'Trump will be rebuked again': Ex-Trump lawyer Ty Cobb predicts SCOTUS birthright citizenship ruling

Cobb said Trump views the Supreme Court through a transactional lens and expects justices he appointed to rule in his favor
Speaking with CNN's Erin Burnett on Monday, May 29, Ty Cobb singled out the birthright citizenship dispute as uniquely significant (Screengrab X @RpsAgainstTrump/Getty Images)
Speaking with CNN's Erin Burnett on Monday, May 29, Ty Cobb singled out the birthright citizenship dispute as uniquely significant (Screengrab X @RpsAgainstTrump/Getty Images)

WASHINGTON, DC: Former White House special counsel and chronic Trump critic Ty Cobb predicted the Supreme Court will "rebuke" President Donald Trump again by rejecting his executive order ending birthright citizenship.

His comments came after Trump experienced a mixed day at the Supreme Court, with several rulings going against positions he supported. Cobb argued those decisions showed the justices were acting independently rather than delivering victories Trump expected. 

(CNN/YouTube)
Ty Cobb also defended Justice Amy Coney Barrett after criticism from some of Trump's allies over her opinion in the Mississippi ballot case(YouTube @cnn)

 

Ty Cobb says Trump expects judicial loyalty

Speaking with CNN's Erin Burnett on Monday, May 29, Cobb said Trump views the Supreme Court through a transactional lens and expects justices he appointed to rule in his favor.

Burnett noted that Trump was frustrated after setbacks in a mail-in ballot case and another involving Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook. She added that Trump believes he "stacked" the Supreme Court with people who would side with him.

Cobb agreed with that assessment.

U.S. President Donald Trump takes a question from a reporter in the Roosevelt Room of the White House on March 3, 2025 in Washington, DC. Trump announced that Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, one of the largest manufacturers of semiconductor chips, plans to invest $100 billion in new manufacturing facilities in the United States. (Photo by Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)
President Donald Trump takes a question from a reporter in the Roosevelt Room of the White House on March 3, 2025, in Washington, DC (Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)

"Trump views this very transactionally — they're his people, they should vote his way. I mean that's his view of the world," he said.

Instead, Cobb argued that Chief Justice John Roberts and several conservative colleagues chose to "call balls and strikes," echoing Roberts' well-known confirmation hearing remark, and "hold the center" in both the Mississippi case and the Federal Reserve dispute.

Ty Cobb praises Amy Coney Barrett's ruling

Cobb also defended Justice Amy Coney Barrett after criticism from some of Trump's allies over her opinion in the Mississippi ballot case.

"Amy Coney Barrett, who wrote the Mississippi ballot case, is a conservative; she is a strong conservative, but she's also an intellectually honest person," Cobb said.

Clarence Thomas, Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States (Getty Images)
Clarence Thomas, Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States (Getty Images)

"And she wrote the decision in the way that she actually believes," he said.

He added that he knew "they're livid about that," saying Steve Bannon had criticized Barrett and that Trump was also angry over the ruling.

"But the reality is she did her job, and she should be proud of that," Cobb said.

Birthright citizenship ruling should be unanimous

Looking ahead to the court's remaining decisions, Cobb said he expected another defeat for Trump.

"I would expect that Trump will be rebuked again on birthright citizenship," he said.

Cobb called the case "obvious" and said the ruling "should be unanimous," although he suggested Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas could still side with Trump.

He added that other pending cases involving transgender athletes and campaign finance could ultimately favor the president.

Even so, Cobb singled out the birthright citizenship dispute as uniquely significant, saying, "On birthright citizenship, which I think is at the fundamental core of what it is to be an American, I think that the country will be proud tomorrow of the Supreme Court."

GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL UPDATES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The Justice Department is investigating whether Harvard's China-linked scholarships discriminated against American students
3 hours ago
Trump suggested the ally was at fault, saying, 'When you let other people do your work, sometimes that doesn't work out'
3 hours ago
Marjorie Taylor Greene claimed unnamed senior Trump officials support military action against Iran because they are pursuing future presidential bids
4 hours ago
Days after accusing China of helping cost him the 2020 election, Trump downplayed Beijing's alleged role
4 hours ago
The case centers on releasing audio recordings and transcripts of Biden's 2016–17 interviews with his memoir ghostwriter
5 hours ago
Kennedy says the states must prove Medicaid payments were legitimate before more than $1 billion in federal funding is restored
6 hours ago
Republican lawmaker says newly declassified intelligence warrants suspending every Chinese F-1 and J-1 visa issued by the US
6 hours ago
As Democrats push for higher taxes on the wealthy, Trump argued the policy would drive rich residents to Republican-led states, leaving blue states
6 hours ago
Trump is reportedly pursuing a new legal route to revive his trade agenda despite advisers warning of economic and political fallout
7 hours ago
The Pentagon on Monday confirmed that around 100 US service members were injured in incidents and attacks originating from Iran since July 7
7 hours ago