'American Idol' fans claim runner-up John Foster’s face showed he knew the result before it was announced

According to 'American Idol' viewers, John Foster’s disappointed expression gave it away that he knew Jamal Roberts would be named the winner
UPDATED MAY 20, 2025
According to 'American Idol' viewers, John Foster (R) saw the winner's name on host Ryan Seacrest's card moments before he made the announcement (Screengrab/American Idol/ YouTube)
According to 'American Idol' viewers, John Foster (R) saw the winner's name on host Ryan Seacrest's card moments before he made the announcement (Screengrab/American Idol/ YouTube)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Jamal Roberts was crowned the winner of 'American Idol' Season 23 on Sunday, May 18, but many viewers suspect runner-up John Foster saw the result moments before it was announced.

Foster stole the hearts of 'American Idol' fans all across the country during his audition by performing two classic country tunes, 'Don't Rock The Jukebox' and 'Goodbye Time', according to Gator 99.5.



 

Viral video shows John Foster's reaction moments before the 'American Idol' Season 23 winner was announced

The 'American Idol' finale was a three-hour-long event, consisting of many performances, including one from Jessica Simpson

After the second round of songs, the show eliminated Texas' Breanna Nix, leaving only Foster and Roberts in the race to win the ultimate title.

Interestingly, the clip from the episode that has gone viral suggests that Foster might have already known his fate.

John Foster's reaction went viral after he seemed like peeping on the envelope (Screengrab/American Idol YouTube)
'American Idol' finalist John Foster's reaction went viral as he seemed like peeping at the card (Screengrab/American Idol/YouTube)

Before the announcement of the winner, host Ryan Seacrest stood on stage with the two finalists. Foster stood right next to Seacrest, whereas Robers was on the other side.

Seacrest paused for a moment before announcing the winner’s name.

However, before he spoke, he opened the envelope, and some believed that Foster might have seen the name inside because he had a disappointed look even before the winner's name was announced.


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by American Idol (@americanidol)


 

Ultimately, Jamal was named the winner, and Foster was the runner-up.

Meanwhile, TV Insider reported that Foster did indeed "barely" see the results on the envelope. The outlet caught up with Foster after the finale, and the singer said, "I was in a total blur. I knew I was at peace with being runner-up. Jamal is such an incredible performer. I was at peace. I really was. It’s a true honor to be runner-up."

Notably, the final five contestants for the season were Nix, Foster, Roberts, Slater Nalley, and Thunderstorm Artis.

Fans suspect John Foster saw results before it was announced

Several 'American Idol' viewers felt John Foster saw the result moments before it was announced, and that it was evident in his facial reaction in the viral clip.

An Instagram user commented, "John deff peeped down the card & saw Jamal name on there n looked at him & smiled," while one added, "John saw the card! He knew!"


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by American Idol (@americanidol)


 

A person stated, "John saw the name on the card. That must have been tough," whereas one mentioned, "John totally accidentally saw the card lol. So deserved! Wish we wish see the whole end ! They need to start that part sooner so we can see the celebration."

"YALL SAW JOHN LOOK AT THE CARD?😂 he saw Jamal name," one more wrote, while another commented, "My Guy peeped it out before Ryan announced."

"John saw that Jamal won and was just like his name a gracious competitor!" an individual remarked. 

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

MORE STORIES

The post Khloe Kardashian liked featured Charlie Kirk speaking with a fan at an event about his devout Christian faith
Sep 13, 2025
Whitney Cummings sparked widespread outrage after posting a controversial tweet about the killing of conservative activist Charlie Kirk
Sep 13, 2025
Prince Harry was spotted entering King Charles’s London residence, months after saying his father had ignored his calls
Sep 11, 2025
Rosie O'Donnell said Ellen DeGeneres’ friendship denial hurt so much she printed T-shirts for her staff reading, 'I don’t know Rosie, we’re not friends'
Sep 10, 2025
A post alleged that Karoline Leavitt called Patti LaBelle 'just a singer,' leading LaBelle to deliver a seven-word response that froze the studio
Sep 10, 2025
Jennifer Lopez feels free channeling emotions into music, but Ben Affleck is embarrassed and sees it as crossing a line, according to the source
Sep 9, 2025
Howard Stern added that he missed last week’s show due to illness, not contract talks, and addressed rumors of being fired from his own show
Sep 9, 2025
Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce’s engagement in August 2025 triggered a wave of pregnancy chatter after an ultrasound photo went viral
Sep 9, 2025
Ed Sheeran, 34, revealed that he was leaving Suffolk with his wife Cherry Seaborn and their two daughters, Lyra and Jupiter
Sep 9, 2025
From Ice Spice’s chaotic corset to Paris Hilton’s flame dress, see the celebs who landed on the worst-dressed list at the 2025 VMAs
Sep 8, 2025