrect person."

“The people spoke with Mr Rosenberg’s counsel, who informed the People that Mr. Rosenberg was not, in fact, served with the subpoena, that Mr Rosenberg had not corresponded with defense counsel, and that Mr. Rosenberg does not have any connection to the Brooklyn address where the subpoena purportedly was served,” Colangelo added.



 

The impending trial, slated for jury selection on April 15, revolves around allegations of Trump's involvement in concealing payments made before the 2016 election to silence adult film actress Stormy Daniels about an alleged affair.

Trump, aged 77, has pleaded not guilty to 34 counts of falsifying business records, each carrying a potential prison sentence of up to four years.

Trump's legal team intends to seek communication records between Rosenberg and Cohen from February 2021 to May. Rosenberg, previously entangled in controversy over communications with Cohen, was suspended pending investigation by Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg’s office.

Despite the suspension, Rosenberg’s interactions were lauded by Cohen's lawyer Lanny J Davis as “always professional and focused on Mr. Cohen’s personal security, which we appreciated."

Rosenberg's legal involvement extends beyond the Trump-Cohen saga. He contributed to the prosecution of Steve Bannon in an alleged $15 million border wall fundraising scam, for which Trump later pardoned Bannon. Additionally, Rosenberg played a role in recent investigations into cryptocurrency and dark web drug trafficking, as acknowledged by Bragg’s office.

Cohen, once a staunch ally of Trump, turned against him, cooperating with investigations following his imprisonment for campaign finance violations and perjury. Trump subsequently launched a $500 million lawsuit against Cohen for defamation and breach of confidentiality, the New York Post reported.

Social media reactions to the faux pas

Social media erupted with reactions following revelations of the erroneous subpoena. Users mocked the blunder, with one sarcastically remarking that Trump hires "only the best people."

"Beautiful. ONLY THE BEST PEOPLE," one posted on X.

"Bahah maga clown show," another wrote.

"Another Alina Habba level W," a comment read.

"I would have sent them a bunch of printed-out Trump tweets and truths," someone else quipped.

"Well, they got to wrap this up before November or the Kangaroos get paid overtime," another added.



 



 



 



 



 

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online. 

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Rosie O'Donnell repeatedly criticized Trump during her monologues, reviving a feud dating to her 2006-07 'The View' stint and his 2016 attacks
2 hours ago
Vance said earlier generations made his life possible, adding that Black, white, rich and poor Americans built the country together across generations
3 hours ago
Ken Paxton is facing a tight race against Democrat James Talarico, raising donor fears that Democrats could score a major win in the deep-red state
4 hours ago
National Cattlemen's Beef Association's CEO Colin Woodall warned that subsidized, below-market beef would not rebuild the US herd
4 hours ago
The Trump-aligned board voted in August 2026 to add inscriptions crediting him for renovations, prompting opponents to file emergency legal challenges
4 hours ago
A Maoist faction of the DSA rejected Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez as its 2028 standard-bearer, citing her stances on policing and Israel
6 hours ago
Officials told CNN that Harp stayed with Trump much of the day, joined meetings, advised him on posts, and served as a channel for foreign leaders
7 hours ago
Miller enlisted in 1939 and manned an anti-aircraft gun after helping his wounded commander at Pearl Harbor, later receiving the Navy Cross in 1942
8 hours ago
'I mean, first of all, he's almost 10 years older than I am. And with an illness... you kinda can't let your head go there', Jill Biden said
9 hours ago
JD Vance said the administration had relied on alternative routes, pipelines and other infrastructure to keep oil moving despite the disruption
16 hours ago