‘Jersey Shore’ star Angelina Pivarnick calls it quits with fiance Vinny Tortorella amid cheating scandal

NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK: 'Jersey Shore' star Angelina Pivarnick and her fiance Vinny Tortorella have ended their relationship after dating since 2022, following months of cheating accusations.

The couple first connected on Instagram in early 2022, began dating, and got engaged in November of that same year. 

However, their relationship was rocked by controversy when Pivarnick reported a domestic violence incident involving Tortorella, though he denied the claims.

Amid cheating allegations and mounting tension, Pivarnick has now confirmed that they have broken up.

Angelina Pivarnick and Vinny Tortorella accuse each other of cheating

During a recent appearance on 'Jersey Shore' Season 7B reunion, Angelina Pivarnick revealed that Vinny Tortorella had cheated on her. 

She shared, "We're currently filming for another season, and [I] found out he cheated on me."

Pivarnick also accused him of being a "clout chaser," stating, "He just wanted to be on TV. He didn’t care about anything that had to do with me."

In response, Tortorella, who was absent from the reunion taping, took to Instagram to confirm their split and accuse Pivarnick of being unfaithful as well. 

He wrote, "I made a hinge 2 weeks after breaking off my relationship after I found out I got cheated on again," in a comment to a follower, as per PageSix. 

He followed up with another comment, saying, "I broke the relationship off and wanted to find a new woman. I deserve that chance after getting screwed over multiple times."

Tortorella challenged Pivarnick to provide proof of his infidelity. "I didn’t watch the reunion but saw the clip they posted. She made sure to plant the seed trying to say I cheated, WELL show some proof then. It doesn’t exist!" he wrote in his comment.

What did Angelina Pivarnick's private investigator report?

According to OK Magazine, details of Vinny Tortorella's alleged affair were uncovered by a private investigator hired by Angelina Pivarnick.

The investigator, John Downey, a retired NYC Police Department sergeant with Stallion Security and Investigations, began working on the case in November 2024. The investigation was prompted by a request from Pivarnick’s agent, Tony, to monitor Tortorella’s activities while Pivarnick was away filming for her show.

The surveillance began on November 16, 2024, when Downey reported that Tortorella was driving a white Porsche SUV with New Jersey plates.

The investigator tracked him to Staten Island before following him to Tao Uptown, a popular restaurant and nightclub in New York City, at 10.45 pm.

There, Downey observed Tortorella with an unidentified blonde woman. After leaving the club around midnight, Tortorella accompanied the woman to her apartment, where they stayed together until around 2.45 am.

When Pivarnick asked for an update, Downey told her that Tortorella was with the "woman".

He added that Tortorella had told Pivarnick he was “out with his boys".

Downey, feeling that Pivarnick had been deceived, confirmed the situation, saying, "[I am] here to confirm that he was with a girl while she was away filming."