Trump-aligned podcaster’s tone shift signals crack in core base: ‘People feel betrayed’

The podcasters who once convinced American youth to support Trump are now warning Trump about his policies and saying that the president has broken his campaign promises
PUBLISHED 1 HOUR AGO
Trump appeared on numerous podcasts in the days leading up to the 2024 presidential elections, prompting many to call it a "podcast election," which he won (AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein)
Trump appeared on numerous podcasts in the days leading up to the 2024 presidential elections, prompting many to call it a "podcast election," which he won (AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein)

WASHINGTON, DC: Once-Trump-aligned podcasts, which are often credited with building narrative and ground support for Trump among the conservative base, are now questioning Trump over Iran and his ‘broken promises.'

From Joe Rogan to Theo Von, key podcasters are arguing that broken campaign promises may have hurtful consequences for Trump. Trump appeared on numerous podcasts in the days leading up to the 2024 presidential elections, prompting many to call it a "podcast election," which he won.

Donald Trump appeared Joe Rogan's podcast (PowerfulJRE/ YouTube)
Donald Trump appeared on Joe Rogan's podcast (PowerfulJRE/ YouTube)

MAGA influencers are warning Trump

The podcasters who once convinced American youth to support Trump are now warning the POTUS about his policies and saying that the president has broken his campaign promises.

A recent write-up by Semafor highlights the growing dissent and shifting trend among conservative influencers who campaigned for Trump and played a key role in his 2024 win.

The piece headlined, ‘Baffling: Trump’s podcaster problem runs deep,' notes that while Joe Rogan joined President Trump for the signing of an executive order to further the cause of psychedelic therapy research, other issues remain in play.

"But even if the White House’s efforts to court Rogan proved successful, Trump has more work to do," Semafor wrote. "Of the 14 longform ‘bro’ podcasts Trump appeared on during his 2024 presidential campaign, eight of the hosts have questioned or criticized the war, while just two have endorsed it."

President Donald Trump turns to, from far left, U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert Kennedy Jr., Joe Rogan, CEO of American for Ibogaine W. Bryan Hubbard, and retired U.S. Navy Seal Marcus Luttrell in the Oval Office of the White House, Saturday, April 18, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)
President Donald Trump turns to Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert Kennedy Jr., Joe Rogan, CEO of American for Ibogaine W. Bryan Hubbard, and retired Navy SEAL Marcus Luttrell in the Oval Office of the White House, Saturday, April 18, 2026, in Washington (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)

Trump voters feel betrayed by Iran war

A long-form podcaster who enjoys a great deal of popularity among the conservative section, Joe Rogan, criticized Trump for entering into a war with Iran.

"Well, it just seems so insane based on what he ran on," Rogan said in March. "I mean, this is why a lot of people feel betrayed, right? He ran on ‘no more wars’ and ‘these stupid senseless wars,’ and then we have one that we can't even really clearly define why we did it."

Rogan lacked firm support for ICE operations. Expressing a mixed view on ICE raids, Rogan earlier said that he understands both for and against points when it comes to how ICE was carrying out its job. 

Joe Rogan (PowerfulJRE/ YouTube)
Podcaster Joe Rogan helped Trump convince youth to vote for him ahead of the 2024 elections (PowerfulJRE/ YouTube)

However, he supported the ICE raid, saying that it was important to secure the border, which democrats failed to do.

Joe Rogan blames Israel for pressuring Trump into war

Days after joining Trump at the White House for the signing of the executive order to speed up the research work into psychedelics, Rogan blamed Israel for pressuring Trump into war.

"Netanyahu kept visiting the White House. You think it's a coincidence that Netanyahu keeps visiting the White House and then eventually they decide to give in and start bombing?" Rogan asked.

Trump will give the country back to Democrats

Besides, comedian Dave Smith also called out Trump over the Iran war despite supporting him in the 2024 election. Smith is a vocal critic of Israel’s influence on America.

"After '24, this coalition came together where Donald Trump, for the first time ever, wins the popular vote, wins every single swing state and really, more remarkably, won the youth and the culture," Smith said in an interview with Rogan last month.

(Screenshot/thetuckercarlsonshow)
Dave Smith said that Trump will soon give the country back to Democrats (Screenshot/thetuckercarlsonshow)

"That whole coalition has been destroyed over this war," he said. "And now he's going to hand the country right back over to these Democrats, whom we've been fighting so hard. All for what? All for a war that Netanyahu wanted?"

Theo Von condemns Trump over Iran war

Comedian Theo Von, who interviewed Trump before the 2024 election and is often dubbed as Trump’s favourite podcaster, has been criticizing Trump over the Iran war.

Von condemned Trump’s threat on Easter to wipe out Iranian civilization.

"On Easter, that’s unbelievable. You know when people are hoping for something new literally on the day when people are hoping and are believing with their hearts as much as they can and are celebrating something new, a rebirth, a resurrection, a possibility. To write that is it's diabolical. It's insane," he said.

Ben Shapiro went after Theo Von in his latest rant (Theo Von/YouTube)
Comedian Theo Von is popular as Trump's favorite Podcaster (Theo Von/YouTube)

Von alleged that Trump was compromised by Iran.

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

During a discussion on 'The Court of History' podcast, historians Sidney Blumenthal and Sean Wilentz argued the timing was unlikely to be random
1 day ago
David Gross also warned that AI-driven military systems could make rapid, error-prone decisions during future conflicts
2 days ago
TMZ reported receiving two new notes the same day Savannah Guthrie returned to the 'Today' show after a two-month absence
Apr 10, 2026
Melania Trump clarified that while she and her husband occasionally attended the same social events as Epstein due to overlapping elite circles
Apr 10, 2026
Brent Sadler said the F-15 co-pilot rescue after 36 hours in Iran required coordination with US forces and Gulf partners providing airspace clearance
Apr 6, 2026
Air traffic control is responsible for any vehicles on the runways, expert says
Mar 24, 2026
Expert Michael Gould said Nancy Guthrie’s case is likely a homicide after 40 days without contact
Mar 18, 2026
Chalamet left the Oscars early after losing Best Actor for the third time, sparking debate over his Hollywood persona and strategy
Mar 17, 2026
FBI expert Maureen O’Connell said blood patterns suggest Nancy Guthrie was wrapped and carried out of the house
Mar 11, 2026
Kamala Harris and Gavin Newsom are seen as potential Democratic candidates for the 2028 White House race
Mar 10, 2026