Sean 'Diddy' Combs’ attorney says judge acted as ‘13th juror,’ vows to appeal 50-month sentence

Sean 'Diddy' Combs was sentenced to 50 months in prison for Mann Act violations, with his attorneys claiming the judge overstepped the jury’s verdict
PUBLISHED OCT 4, 2025
Sean 'Diddy' Combs was sentenced to prison and fined half a million as part of his punishment (Paras Griffin/Getty Images)
Sean 'Diddy' Combs was sentenced to prison and fined half a million as part of his punishment (Paras Griffin/Getty Images)

NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK: Sean 'Diddy' Combs’ lawyers announced they will appeal his recent sentence after accusing Judge Arun Subramanian, of overstepping his role.

Lead attorney Marc Agnifilo said the judge “acted as a 13th juror” when he handed down the sentence.

Combs received four years and two months in prison on two Mann Act charges related to transporting individuals for prostitution. His defense team argued the punishment disregarded the jury’s acquittal on more serious charges.

Sean
Sean 'Diddy' Combs performed at Howard University’s Yardfest in Washington DC in October 2023 (Getty Images/Thaddaeus McAdams)

Lead attorney Marc Agnifilo criticizes judge’s role in sentencing

“We are planning to appeal,” said Agnifilo. “We think we have a strong basis to appeal.”

He added, “What we feel happened today was that the judge acted as a 13th juror and second-guessed the jury.”

Attorney Marc Agnifilo, the sentence was driven by outside pressure. “The sentence was based on conduct the jury rejected. The jury acquitted Mr Combs of any coercion,” he said.

“The jury’s verdict was resoundingly clear. There was no sex trafficking, no racketeering; everything was consensual and adult, which is why he was convicted only of the prostitution offense.”

Attorney Brian Steel, another member of the defense team, described the ruling as a “very bad day for everybody.”

“There is a human being now in custody for 50 months based upon conduct that the jury heard, the jury resolved, and the jury rejected,” Steel said.

Lead attorney Teny Geragos highlighted the importance of the jury’s decision: “The jury made it very clear in their verdict that they acquitted him of the sex trafficking and RICO counts. Not guilty means not guilty.”

Sean Combs is seen on October 30, 2023, in Los Angeles, California (Hollywood To You/Star Max/GC Images)
Sean 'Diddy' Combs was spotted in Los Angeles, California in October 2023 (Hollywood To You/Star Max/GC Images)

A juror from Combs’ trial told ABC News that the rapper’s 50-month sentence was too light.

“I think he got off easy. I’m surprised the judge was that lenient,” the juror said.

“I think 10 years would have been more appropriate. He has many more civil suits filed against him, so he will be in and out of court for years. I’m sure he will have more fines to pay, too.”

Sean 'Diddy' Combs apologizes in court

Since his arrest in September 2024, Sean 'Diddy' Combs’ has been held at the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn.

Appearing in court on October 3, he issued an apology for what he described as “disgusting, shameful, sick” behavior.

“I don’t have anybody to blame but myself,” Combs said. “I know I’ll never put my hands on another person again. I know I’ve learned my lesson. My acts of domestic violence are a burden I’ll carry for the rest of my life.

Meaning of ‘13th juror’ explained

The term “13th juror” refers to a judge who second-guesses a jury’s verdict, despite being required to follow it.

It can also describe an outsider commenting on a case. The phrase was also the title of John Lescroart’s 1992 legal thriller novel.

MORE STORIES

NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell backed the decision, stressing that the selection process was deliberate and that the criticism had become a tradition
8 hours ago
Reports say Lauren Sanchez played matchmaker for Katy Perry and Justin Trudeau, joking she’s 'launching romances'
1 day ago
Britney Spears denies driving in a viral reckless clip as her family fears she’s spiraling amid Kevin Federline’s explosive memoir
1 day ago
Katy Perry and Justin Trudeau made their first public appearance as a couple on Saturday, stepping out for a date at the iconic Crazy Horse
3 days ago
Nelly Furtado said she’s stepping back from live shows after online body-shaming, choosing to focus on personal growth and creative pursuits
3 days ago
June Lockhart, an Emmy and Tony winning actress, died from natural causes on October 23 at her Santa Monica home, surrounded by family
3 days ago
Whoopi Goldberg admitted past drunken missteps on 'The View' and reassured viewers she is not racist, emphasizing years of sobriety
4 days ago
Kevin Federline claimed Sean Preston and Jayden James stopped visiting Britney Spears, saying they feared for her safety and well-being
4 days ago
'The View' criticized Donald Trump’s $250 million White House ballroom as Americans faced economic hardships from the government shutdown
5 days ago
According to an onlooker, Britney Spears 'nearly ran over her friend while pulling out' of Red-O's parking lot after the night out
5 days ago