‘American Idol’ winner Jamal Roberts calls out Carrie Underwood’s genre bias: 'She had her favorites'

Jamal Roberts weighed in on Carrie Underwood’s judging style, suggesting she wasn’t supportive of all contestants and didn’t connect with every genre
PUBLISHED JUN 13, 2025
Jamal Roberts has responded to rising online buzz about Carrie Underwood’s judging behavior (American Idol/YouTube)
Jamal Roberts has responded to rising online buzz about Carrie Underwood’s judging behavior (American Idol/YouTube)

NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK: ‘American Idol’ winner Jamal Roberts is finally speaking out about the buzz surrounding his dynamic with judge Carrie Underwood.

In a recent interview with journalist Nate Vinson, Roberts addressed growing speculation online about Underwood’s behavior during her debut season on the judging panel.

The conversation arose during the BET 45th anniversary dinner, held on Monday, June 9, when Vinson brought up a popular online theory about Underwood’s judging style during her debut season on the show.

Responding to the observation, the 27-year-old singer said, “I don’t think she’s into every genre, to be honest. She had her favorites, and once she picked them, she stood by them."



 

Jamal Roberts hints at genre bias by judge Carrie Underwood

Roberts shared his thoughts after journalist Nate Vinson highlighted the 'very strong narrative online' about Underwood’s debut as a judge—specifically, that she appeared less supportive of Roberts compared to other contestants.

Roberts responded candidly, “Carrie is a country singer and she likes country music. I mean, I don’t think she likes every genre for real. She had her picks, and she had her choice of who she really liked, and she stuck with it.”

Jamal Roberts 'American Idol' 2025. (Cover Image Source: Instagram| American Idol)
Jamal Roberts in 'American Idol' 2025 (Instagram/American Idol)

He went on to add, “We applaud her for sticking to her roots and sticking to who she liked, but I feel like the better person won.”

The 23rd season of 'American Idol' came to a close on Sunday, May 18, with fans thrilled to see Roberts take home the crown. John Foster finished as the runner-up while Breanna Nix was eliminated halfway through the finale and finished in third place. 

A still of John Foster, Breanna Nix and Jamal Roberts from 'American Idol' Season 23 (Cover Image Source: Instagram | @americanidol)
A still of John Foster, Breanna Nix and Jamal Roberts from 'American Idol' Season 23 (Instgram/@americanidol)

 Carrie Underwood’s reaction to Jamal Roberts' win raises eyebrows

The singer drew plenty of attention during the season finale —not for her judging, but for her reaction to Roberts' win.

Carrie Underwood in a screenshot from 'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)
Carrie Underwood in a screenshot from 'American Idol' (YouTube / American Idol)

While fans celebrated his victory, many took to social media to call out what they saw as Underwood's lack of enthusiasm at the moment. When Roberts was announced as the winner after the three-hour finale, all three judges—Carrie Underwood, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan—initially gave him a standing ovation.

Luke Bryan, Carrie Underwood and Lionel Richie in a screenshot from 'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)
Luke Bryan, Carrie Underwood and Lionel Richie in a screenshot from 'American Idol' (YouTube / American Idol)

However, as the winner began performing Anthony Hamilton’s 'Her Heart' as his final song, viewers noticed Underwood taking her seat while the other two judges continued standing in support.

Viewers were quick to criticize the moment, slamming the judge for what they described as an 'evil' reaction and accusing her of looking noticeably displeased when the winner was announced.

Carrie Underwood praises Jamal Roberts despite past tension

During the 'Idol' audition, Underwood encouraged Roberts to 'loosen up' and find his 'swagger'—offering what many saw as constructive guidance. Despite facing some criticism from fans over her judging style, Underwood was quick to celebrate Roberts' May 18 victory with a heartfelt Instagram message.


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Carrie Underwood (@carrieunderwood)


 

“Congratulations to the newest winner of @americanidol!!! I’m so proud of @officialjamalroberts and all he has accomplished this season and I can’t wait to see what mountains he climbs next! He’s going to do great things!” she wrote.

The singer won 'American Idol' in 2005 during the show’s fourth season. Her victory launched a massively successful country music career. Since her win, she has earned multiple Grammy Awards, sold over 70 million records worldwide, and solidified her status as a country music powerhouse.

MORE STORIES

The post Khloe Kardashian liked featured Charlie Kirk speaking with a fan at an event about his devout Christian faith
Sep 13, 2025
Whitney Cummings sparked widespread outrage after posting a controversial tweet about the killing of conservative activist Charlie Kirk
Sep 13, 2025
Prince Harry was spotted entering King Charles’s London residence, months after saying his father had ignored his calls
Sep 11, 2025
Rosie O'Donnell said Ellen DeGeneres’ friendship denial hurt so much she printed T-shirts for her staff reading, 'I don’t know Rosie, we’re not friends'
Sep 10, 2025
A post alleged that Karoline Leavitt called Patti LaBelle 'just a singer,' leading LaBelle to deliver a seven-word response that froze the studio
Sep 10, 2025
Jennifer Lopez feels free channeling emotions into music, but Ben Affleck is embarrassed and sees it as crossing a line, according to the source
Sep 9, 2025
Howard Stern added that he missed last week’s show due to illness, not contract talks, and addressed rumors of being fired from his own show
Sep 9, 2025
Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce’s engagement in August 2025 triggered a wave of pregnancy chatter after an ultrasound photo went viral
Sep 9, 2025
Ed Sheeran, 34, revealed that he was leaving Suffolk with his wife Cherry Seaborn and their two daughters, Lyra and Jupiter
Sep 9, 2025
From Ice Spice’s chaotic corset to Paris Hilton’s flame dress, see the celebs who landed on the worst-dressed list at the 2025 VMAs
Sep 8, 2025