'American Idol' crew '100% prefers working with' Carrie Underwood after Katy Perry's chaotic years

A production insider recently revealed that Carrie Underwood's entry as a judge has changed the entire atmosphere of 'American Idol'
PUBLISHED DEC 29, 2024
Carrie Underwood replaced Katy Perry on 'American Idol' after the 'Roar' singer stepped down as a judge to focus on her career (John Nacion/FilmMagic, Kevin Mazur/Getty Images for iHeartRadio)
Carrie Underwood replaced Katy Perry on 'American Idol' after the 'Roar' singer stepped down as a judge to focus on her career (John Nacion/FilmMagic, Kevin Mazur/Getty Images for iHeartRadio)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Carrie Underwood has reportedly come as a blessing to the crew members of ‘American Idol’ after the "chaotic and stormy" years with Katy Perry left them in teeters.

Speaking to The US Sun, as reported by The Express, a production insider gushed that Underwood's entry as a judge has changed the entire atmosphere of the show. 

Carrie Underwood performs onstage at the 38th Annual Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame Induction Ceremony at Barclays Center on November 03, 2023 in New York City. (Photo by Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic)
Carrie Underwood performs onstage at the 38th Annual Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame Induction Ceremony at Barclays Center on November 03, 2023, in New York City (Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic)

After the 'Roar' songstress stepped down earlier this year, 'The Champion' hitmaker replaced her for a paycheck of $12 million, joining the illustrious panel comprising of Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie.

'American Idol' crew is 'much happier' and 'more comfortable' with Carrie Underwood on the panel

The insider admitted, "Carrie has been a ‘godsend’ for the show. I hate to sound so cheesy, but it really is like a ray of sunshine after a chaotic and stormy few years with some of the on-camera talent."

Katy Perry performs onstage during iHeartRadio Q102's Jingle Ball 2024 Presented By Capital One at the Wells Fargo Center on December 16, 2024 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Kevin Mazur/Getty Images for iHeartRadio)
Katy Perry performs onstage during iHeartRadio Q102's Jingle Ball 2024 Presented By Capital One at the Wells Fargo Center on December 16, 2024, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania (Kevin Mazur/Getty Images for iHeartRadio)

The outlet further revealed that during her tenure, Perry often faced backlashes for her reported involvement in various controversies, including kissing a younger contestant and "mom-shaming" a contestant. All these incidents created unprecedented tension on set.

"To put it bluntly, everyone in the crew, the studio suits, and the producers are much happier and more comfortable now with Carrie on the panel," the production insider shared.


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by American Idol (@americanidol)


 

"Carrie is very professional and a natural. She’s been close with Luke for years, knows and adores Ryan [Seacrest], and bonds well with Lionel. Everyone 100% prefers working with Carrie to Katy—it’s not even a question," the tipster asserted. 

On the 'Victory in Jesus' singer’s judging style, they noted, "Carrie is a combination of Paula and Simon. She’s sweet and nurturing like Paula but isn’t afraid to give honest, constructive feedback like Simon."

Katy Perry was 'scrambling to reclaim her spot' on the 'American Idol' panel

The positive words about Carrie Underwood’s presence in 'American Idol' came just a few months after another insider spilled that Katy Perry was begging to get her position back on the judge’s table after her most recent album, '143', bombed.

(L-R) Lionel Richie, Katy Perry and Luke Bryan attend
Lionel Richie, Katy Perry, and Luke Bryan attend 'American Idol' 20th Anniversary Celebration at Desert 5 Spot on April 18, 2022, in Los Angeles, California (Momodu Mansaray/Getty Images)

"'American Idol' was a safe, steady gig for Katy. Now that her album has flopped, she's scrambling to reclaim her spot at the judges' table," shared the source, as per RadarOnline

They added, "It's a clear sign even she knows her days as a chart-topping artist are behind her. But Carrie's got the gig now — and unless the new season is a ratings disaster, there's no way Katy is getting back in that chair!"

MORE STORIES

The post Khloe Kardashian liked featured Charlie Kirk speaking with a fan at an event about his devout Christian faith
Sep 13, 2025
Whitney Cummings sparked widespread outrage after posting a controversial tweet about the killing of conservative activist Charlie Kirk
Sep 13, 2025
Prince Harry was spotted entering King Charles’s London residence, months after saying his father had ignored his calls
Sep 11, 2025
Rosie O'Donnell said Ellen DeGeneres’ friendship denial hurt so much she printed T-shirts for her staff reading, 'I don’t know Rosie, we’re not friends'
Sep 10, 2025
A post alleged that Karoline Leavitt called Patti LaBelle 'just a singer,' leading LaBelle to deliver a seven-word response that froze the studio
Sep 10, 2025
Jennifer Lopez feels free channeling emotions into music, but Ben Affleck is embarrassed and sees it as crossing a line, according to the source
Sep 9, 2025
Howard Stern added that he missed last week’s show due to illness, not contract talks, and addressed rumors of being fired from his own show
Sep 9, 2025
Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce’s engagement in August 2025 triggered a wave of pregnancy chatter after an ultrasound photo went viral
Sep 9, 2025
Ed Sheeran, 34, revealed that he was leaving Suffolk with his wife Cherry Seaborn and their two daughters, Lyra and Jupiter
Sep 9, 2025
From Ice Spice’s chaotic corset to Paris Hilton’s flame dress, see the celebs who landed on the worst-dressed list at the 2025 VMAs
Sep 8, 2025