'That's a plot twist': Internet weighs in as John Oliver says Trump's prosecution as obvious as Natasha Lyonne playing 'next Batman'

The 'Last Week Tonight' host also took a jab at Donald Trump's son Eric, whose birthday happens to be January 6
John Oliver asserts Donald Trump can face criminal charges as surely as Natasha Lyonne should play 'the next Batman' (Getty Images, Peabody Awards via Wikipedia)
John Oliver asserts Donald Trump can face criminal charges as surely as Natasha Lyonne should play 'the next Batman' (Getty Images, Peabody Awards via Wikipedia)

NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK: In recent developments, John Oliver shared insights directed towards the Supreme Court during his recent episode of 'Last Week Tonight' on HBO.

He discussed the decision of the court to deliberate on whether former President Donald Trump enjoys presidential immunity concerning potential prosecution related to alleged interference in the 2020 presidential election.

BEVERLY HILLS, CA - AUGUST 08:  John Oliver accepts the TCA Award for Outstanding Achievement in New
John Oliver discussed the decision of the Supreme Court to deliberate on whether former President Donald Trump enjoys presidential immunity (Getty Images)

Donald Trump's potential criminal prosecution sparks debate

Oliver included a segment from an ABC News report, where the reporter emphasized the significant and unanswered question before the court, "Can a former president be criminally prosecuted for actions taken while in office?”

Oliver mused, “It’s an interesting question and real quick: Yes. Yes. A former president can be criminally prosecuted for actions taken in office. It is one of those questions to which the answer should really be obvious."

He added, "Like, did Robert Durst kill those people, or which cereal mascot f**ks the most, or who should play the next Batman? And for the record, the answers are: Absolutely, it’s not even close [Tony the Tiger] and Natasha Lyonne."

John Olver said,
John Olver feels that Donald Trump's criminal prosecution is as 'obvious' as Natasha Lyonne being Batman (Peabody Awards via Wikipedia)

Oliver also highlighted an intriguing exchange that took place during the case's proceedings before the DC Circuit Court. Judge Florence Pan posed a "wild hypothetical" question to Trump's attorney, John Sauer, which vividly showcased the absurdity of Trump's stance.

The question was, "Could a president who ordered Seal Team 6 to assassinate a political rival, who was not impeached, would he be subject to criminal prosecution?" 

Sauer responded, "If he were impeached and convicted first."

To which Oliver remarked, "Wow. Only under those conditions? It really feels like the answer to, ‘Can the president kill a guy?’ shouldn’t be, ‘No, unless half the people in Congress think the other guy had it coming'."

Federal trial for January 6 charges may face postponement

In the meantime, this situation suggests that the federal trial regarding the January 6 charges might face postponement until after the November presidential election.

"And if Trump secures victory in that election, who knows what unfolds?" Oliver quipped. "I mean, we might as well hope for the sun to explode, although that's a rather remote possibility."

(@donaldjtrumpjr/Instagram)
John Oliver noted a “fun fact” that Eric Trump‘s birthday happens to be January 6 (@donaldjtrumpjr/Instagram)

Oliver continued, "So it seems like consequences for the insurrection could be yet another thing that Trump tries to kick down the road, ignoring it and hoping it goes away like his various debts or multiple court cases or acknowledging any of his children’s birthdays". He then pointed out a "fun fact" that Eric Trump's birthday coincidentally falls on January 6.

“It’s true — and a wonderful reminder that Trump’s the only politician in DC during the riot who considers that to be the second worst thing to happen to him on Jan. 6,” Oliver quipped.

Internet weighs in

Social media users took to X to express their views on Oliver's statements. One user wrote, "I think you meant "cereal mascot." 



 

A user simply stated, "So not at all?"



 

Another wrote, "Ah, I guess John Oliver is feeling the ratings squeeze of not having ppl terrified of Trump all the time and watching him to help make sense of it all."



 

"John Oliver throwin' shade like it's sunny, but Natasha as Batman? Now that's a plot twist I'd pay to see!" said another. 



 

This article contains remarks made on the internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'I do believe undeniably that the history and the environment was worsened by the prices at the pump,' Karoline Leavitt said
2026-11-05T05:48:03.000Z
Barack Obama urged Democrats to use their new congressional majority to push for changes and limit the impact of Donald Trump's remaining two years in office
2026-11-05T05:20:41.000Z
Hakeem Jeffries outlined his priorities on affordability, accountability and American values in a letter seeking support from incoming lawmakers
2026-11-05T05:01:06.000Z
Trump spent about 25 minutes discussing White House construction and other renovation projects before addressing Republican losses in the midterms
2026-11-05T04:30:10.000Z
Donald Trump also defended his handling of the Iran conflict, insisting he would not have made different decisions
2026-11-05T04:00:26.000Z
Although Mike Johnson secured re-election to his Louisiana House seat, it remains unclear whether he will complete his full two-year term
2026-11-05T03:31:51.000Z
A White House official hinted Donald Trump could hold Pete Hegseth accountable, saying, 'That will play out in the lame duck'
2026-11-05T02:52:32.000Z
Hakeem Jeffries said Democrats would prioritise affordability over retaliating against Donald Trump or pursuing impeachment after their midterm victory
2026-11-05T02:32:58.000Z
JD Vance said inflation, voter dissatisfaction with US ties to Israel and the Iran conflict contributed to Republicans losing support among 2024 Trump voters
2026-11-05T02:09:43.000Z
The results highlight the scale of the electoral challenge facing Republicans in the district. In 2026, Nagel received approximately 56,000 votes, while independent candidate DeVelle Jackson secured around 24,000
2026-11-04T21:02:00.000Z