Carrie Underwood slammed as she appears 'unhappy' after Jamal Roberts won ‘American Idol’ Season 23

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: ‘American Idol’ season 23 ended on Sunday, May 18, with Jamal Roberts becoming the winner.
However, it was Carrie Underwood's reaction that received a lot of attention online, the Daily Mail reported.
Carrie Underwood sat down while Jamal Roberts sang his last song
This young black man lost his mom who raised him, lost his grandmother, FATHER not around and still made it! PE Teacher, raising daughters on his own! LORD JESUS cover him! THIS IS A GIFT FROM GOD NOT A TALENT! Vote NOW! #JamalRoberts #AmericanIdolpic.twitter.com/RJCH2qBs1u
— Controversial KikiVonyee (@kikivonye) April 21, 2025
The finale was between three singers—Breanna Nix, John Foster, and Roberts—who all performed with some guest voices like Season 23 mentor Jelly Roll, Jessica Simpson, Salt-N-Pepa, Goo Goo Dolls, Josh Groban, and Patti LaBelle.
View this post on Instagram
At the end of the three-hour show, Roberts was announced the winner of the singing competition, and all three judges — Underwood as well as Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan gave him a standing ovation.

However, when the winner began singing Anthony Hamilton's ‘Her Heart’ as his last song on the show, the 42-year-old judge took a seat while her fellow judges remained standing. This angered some viewers online.
Not Carrie Underwood sitting down and probably being told to stand up when Jamal won 🙄 #AmericanIdol pic.twitter.com/CCQbLBnmS9
— Shay💋 (@sunshine0nme) May 19, 2025
Some even pointed out Underwood's "evil" reaction and said that she did not look happy when Roberts was announced as the winner of the show.
View this post on Instagram
Netizens accuse Carrie Underwood of not being happy after Jamal Roberts won 'American Idol' Season 23

Many viewers took offence at Carrie Underwood’s expression and gesture after Jamal Roberts won.
One X user wrote, “I know Carrie Underwood is big mad. Congrats, Jamal!!!!”
“I bet Carrie Underwood is pissed! Lol...Please Lord let this be her LAST season! 🙏🙏🙏🙏” one person wrote.
I bet Carrie Underwood is pissed! Lol...Please Lord let this be her LAST season! 🙏🙏🙏🙏
— narp70 (@narp70) May 19, 2025
Sharing a GIF, another said, “Carrie Underwood’s face when Jamal won! #AmericanIdol.”
Carrie Underwood’s face when Jamal won! #AmericanIdol pic.twitter.com/a0yl2d8n99
— J.Cannon (@JCannon601) May 19, 2025
One individual stated, “I don't think Carrie Underwood was too happy he won lol.”
I don't think Carrie Underwood was to happy he won lol
— EmmittTheeBeast (@EmmittTheeBeast) May 19, 2025
Another wrote, “Carrie had a lot to say about Jamal Roberts… now look who’s holding the crown. Mississippi stays producing greatness. We don’t talk—we win. Built different, baby. #AmericanIdol #jamalroberts #Mississippi.”
Carrie had a lot to say about Jamal Roberts… now look who’s holding the crown. Mississippi stays producing greatness. We don’t talk—we win. Built different, baby. #AmericanIdol #jamalroberts #Mississippi
— Courtney Pernell (@Baker27Courtney) May 19, 2025
Posting a meme, an individual remarked, “Me watching Carrie Underwood hating self when Jamal won American Idol 😂 #americanidolfinale #AmericanIdol.”
me watching Carrie Underwood hating self when Jamal won American Idol 😂 #americanidolfinale #AmericanIdol pic.twitter.com/sHf73hBY4q
— Cloud9ineDreams💫 (@Cloud9ineDreams) May 19, 2025
Another shared, "Carri didn’t seem too excited about the winner of America’s idol! It gives prejudice. 💯 I’m soooooo happy Jamal won!!! Bring back my girl katie!!! #americanidolfinale #AmericanIdol."
Carri didn’t seem too excited about the winner of America’s idol! It gives prejudice. 💯 I’m soooooo happy Jamal won!!! Bring back my girl katie!!! #americanidolfinale #AmericanIdol pic.twitter.com/eeWZ11bkGt
— Bri Chant’e (@Bri_TheAKA) May 19, 2025
One netizen asked, "Why is Carrie Underwood looking so evil at Jamal @americanidol
she needs to be removed this unprofessional #AmericanIdol."
Why is Carrie Underwood looking so evil at Jamal @americanidol she needs to be removed this unprofessional #AmericanIdol pic.twitter.com/aK1SKdhMFs
— Trey Jones (@handsomeface345) May 13, 2025
Who is Jamal Roberts?
Jamal Roberts from Meridian, Mississippi, was crowned the winner of the latest season of ‘American Idol’.
View this post on Instagram
He is 27 years old and works as an elementary school teacher. He beat Foster after Nix got the fewest number of votes.
Roberts has now become the second Black man to win ‘American Idol’, 22 years after Ruben Studdard won the show in 2003.
"I'm anointed. I know how to use it. I know how to tap in," the winner told Gold Derby on the red carpet following his victory, as per Yahoo.
This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support online claims or opinions.