Sen Tom Cotton insists September boat strike survivors were valid targets: 'Not incapacitated'

Cotton disputed claims of ‘helpless’ boat survivors as he told NBC that they were on the capsized vessel, not adrift, and thus remained valid targets
PUBLISHED DEC 7, 2025
Tom Cotton backed Pete Hegseth amid Signal app controversy and said that the Pentagon report cleared him of wrongdoing (NBC News/YouTube, Getty Images)
Tom Cotton backed Pete Hegseth amid Signal app controversy and said that the Pentagon report cleared him of wrongdoing (NBC News/YouTube, Getty Images)


WASHINGTON, DC: Chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee Tom Cotton appeared on NBC’s ‘Meet the Press’ on Sunday, December 7. During his appearance, Cotton defended the Trump administration's initial September boat strike that left several dead.

Cotton argued that the survivors were "not incapacitated" and that it was “entirely appropriate” to strike the boat again to ensure that the cargo was destroyed. 

Tom Cotton may be promoted to a lower-level leadership position initially (Getty Images)
Tom Cotton may be promoted to a lower-level leadership position initially (Getty Images)

Tom Cotton clears the air about The Washington Post story 

Tom Cotton told host Kristen Welker that the controversy surrounding the boat strikes began about 10 days ago when The Washington Post reported that there were “helpless” survivors after the initial strike.

“That is simply not the case,” he claimed.



The Senate Intelligence Committee’s chairman added that the survivors were not “floating in the ocean,” on a wooden plank, or in life jackets. He added that they were on the capsized vessel and hence “valid targets.”

Cotton further claimed that Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth’s orders were not in violation of the Law of War. 

BRUSSELS, BELGIUM - FEBRUARY 13: US Secretary of Defence Pete Hegseth speaks during a joint press conference held with NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte during the NATO Defense Ministers' meeting on February 13, 2025 in Brussels, Belgium. NATO Defence Ministers are convening in Brussels for a meeting chaired by NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte. Also in attendance is US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, marking the first visit to NATO by a member of the new Trump administration. High on the agenda for the allies will be ascertaining how the US intends to influence the trajectory of the war in Ukraine, as the conflict nears the third anniversary since Russia's full-scale invasion. (Photo by Omar Havana/Getty Images)
Secretary of Defence Pete Hegseth speaks during a joint press conference held with NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte during the NATO Defense Ministers' meeting on February 13, 2025, in Brussels, Belgium (Omar Havana/Getty Images)

Cotton added that he believed the publication owed Hegseth and Admiral Mitch Bradley an apology for the “slander.” 

When asked whether Bradley had confirmed that all the people on the boat were military targets, Cotton said he didn’t “personally hear him” say that because the admiral had several briefings that Cotton was not a part of.

However, the senator was told by Mark Warner that the admiral had “high confidence” based on multiple sources of intelligence. 

Tom Cotton backs Pete Hegseth using the Signal app

During his ‘Meet the Press’ appearance, the Senate Intelligence Committee’s chairman was asked about the Pentagon’s inspector general’s revelation that Hegseth had shared secret information about America in a Signal group chat.

In doing so, he had allegedly created a risk to operational security that could have potentially failed mission objectives. 

Pete Hegseth pauses to talk to reporters after a series of meetings with senators in the Russell Senate Office Building on Capitol Hill on November 21, 2024 in Washington, DC. Hegseth was nominated by President-elect Donald Trump to be the next Secretary of Defense. (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
Pete Hegseth pauses to talk to reporters after a series of meetings with senators in the Russell Senate Office Building on Capitol Hill on November 21, 2024, in Washington, DC (Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

Cotton said that he had “100%” confidence in Pete Hegseth and added that he had read the report, which exonerated Secretary Hegseth of any “criminal wrongdoing.” 

He added that by the time information was shared on the Signal app, they were also communicating with foreign counterparts to let them know what had happened. 

“I think this is a bit of a mountain out of a molehill,” he added.

When asked whether he would recommend them not to use the Signal app, Cotton said that he was confident that Hegseth was making the right decision to protect America and keep the administration officials and foreign counterparts informed. 

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The documentary followed Melania Trump during the opening weeks of 2025, a pivotal period as the Trump family prepared for a return to the White House
5 hours ago
Before becoming the top law enforcer Pam Bondi was seen as a 'sweet' prosecutor with 'debilitating insecurity' who loved dogs and the gay community
6 hours ago
Tom Homan called Keith Ellison’s claims 'nonsense' and warned that interfering with federal immigration officers is a felony under federal law
6 hours ago
James Comer argued that without an official transcript, the public would be left with competing accounts, undermining transparency
7 hours ago
Trump declared that he has given strict orders for the United States to take extreme action against Iran
7 hours ago
The White House list remains posted on the administration’s website, with the inclusion of the Hunter Biden protection item
7 hours ago
James Woods accused Don Lemon of misleading coverage, saying Lemon knew more than he admitted and calling him a 'dingleberry' in American journalism
8 hours ago
Archbishop Timothy Broglio said a US move to seize Greenland would not be a just war and could place Catholic troops in morally difficult situations
8 hours ago
Trump highlighted his achievements on immigration enforcement, stating that illegal crossings at the southern border had been successfully stopped
8 hours ago
Scott Bessent said Donald Trump’s Greenland push was not tied to a Nobel snub and said US–Europe tensions remain manageable
9 hours ago